Darth Malak vs Jedi Exile

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



SunRazer
Time for another one of these.

Prime versions. Standard equipment.

a. Neutral ground, morals off.

b. Star Forge, morals on.

1. Sabers

2. Force

3. All-out

MythLord
Surik maybe, probably, dunno.

chingchangwalla
Malak

Nephthys
Prime Exile could recreate Revan's Star Forge feat, imo.

Emperordmb
Exile prolly loses against regular Malak... gets raped by SF Malak

Nephthys
Lol. Yeah, the Exile who beat a Traya who stomped nearly 20 Sith at once, while weakened with Traya amped..... gets stomped by a Malak who choked 2 whole Jedi.

chingchangwalla
**** yourself Neph, Meetra's boring

Nephthys
At least Meetra can go down on you. What's Malak got? He's got ****ing nothing, thats what. Boom I win.

red8
The Exile in a good fight.

darthbane77
Malak should take this, without SF amp it'll be a good fight; with the amp Malak takes it with little to moderate difficulty.

Ursumeles
Bump

SF Malak wins probably all rounds, regular Malak should lose Force, win Sabers and I am not sure about All-Out.

Ursumeles
Bump

I meant win Force, lose Sabers btw, lol.

Deronn_solo
Originally posted by Nephthys
Prime Exile could recreate Revan's Star Forge feat, imo.

Ehh....

DarthAnt66
Malak dominates.

Geistalt
Meetra might take 1. Aside from that...


Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Malak
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Malak dominates.

AncientPower
Lmfao Meetra sweeps.

Nephthys
Originally posted by Nephthys
Lol. Yeah, the Exile who beat a Traya who stomped nearly 20 Sith at once, while weakened with Traya amped..... gets stomped by a Malak who choked 2 whole Jedi.

TenebrousWay
Surik, probably in a)

Malak in b)

AncientPower
There's no way Malak is defeating Meetra in terms of the Force when she's confirmed to become more powerful than Traya in the years proceeding KOTOR2.

Nephthys
Huh?

SunRazer
She means the years after.

Nephthys
Yeah but I thought it was commonly accepted that Meetra became complete trash the second Kotor 2 ended.

SunRazer
No. She became trash the second Drew started writing her.

AncientPower
It isn't generally accepted, but people like to think Dromund Kaas is the equivalent of Dantooine for some reason.

Two powerful dark side sites and the Emperor's experiments, all of which only came after Dromund Kaas already being powerful enough to draw the Emperor to it, specifically over other hidden Sith worlds(like Oricon and pre-MSG Malachor V for example). Says a lot that four thousand years later, when the dark temple is a ruin and the Sith influence is gone (namely the Emperor's), we still have it giving Kyle Katarn, Jaina Solo, Mara Jade and Luke Skywalker everything between full dark side corruption, the inability to feel the Force, and a major hindrance on their reflexive abilities.

The Exile > Traya occurs some time in the years between Malachor V and her trip to Nathema, that is a fact. We know she spends years growing as the leader of the Jedi Order. Both Sion and Traya confirm it happens, and furthermore we know she was at least contending with Traya in the force during their fight. Remove the Trayus Core and the hell Meetra sustained getting to her, and we have a very clear picture of the Exile becoming more powerful than Traya.

Yes, Exile > Traya is a thing.

Nephthys
Not this again. Dromund Kaas was way less powerful than Malachor. Nobody's buying that it crippled her to half strength.

AncientPower
Source? All I'm seeing is another non-argument.

Nephthys
A non-argument only needs a non-argument in response. Malachor was corrupting anything that walked upon it and was a veritable bastion of the darkside. Kaas had a planetary population walking around it with no ill effects. Meetra merely notes the dark sides presence and doesn't mention feeling weaker. By contrast she notes how horrific Malachor was and all the other information on it supports it being immensely debilitating.

At no point is it so much as slightly hinted that Kaas significantly weakened Meetra. It's just a load of bullshit you invented to make your fav not embarrassingly shit.

AncientPower
Lmfao.

>Ignores all NJO Jedi being hindered/corrupted/severed by a weaker Kaas.
>Ignores Scourge confirming the citadel is a dark side nexus.
>Ignores Revan confirming even his powers are hindered.
>Ignores Meetra being incapable of even meditating.

And I'm the one in denial. laughing out loud

It isn't even about Kaas >/~ Malachor V, that is so far beyond the point in question that you may as well be debating DBZ for all the relevance it has.

UCanShootMyNova
Not sure. Both are trash.

Time-Immemorial
Originally posted by Nephthys
Huh?

You seem confused a lot.

cs_zoltan
Damn it man, control your menses.

carthage
Malak pretty easily

Trocity
Meetra kind of sucks and Malak is pretty underrated.

He sweeps.

AncientPower
Originally posted by AncientPower
Lmfao Meetra sweeps.

Geistalt
Originally posted by SunRazer
No. She became trash the second Drew started writing her. That's not the (only) reason she loses, tho.

carthage
She got trashed by Nyriss, she isn't cut out for fighting high tiers

AncientPower
Head canon is fun.

carthage
Its not head canon when she got stomped.

Keep backtracking though

Trocity
She only got stomped because Nyriss attacked her before she was ready and put her on the back foot immediately, duh.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.