Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Was their comic fight about right, or no?

Who wins?

This is a case where the in-comic encounter was as definitive as we're likely to get. No need to try to interpret beyond its outcome.

Midnighter doors his opponent into space.

Originally posted by carver9
Midnighter doors his opponent into space.

I see what you're doing here.

Originally posted by cdtm
I see what you're doing here.

their fight was WITHOUT weapons, pure h2h. In THIS battle, without PIS, Carver is 100% correct.

With the Carrier, sure. But their comic fight did eventually include weapons. I stand by my opinion.

Originally posted by Digi
With the Carrier, sure. But their comic fight did eventually include weapons. I stand by my opinion.

I know you hate having the Carrier in street level fights, lol.

It's idiotic. It's Cap V. Batman, but one of them gets mjolnir. If the OP wants to clarify, that's fine. Otherwise, it defeats any reason for a debate to include it.

Originally posted by Digi
It's idiotic. It's Cap V. Batman, but one of them gets mjolnir. If the OP wants to clarify, that's fine. Otherwise, it defeats any reason for a debate to include it.

Originally posted by Digi
It's idiotic. It's Cap V. Batman, but one of them gets mjolnir. If the OP wants to clarify, that's fine. Otherwise, it defeats any reason for a debate to include it.

Originally posted by Digi
It's idiotic. It's Cap V. Batman, but one of them gets mjolnir. If the OP wants to clarify, that's fine. Otherwise, it defeats any reason for a debate to include it.



It's cheap debating.

Cheap, yes.

This is Midnighter. Known for using cheap ass tactics if he can.

If OP doesn't have them off, then its on. Simple as.

Not hard to grasp.

I'm not disagreeing. He does shit like that regularly. But like, why does this thread exist if we're including it? Common sense dictates we remove it for the sake of argument.

/Srug

Because cdtm is obviously an idiot, and I hate him

Originally posted by Digi
I'm not disagreeing. He does shit like that regularly. But like, why does this thread exist if we're including it? Common sense dictates we remove it for the sake of argument.

/Srug
Again i must

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Because cdtm is obviously an idiot, and I hate him

See, this I can get behind.

Iron Fist beats them both. And sinks the damned Carrier.

Originally posted by Digi
I'm not disagreeing. He does shit like that regularly. But like, why does this thread exist if we're including it? Common sense dictates we remove it for the sake of argument.

/Srug