Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Two incredibly formidable ancient Sith square up against the mightiest of the Banite Line. Who emerges victorious? Fight takes place on flat, neutral terrain.

If team wins, give Sidious SOD Maul.

If Sidious wins, give team Naga Sadow.

Sidious wins. His feats are significantly better, his powerscaling-hype-thematic placement is far superior, and he's just a better combatant. They may try sorcery but Sidious is hardly unfamiliar with that and really, his lightning is more powerful than their spells anyway.

With Naga Sadow it's closer, but honestly Sidious still wins as long as he can dodge his bricks without losing his focus.

Sidious after killing Plagueis was probably the most powerful Sith Lord in history. Muur and Nadd should still be comparable, but I don't know if they'd win. With Sadow, they certainly win, though.

SoD Maul's presence turns that around.

Oh, good point; is this pre or post Plagueis death Sidious? Post death is solidly above any sith that has ever come before him.