Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Fight takes place in the prison yard. Pure H2H.

- Fisk, as we see him in s2 of Daredevil.
- Luke, as we see him in Seagate, before he gets his powers.

Both opponents are bloodlusted. Who wins?

Fisk likely wins. He's durable as shit and stronger than Carl too. Can't see Fisk getting jumped by Juice and his friend like Carl did

Not sure, this might be really close. Luke was a beast in those prison fights and Fisk won't have his armoured suit to protect him. Might come down to how much space they have. In a small cell Fisk might be able to use his size to smother Luke's attacks and overwhelm him, but in a ring where Luke has space to manoeuvre he might be able to use his skills to target Fisk's joints and use strikes, locks and holds to wear Fisk down.

Well, I made the fight in the prison yard.

In the prison yard I'll tentatively give the advantage to Luke based on my reasoning above, but I'm open to counter-arguments because I think it will be really close. It's actually quite a good catch-up.

Fisk gave Matt a solid fight immediately after surviving a car crash. He shrugged off a taser, and was strong enough to hoist a heavily-armoured man right over his head. Not only that, but this was a Fisk who didn't spend most of his free time exercising in a prison yard.

Yeah, Cage won some fights, but he was also beaten half to death by two street thugs the moment they intended to hurt him. Does anyone here actually think that those two would have any hope of bringing down Fisk, or giving Matt half as good a fight as he did?

This match isn't close. Fisk wins it decisively.

Shades and Comanche had weapons. I don't think Fisk would have just tanked getting clocked in the head and ribs over and over with a steel plate knuckle duster.

I actually just rewatched the fight between Fisk and Matt, and I am not so sure this match is a good idea anymore. Fisk actually took like 5 billy club strikes right to the head in rapid succession, and they barely slowed him down.

From about 1:45.

dbfLhW0q5EI

This is a mismatch.