Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

DD version of Vos. Thoughts?

dd vos,
TCW Maul vs DD Vos would be a better fight

Maul

Don't know much about Vos, but Maul gets my vote. Dooku called this guys lightsaber technique bad, and I'm pretty sure Maul would give the count a good run for his money.

that was legends vos
In dd, vos was able to beat an injured dooku(blaster wound) despite dooku being able to throw him around with the force and dooku "perhaps" being the more skilled duelist with the aid of a stylistic edge via his unpredictability

TPM Maul isn't taking this.

Fair enough. DD is?

dark desciple

as for tcw maul, vos is the better duelist, though maul *may* be more powerful(ragdolling an amped dd ventress while amped vs ragdolling tcw kenobi while amped)

Rebels maul htough logically should be able to ragdoll the crap out of vos and could have surpassed him as a duelist

Vos stomps

Maul.

Maul, yeah.

TPM Maul per jason fry is the less skilled, and inferior duelist compared to tcw maul. Comparing TCW maul, let alone tpm maul to vos as a duelist, vos beat dooku with favorable circumstances, maul with equally favorable performances had much less success vs a significantly inferior duelist in tcw kenobi. Additionally dd vos has wrecked grevious, someone who himself has outperformed maul(as a duelist) vs superior versions of tcw kenobi. So vos should be superior to tcw maul as a duelist, leet alone his tpm counterpart

Force wise, ragdolling ventress is> to anything tpm maul has done.

There is no way tpm maul is beating vos here

Juyo > Djem So/Ataru

DD Vos only had the unpredictability advantage over Dooku; Maul is just as unpredictable if not more.

Vos of course.

Maul in a damn good fight. Otherwise split.

Maul wins.

DD Vos IMO

Originally posted by Kurk
Juyo > Djem So/Ataru

DD Vos only had the unpredictability advantage over Dooku; Maul is just as unpredictable if not more.

Where is it stated he uses Djem So again?

Originally posted by Kurk
Juyo > Djem So/Ataru

DD Vos only had the unpredictability advantage over Dooku; Maul is just as unpredictable if not more.
Dooku was still stated as only "perhaps" less skilled.
Disarming Dooku with a style edge and him having a blaster wound is>>>getting outdueled by tcw kenobi with the help of your brother and kenobi using his less favored style. And let's re,ever that's a superior version of maul than the one here.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Dooku was still stated as only "perhaps" less skilled.
Disarming Dooku with a style edge and him having a blaster wound is>>>getting outdueled by tcw kenobi with the help of your brother and kenobi using his less favored style. And let's re,ever that's a superior version of maul than the one here. Dooku "over-extended" ; Vos didn't disarm him.

"Vos seemed to be holding his own against Dooku. He leapt, sprang, ducked, and tumbled. Dooku might have been a master of technique, but Vos's characteristic unpredictability-quite possibly even to himself-often gave him the edge.

As it did now. Vos all but danced around Dooku, forcing the older man to whirl, strike, and block from every side. And then-there it was. Dooku overextended-only a trifle-and the next thing Kenobi knew the count's lightsaber was across the room and the count himself was on his back.

Vos smiled down at the defeated Sith. The tip of his lightsaber was a centimeter away from Dooku's throat."
Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Where is it stated he uses Djem So again?
idk; maybe it was just ataru though I don't think it specifically says that anywhere either. This is canon anyway so why am I bringing it up.

So vos pressed dooku to make a mistake?

Vos still takes this every time

Vos.

TPM is better than Rebels Maul, but even then, he was still losing to padawans.

Vos utterly dominates.

Rebels Maul is canonically a superior duelist to TCW Maul who is confirmed to be a physically better and more skilled duelist than tpm maul.

Maul being a broken character or being stuck in the past as a character doesn't change that he improved as a combatant

Bla bla bla. Vos never defeated Dooku, it was such a shit book

Originally posted by Trocity
TPM is better than Rebels Maul, but even then, he was still losing to padawans.



You say he lost to Padawans (was actually only 1 fully trained Padawan), as if Maul was some Sith Master in TPM...

Fact is TPM Kenobi and TPM Maul were about the same age and would have trained for a similar amount of time. And they were both Jedi/Sith apprentices.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
So vos pressed dooku to make a mistake?

Vos still takes this every time Ventress also over-extended fighting Dooku earlier in the book. I guess Dooku pushed her to make a mistake with his conservative Makashi.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Rebels Maul is canonically a superior duelist to TCW Maul


Now you're really stretching the "evidence"

Originally posted by Trocity
TPM is better than Rebels Maul, but even then, he was still losing to padawans.

Vos utterly dominates. Context. You seem quite dense by your inability to go with the context. It always matters. Maul wins.

The irony.

Originally posted by Trocity
The irony. What context have I ignored ? Don't puss out now.

In terms of Star Wars related, or in general? If the former, the list is gonna be long. If the latter, we'll be here all week.

Originally posted by Trocity
In terms of Star Wars related, or in general? If the former, the list is gonna be long. If the latter, we'll be here all week. Then two examples shouldn't be difficult at all.

"Jango Fett making Mace Windu run away."

"Vader being too slow to react to Han shooting at him."

Originally posted by Trocity
"Jango Fett making Mace Windu run away."

"Vader being too slow to react to Han shooting at him."

Jango's flame thrower made him jump backward and regroup below. He knew he had to get out of there or he would have been critically injured. Later Windu soundly defeated him after the beast damaged the jetpack and greatly impacted Fett's manner of creating space between himself and the Jedi.

Vader was too slow to react initially. He did react after multiple shots and stopped him. Reacting before he can nail a shot is what Kylo did to Poe. That's reacting before the blast can hit you and countering.