Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Melinda as of season 3 of Agents of Shield
*Black Widow as of Civil War

H2H only

No Agents of Shield fans

I'll bite. At this point I have to give it to May.

Strictly h2h it comes down to who has more feats to pull from which May has in spades. It doesn't help that Widow has remained mostly constant across 5 movies in terms of h2h ability.

Widow wins. Has beaten better competition.

Originally posted by tkitna
Widow wins. Has beaten better competition.

Have to give it to Widow. Feats she's superior, even cartoonish at times.

Also iirc, May is said to be second to Widow in AoS.

Originally posted by Robtard
Have to give it to Widow. Feats she's superior, even cartoonish at times.

Also iirc, May is said to be second to Widow in AoS.

I believe she was referred to as second to Widow as a spy, not as a fighter.

H2H Widow and May have done pretty much the same things: May event has her own version of the stupid chair scene.

IIRC, May was able to hang for some time with a bloke who had Asgardian-heightened strength. That puts her above BW in terms of opponent difficulty.

Black Widow wins...

Natasha is the s3xier of the two (May does look nice when she wants to though)...