Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins?

Plagueis or Krayt.

Most likely Plagueis.

1. Plagueis
2. Caedus/Krayt
3. Krayt/Caedus
4. Revan
5. Exar Kun

I think Revan is more powerful in the force then either Krayt or Caedus, but his saber skills leave a lot to be desired, which is why he can't last long.

His saber skills are Dooku-level at best, if that.

Why is Caedus here?

Hmmm, there's a lot of things to consider here. 1v1 Revan is superior to anybody here, but not by much. He's likely the strongest here in the Force, but Plagueis and Caedus at least are superior swordsman, and are the most comparable in the Force. It comes down to Plagueis, Revan, or Caedus; but I'd have to give it to either Revan or Caedus, I can see one of them winning just as easily as I can see the other winning. It should be noted Plagueis has a shot as well, but I feel his chances are less than Revan's or Caedus'. Lol, I'm probably gonna get crucified for this shit.

Plagueis and Kun completely outclass everyone here

Originally posted by Trocity
Why is Caedusanyone but Plagueis here?

Raw power can't win this alone, I reckon versatility and sustainability are the biggest factors.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Raw power can't win this alone, I reckon versatility and sustainability are the biggest factors. Well, Plagueis knows friggin' everything the Rule of Two had amassed over the course of a thousand years, can seemingly learn powers he has no natural talent for through sheer force of will, and was able to subvert the Force's will in order to practice the most unnatural, heinous power of them all - control of life and death - and used it to achieve self-sustaining immortality and in-combat healing.

That seems to fit the bill.

Plagueis
Krayt
Revan/Kun
Caedus

Originally posted by ILS
Well, Plagueis knows friggin' everything the Rule of Two had amassed over the course of a thousand years, can seemingly learn powers he has no natural talent for through sheer force of will, and was able to subvert the Force's will in order to practice the most unnatural, heinous power of them all - control of life and death - and used it to achieve self-sustaining immortality and in-combat healing.

That seems to fit the bill.

When has Plagueis healed himself mid-combat?

Plagueis => Krayt > Revan > Exar Kun > Darth Caedus

Originally posted by Azronger
When has Plagueis healed himself mid-combat? Sheev noted he was doing so while being fried by lightning on his deathbed. The issue was Sheev's was lightning too powerful to heal against, and Plagueis was drunk and arrogantly trying to heal against the lightning instead of putting up a defence.

Plagueis > Krayt ~/> Caedus ~ Revan >/~ Kun

Plagueis ~ Kun ~ Revan > Krayt > Caedus

Caedus ~ Kun >> Revan > Krayt > Plagueis

^^
That was once the popular held opinion on the forums, lal.

Except, Krayt would be dead last in that regard, kek.

Wasn't Maul > Krayt once a common opinion?

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
^^
That was once the popular held opinion on the forums, lal.

Except, Krayt would be dead last in that regard, kek. The most cancerous it ever was was something like:

Caedus > Plagueis >>> Kun ~ Revan ~ Krayt

Essentially because everyone Silver hadn't yet made a detailed argument for must "not have very good feats" and were quickly relegated to shit-tier.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
Wasn't Maul > Krayt once a common opinion? Yup. Krayt, Kun Revan etc were all sub-Maul tier for a long time.

Yep.

As good as Silver, and XMan was, they set the tone for Krayt lowballing and the we were just mindless puppets on their string.

Ninja'd by Swords.

Originally posted by ILS
Yup. Krayt, Kun Revan etc were all sub-Maul tier for a long time.
I mean...Revan stil, is

Maul > Venamis > Bane > Vitiate > Revan

Originally posted by ILS
Caedus ~ Kun >> Revan > Krayt > Plagueis

It's actually a good rank if you invert it (and reduce the Revan/Kun gap), lmao.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Yep.

As good as Silver, and XMan was, they set the tone for Krayt lowballing and the we were just mindless puppets on their string.

Ninja'd by Swords. When they knew what they were talking about, all was well. But because they were the Star Wars gurus, if they lacked information on a character it wasn't because they didn't have it, it was because that character was shit. Nobody could know more than them.

"Silver, what is Krayt's best feat?"

"IDK, beating Wyyrlok"

"Kay, sub-Kenobi tier it is"

Basically that's how it was back in the day, lmao.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
Wasn't Maul > Krayt once a common opinion?

"Maul is faster, more skilful, stronger, more resilient, more tactically capable, more martially capable, and more powerful (assuming this is TCW Maul). He has just about every edge here."

-ShootingNova, regarding Darth Maul vs Reborn Krayt, from 2 years and 6 months ago

Interestingly enough, in that axed Darth Maul game, the concept they threw together was the following:

-A Darth Maul clone of some kind who made it's way into the Legacy era to fight Darth Krayt and his One Sith

Darth Talon was going to help Maul, or something equally retarded.

Yep:

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_the_Sith_Lords

You f*ckers cannot imagine the fun I would have had with Maul vs Krayt in video game format. I would have raised this forum to the ground.

Originally posted by ILS
You f*ckers cannot imagine the fun I would have had with Maul vs Krayt in video game format. I would have raised this forum to the ground.

Play Jedi Academy with mods. Its one of the funnest games I've ever played.

Watching Ragnos get his shit pushed in by Luke is so fun.

Multiplayer is pretty awesome too.

I know a Krayt model has been created, but not the way you would have liked, and there are tons of Maul models.

Originally posted by ILS
Interestingly enough, in that axed Darth Maul game, the concept they threw together was the following:

-A Darth Maul clone of some kind who made it's way into the Legacy era to fight Darth Krayt and his One Sith

Darth Talon was going to help Maul, or something equally retarded.

And people say TOR is bad. There's always a worse idea.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Play Jedi Academy with mods. Its one of the funnest games I've ever played.

Watching Ragnos get his shit pushed in by Luke is so fun.

Multiplayer is pretty awesome too.

I know a Krayt model has been created, but not the way you would have liked, and there are tons of Maul models. Perhaps. I've heard good things.Originally posted by Nephthys
And people say TOR is bad. There's always a worse idea. Touche. Would have been a cooler game doe.

Plagueis rather easily

Plagueis=Revan=Caedus>Krayt>Kun