Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Versions
* Luke as of the Black Fleet Trilogy
* Yoda as of Revenge of the Sith

Rules:
* In character, but serious
* Fight takes Place on Byss, no Nexus
* Starting distance: 15m

1. Sabers and Melee only

2. Force only

3. All-Out

Luke didn't surpass Yoda in anything until late NJO for me; the green guy sweeps.

1. Honestly, Luke has a shot, but Yoda still wins for a majority; anything from 7/10 to 10/10.
2. Yoda, no contest. 10/10 for Yoda, even though Luke will obviously give him an incredible fight.
3. Just like sabers goes.

Luke takes sabers and splits all-out, IMHO.

Yoda wins all.

Yoda in all; Luke doesn't surpass him till a decade or so later, sometime during the YV war imo.

The green midget sweeps, in a great fight.

If Luke by Dark Empire is already more powerful than Vader, and his saber skills were matching Vader's by RotJ, it seems likely that he's surpassed Yoda in sabers by BFT. Not sure about the Force.

Luke had already surpassed Yoda by DE. BFT will only make his victory surer.

Originally posted by Azronger
Luke had already surpassed Yoda by DE.

http://replygif.net/i/750.gif

I'm surprised he didn't say ROTJ Luke > Yoda.

Originally posted by Trocity
http://replygif.net/i/750.gif

Hmm? In DE, Luke defeats an opponent superior to Yoda in a duel.

Anyway...

Luke takes saber, Yoda likely takes Force, and slight edge to Luke in all out.

When he's amped by Leia...

Nope. Leia doesn't amp him until after the duel as noted in the audio drama.

Can anyone verify this?

Also doesn't the comic have her amping him beforehand putting the audio drama to the side for now?

Nope. The comic doesn't make it clear either way. Yes, she does appear to be glowing but that could just as easily be due to the art style as other characters seem to glow at different times as well.

As for the audio drama.

I thought there was a case where Luke asked for Leia's help and she said she "already was".

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I'm surprised he didn't say ROTJ Luke > Yoda.

Is being condescending the only thing you can do? I've offered a 1v1 multiple times now, but you always remain silent. If you're so confident that you're right and I'm wrong then how about you prove it.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
I thought there was a case where Luke asked for Leia's help and she said she "already was".

There is.

Originally posted by Azronger
Is being condescending the only thing you can do? I've offered a 1v1 multiple times now, but you always remain silent. If you're so confident that you're right and I'm wrong then how about you prove it.



Pretty sure I've debated you before. Not here, though.

Originally posted by ares834
There is.

So isn't that evidence that she had been helping him in their duel?

Originally posted by The Ellimist
So isn't that evidence that she had been helping him in their duel?

No, as it's not stated when she joined her power with his. It could have been before the duel or it could have been afterwards. However, the audio drama makes it explicitly clear that it is only afterwards that she does so.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ


Pretty sure I've debated you before. Not here, though.

Where?