Force mastery, Force augmentation and raw power

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



The Ellimist
Although there's obviously a correlation, there does seem to be a difference in combatants' ranking with respect to their telekinesis/etc., and their ability to augment their physicals/enhance their precog in a duel. For example, Dooku has better telekinesis feats than Anakin, but Anakin is so powerful that he can destroy Tyranus in a duel when he really tries. I doubt this is because of Anakin's muscles - Dooku can easily beat Grievous. So why the distinction?

My theory is that Force augmentation more reflects your raw power, which correlates with potential more than your refined mastery of telekinesis and other techniques. That's why Anakin would stand a much better chance against Sidious in a duel than a Force fight, even though the Force is the primary determinant in both.

What does KMC think?

EDIT: also, how would this tie into your Force defenses?

ILS
It just depends on what Force abilities are trained extensively as well as a bit of natural talent. There are raw power expressions in both (a Force scream for example), just like there are expressions of mastery.

The Ellimist
I guess the counter-example is Galen Marek, who from his potential should make Vader and Shaak Ti cry. But maybe his technical skill, while good by normal standards, is still far below that of Skywalker and Shaak.

@ILS yeah good point.

Syndicate
Generally agree.

The Ellimist
Rastka Lsu is a weird case. If she really were that weak in the Force, all of the technical skill in the world shouldn't have let her compete with Bane; heck PoD Bane was beating back Kas'im on similar premises, and Kas'im wasn't weak (by the standards of the day).

Syndicate
Personally I think you can train certain areas better then others and Raskta just focused on augmentation and precog over stuff like TK.

Similarly to how Vitiate trained his more esoteric powers over basic precog/augmentation.

The Ellimist
I wonder how that relates to Force defenses. Lsu was weak to TK, but presumably Anakin's defenses were pretty good or Dooku would've just ragdolled him.

Syndicate
Anakin's a very balanced individual who likely put augmentation above his other powers but still maintained a healthy growth in other areas.

FreshestSlice
Originally posted by The Ellimist
Rastka Lsu is a weird case. If she really were that weak in the Force, all of the technical skill in the world shouldn't have let her compete with Bane; heck PoD Bane was beating back Kas'im on similar premises, and Kas'im wasn't weak (by the standards of the day).
Do you not know what Battle Meditation is?

The Ellimist
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Do you not know what Battle Meditation is?

Even with battle meditation, she was still weak enough that others had to reach out to protect her from Bane's telekinesis. Pay attention. thumb up

FreshestSlice
Her shields have nothing to do with her combat ability. So, no, not really. Lsu was never supposed to be weak, just not focused on the more esoteric abilities of her career. Battle Meditation easily covers the gap as it makes you stronger and the opponent weaker. It's really not that hard.

NewGuy01
In general, natural strength is an underrated factor. Even putting that aside, having greater force reserves still wouldn't necessarily guarantee you will be faster or stronger.

Kurk
Originally posted by NewGuy01
In general, natural strength is an underrated factor. Even putting that aside, having greater force reserves still wouldn't necessarily guarantee you will be faster or stronger.
True. Anakin's youth was to an extent advantageous over the old man Dooku.

FreshestSlice
Not as much as him just being better in all relevant ways.

The Ellimist
It's explicitly stated that Lsu was relatively weak in the Force, not just that she didn't have good TK defenses. Even with her BM this was still true in relation to Bane.

If physical strength were that meaningful, Windu would've broken Palpatine's hands as their augmentation was balanced.

Deronn_solo
Originally posted by Kurk
True. Anakin's youth was to an extent advantageous over the old man Dooku.

Must everything come back to Dooku with you?

Kurk
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Must everything come back to Dooku with you?
Yes.

The Ellimist
Kurk who do you think would win in a fight, Bruce Lee or Dooku without the Force?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.