Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

*ROTJ Luke
*Novel Revan
*KOTOR 2 Meetra

Force sabers all out

Who wins

Team 1 sweeps.

Team 2 murders

Team 2, but it's very close

Originally posted by JKBart
Team 2 murders

Team 1 in all.

Originally posted by Tondemonai
Team 2, but it's very close

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Team 1 sweeps.

Team 1, mainly due to 'Killer and Vader.

i think Carthage unwittingly made a decent fight.

Nah, Meetra's the weak link and Nyriss is outmatched.

Well I'm separating KOTOR 2 from the rest of the continuity for the purposes of this thread.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Nah, Meetra's the weak link and Nyriss is outmatched.
KoTOR II Exile > Nyriss

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Well I'm separating KOTOR 2 from the rest of the continuity for the purposes of this thread.

You're alright Skillz.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
KoTOR II Exile > Nyriss

You're adorable.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
KoTOR II Exile > Nyriss

I like u, Skillz

Even though I'm a despicable bastard that has DE Sidious > Valkorion >/= ROTJ Sidious > SWTOR Vitiate >/= ROTS Sidious > Plagueis ~ Novel Vitiate?

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Even though I'm a despicable bastard that has DE Sidious > Valkorion >/= ROTJ Sidious > SWTOR Vitiate >/= ROTS Sidious > Plagueis ~ Novel Vitiate?
Make RotS Sidious >/= SWTOR Vitate, and Plagueis > Novel Vitate, then u are okay
I also like Ant, and he prolly thinks the same

Ant has....

........................

Novel Revan ~ Novel Vitiate ~ ROTS Sidious.

...

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Ant has....

........................

Cancer. Brain cancer.

I'm on the extreme end of there being almost no overlap between the major incarnations of Sidious and Vitiate: DE > RotJ > RotS > EoTPM > Plagueis >= TPM ~ Valkorion > TOR >= Caedus ~ Krayt > novel > Nihilus > Revan ~ Vader >= Kun > Galen Marek > Dooku ~ Ragnos.

^Caedus needs to drop. Straight to hell.

I mean, to be fair, I would put him among the top 5 lightsaber combatants in the mythos.

@Ellimist
Disagree with Ragnos being so low, and maybe Kun's placement.
Aside from that

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
^Caedus needs to drop. Straight to hell.

Oops, I started mixing combative and just Force rankings.

Phuck you.

Fug*

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
^Caedus needs to drop. Straight to hell.
I hate you.

In terms of pure force, he's not above Novel.

As you have Novitate~Plaggy, neither is Krayt.

Novel~Plaggy>/=Krayt>/=Caedus in pure force

Convince me of Caedus' greatness if you feel the need to do so.

Skillz you have Vitiate ~ Plagueis?

I mean. I don't have them too far apart but I feel like Plagueis and Sidious unbalancing the Force is ambiguous enough when compared to Vitiate's feats to take the blurb seriously. How do you see it?

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ


Novel~Plaggy>/=Krayt>/=Caedus in pure force

Convince me of Caedus' greatness if you feel the need to do so.
<|= Krayt is where I place him, lol.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Skillz you have Vitiate ~ Plagueis?

I mean. I don't have them too far apart but I feel like Plagueis and Sidious unbalancing the Force is ambiguous enough when compared to Vitiate's feats to take the blurb seriously. How do you see it?

I am also in agreement to it being ambiguous in that we don't know how impressive it makes them. "More impressive than Vitiate" doesn't suffice as an accurate quantification, imo.

But I think arguments can be made for Plagueis > Novel Vitiate that don't require the imbalance feat.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
<|= Krayt is where I place him, lol.

Good. We are in concert.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I am also in agreement to it being ambiguous in that we don't know how impressive it makes them. "More impressive than Vitiate" doesn't suffice as an accurate quantification, imo.

But I think arguments can be made for Plagueis > Novel Vitiate that don't require the imbalance feat.

I mean, fair enough. I hold the stance that blurbs and statements should only be taken when supported by feats or when the issue is clouded that they can be used to clear it up. I.E. Vitiate > Nihilus. Plagueis > Vitiate. Caedus > Vader. etc.

Obviously stuff like Revan > Nihilus or Bane > Exar Kun is idiotic.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Ant has....

........................

Novel Revan ~ Novel Vitiate ~ ROTS Sidious. I don;t actually think that's where he ranks them. Pretty sure he still ranks Plagueis above prime Revan actually (for some stupid ****ing reason, no disrespect to him.)

I see it more as ROTS Sidious>Novel Vitiate (my a slim-ish margin)>Novel Revan (by an equally slim margin.)