Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

*Atris is bloodlusted and has her morales off

Warmup: Darth Malgus

1. Arcann
2. ROTS Obi wan Kenobi
3. Mace Windu
4. ROTS Anakin Skywalker
5. Yoda
6. FOTJ Luke Skywalker

Where does she stop

Mace is above Anakin.

Is that why Windu muses Skywalker might be more powerful than Yoda?

Atris can't beat anybody here.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Is that why Windu muses Skywalker might be more powerful than Yoda?

Eh while true at this point Mace should be above Skywalker due to technical refinement.

But Ant is still right :shrug:

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Is that why Windu muses Skywalker might be more powerful than Yoda?

He's probably talking in the context of sabers, not power.

Yeah, literally nothing implies that. Not that it matters in the context of this thread--Ant would still be right.

Warmup: Darth Malgus - wins 0/10

1. Arcann - wins 0/10
2. ROTS Obi wan Kenobi - wins 0/10
3. Mace Windu - wins 0/10, stomp
4. ROTS Anakin Skywalker - wins 0/10, stomp
5. Yoda - wins 0/10, ultra stomp
6. FOTJ Luke Skywalker - wins 0/10, ultra stomp

Yeah, this time it was a bad thread Carthage xD

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Yeah, literally nothing implies that. Not that it matters in the context of this thread--Ant would still be right.

He likely is referring to potential and that's innately implied given the disparity between Yoda and Anakin by this point.

No, he's not referring to potential, because he then states "and he is still getting stronger."

Well then unfortunately that makes Mace's statement flat out wrong considering Yoda disarmed Sidious while Anakin had trouble even perceiving him.

Also not true. The text made note that while Skywalker couldn't see Palpatine with his eyes, he could follow him through the Force, which is how powerful Force-sensitives fight anyway. Windu himself only saw Palpatine as a "blur" during the fight, but still managed to best him anyway, further rendering your point useless.

Seeing someone as a blur is a higher level of perception then perceiving someone to be moving in and out of existence. While I'm sure Anakin could react against a few strikes from Sidious similar to Fisto he'd be overwhelmed in short order.

Also Sidious allowed Mace to best him making your point invalid.

The text associates Skywalker's physical tracking of them also as a "blur of speed," too.

Before or after the text states them to be moving in and out of existence? The fight was ramping up continually until the point Sidious allowed himself to be disarmed which is why that's relevant.

Alright, going to the beach. Respond tomorrow or this evening.

After the "moving in and out of existence," but prior to the narrator's change to the perspective of Windu.

If it's Windu's perspective then it's not Anakin percieving them.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
After the "moving in and out of existence," but prior to the narrator's change to the perspective of Windu.
...

Ah.

Quote?

Goes down at warm-up, of course.

Fair. Alright then that must mean you think Grievous is Sidious level in speed.

Grievous was able to break through Kenobi's defenses with the speed of his assault

Kenobi has a better defense then Anakin.

Therefore if Sidious couldn't break through Anakin's defenses with the speed of his assault Grievous should logically be faster then Sidious.

That the stance you're taking here?

Skywalker's an offensive fighter, not defensive. Your string of exaggerations and weakly-connected comparisons don't hold up to reality.

So you're telling me that Anakin would press such a powerful offensive advantage against Sidious the speed disparity between them wouldn't come into play? :/

Alright then, if that's what you want to believe.

I'll be at the beach. Enjoy your fantasies.

What speed disparity? A *strict* duel between the two would feature two of the greatest offensive warriors in Star Wars, and while Palpatine might come out on top, it wouldn't be easy.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
What speed disparity? A *strict* duel between the two would feature two of the greatest offensive warriors in Star Wars, and while Palpatine might come out on top, it wouldn't be easy.

cod