Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

The two combatants should be at least as close as Obi Wan and Dooku, though I guess that's a pretty big gap. What's the weakest that could take a majority against a non-jobbing Luke?

1. RotJ
2. DE
3. NJO (beginning)
4. TUF
5 DN
6 LotF

1. Arcann and Dooku
2. Kun and Droma
3. Rots Anakin and Yoda
4. DE Sidious and Valkorion
5. Zonama Sekot and Yuuzhan'tar
6. The Son and Daughter

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
1. Arcann and Dooku
2. Kun and Droma
3. Rots Anakin and Yoda
4. DE Sidious and Valkorion
5. Zonama Sekot and Yuuzhan'tar
6. The Son and Daughter

Pretty much, not sure about the Son though

IMHO:

1. Obi Wan and Ventress
2. Anakin and Dooku (maybe)
3. Plagueis and Starkiller
4. Caedus and Krayt (maybe)
5. RotJ Sidious and Vader (maybe)

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Pretty much, not sure about the Son though

Glad you agree

Obi-Wan could solo RotJ Luke, honestly. Being generous to Luke, he would have surpassed Obi-Wan during the late NR-period, or the years leading up to DE. For RotJ Luke, a team like Kit Fisto + Saesee Tiin is likely to be more than enough.

The others are also way hyper-inflated. Especially DE and early NJO.

RotJ Luke was a match for Vader in their duel, speculation about the latter underperforming notwithstanding. DE Luke has grown for six years, impressed DE Sidious, taken down AT-ATs, piloted the Falcon using only the Force, etc. Early NJO Luke has already gotten his Black Fleet Crisis feats.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Obi-Wan could solo RotJ Luke, honestly. Being generous to Luke, he would have surpassed Obi-Wan during the late NR-period, or the years leading up to DE. For RotJ Luke, a team like Kit Fisto + Saesee Tiin is likely to be more than enough.

The others are also way hyper-inflated. Especially DE and early NJO.

Why Kit Fisto AND Saesee Tiin. If you reckon Obi could solo, then Fisto can too.

I still suspect that Luke's combat prowess fell off in the relatively peaceful years preceding the Vong War, where he picked up again. That said, I understand it's not an incredibly popular opinion, so I'll let it slide.

He's impressed DE Sidious, but that's a double edged sword; Sidious also implies that Luke is either still inferior to Vader, or not that far ahead of him right before their duel.

@bingbang No, I meant Obi-Wan, not Fisto.

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Why Kit Fisto AND Saesee Tiin. If you reckon Obi could solo, then Fisto can too.

http://gif-finder.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Steve-Carell-Facepalm.gif

Not this shit again.

Originally posted by ares834
http://gif-finder.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Steve-Carell-Facepalm.gif

Not this shit again.

Lol sorry I'll stop

He was having issues with Lady Rhea and Vestara Khai in FOTJ. At his best I can see him beating maybe a Kenobi tier duelist and another, but fighting someone like Caedus/Windu and hes done

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
1. Arcann and Dooku

RotJ Luke could never beat Arcann and Dooku together.

Originally posted by carthage
He was having issues with Lady Rhea and Vestara Khai in FOTJ. At his best I can see him beating maybe a Kenobi tier duelist and another, but fighting someone like Caedus/Windu and hes done

Lol

(For those who don't know he's trolling, Luke was near death when he did that)

Originally posted by Nephthys
RotJ Luke could never beat Arcann and Dooku together.

If he's seriously a RotJ Vader tier duelist, he potentially could depending on how powerful he is in refined Force ability.

Originally posted by Nephthys
RotJ Luke could never beat Arcann and Dooku together.

You should probably read the rest of my list, then proceed to realize that I'm joking.

Reading is for nerds.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
If he's seriously a RotJ Vader tier duelist, he potentially could depending on how powerful he is in refined Force ability.

No he couldn't.

ROTJ Luke has an infinitely better chance at taking ****ing Valkorion than LOTF Luke does at taking the Son and Daughter at the same time lol

There's a chance that on Mortis Luke could replicate what Anakin did, but yeah.