Just finished (finally) Daredevil Season 2 last night.
In sheer physical stats, Keaton is her superior: bullet timer, lifting up a goon in each hand and hand-smacking them together, lifting up the rooftop goon and dangling him over the edge of the rooftop, moving fast enough to where the circus strongman didn't see him plant a dynamite bundle in his waistline, surviving the Joker shooting the Batwing down and still climbing the tower and taking down the goons in the belfry, punching through the floorboard of the Batmobile to remove Penguin's remote control device.
Elektra though has the benefit of Daredevil's showrunner's choreography, which means greater mobility and fighting speed and skill, plus she's got her sais in Round 2. But Keaton has stuff like his his batarang, seeking batarang, grappling gun, napalm gel in Round 2 from his utility belt. Keaton also has his rubber suit/body armor, Elektra just her ninja-ing clothing.
My tale of the tape:
Keaton Batman:
Pros
- Greater overall physical stats in strength, reflexes, and durability
- More resistance to harm due to suit, and the chest plate of said suit being body armor (Note
o the movies ever specify from what his armor chest plate is made?)
- Wide array of gadgets, and thus more versatility, in Round 2
Cons
- Less mobile due to suit, especially the neck/head cowl
- If this counts: was more reluctant to hit Catwoman, and was rewarded with a couple of beatdowns in Batman Returns, though I think it was due to Selina's cat-powers/pheromone-like powers? IDK on that.
MCU Elektra:
Pros
- Greater combat speed and skill
- Far better maneuverability and mobility
Cons
- No armor
- Pure H2H, melee fighter, whereas Keaton has some ranged options in Round 2.
Round 1: Elektra
Round 2: Keaton