Why Dooku refused a seat on the jedi council

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Kurk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FA-wjrhyBiM

Rockydonovang
because he listened to trash like the stupendous wave?

TheMuser
tbh, are there any actually good SW you tubers with more then 20,000 subs.

Kurk
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
because he listened to trash like the stupendous wave? If you have anything you'd like to share about him being inaccurate please do.

Rockydonovang
Antione bandele is alright, though he still likes speculating, just outright ignoring feats, and ignoring context, authoritative statements when it suits him.

Though that can be said for an, unfortunately, large amount of the sw community

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Antione bandele is alright, though he still likes speculating, just outright ignoring feats, and ignoring context, authoritative statements when it suits him.

Though that can be said for an, unfortunately, large amount of the sw community

What feats has he ignored?

Rockydonovang
Kenobi's, Ahsoka's, , Anakin's, Maul's ect.

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Kenobi's, Ahsoka's, , Anakin's, Maul's ect.

Fair enough.

I felt his Anakin VS Mace and Ahsoka VS Vos was a little biased.

He at least addressed the Vader Force push thing.

Rockydonovang
Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird


He at least addressed the Vader Force push thing.
And conveniently ignored that while vader was arguably had his defenses down when ahsoka pushed him, Ahsoka was clearly off balance and inarguably had her defenses down when vader pushed her.

Also, his argument for vos being stronger was beyond laughable. Apparently clashing blades with sora bulq is a better strength feat than disorientating grevious as a padawan, hkeeping maul in a bladelock as of rots, staggering maul, and pushing off an overhand strike by vader while faced in the opposite direction

Kurk
Bandele also comes off as being high in most of his videos too

Rockydonovang
To his credit though he's open minded about most things and after being provided evidence anakin is>mace he accepted it.

Jensaraai though...

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
To his credit though he's open minded about most things and after being provided evidence anakin is>mace he accepted it.

Jensaraai though...

When was this?

Yeah Jensaarbias is a rare specimen that has yet to challenge my Grievous VS Malgus video.

I intentionally held it's quality back as Connor bait conserding how how tried to take over Antoine's Kenobi VS Malgus video during their collaboration.

Rockydonovang
Jensaraii's judgements are just plain stupid a lot of the time:
-Sora Bulq is unquestionably physically stronger than anakin
-Dooku<TPM Maul as a duelist
-Dooku has weaker lightning than Malgus
-Malgus is just as good as kenobi as a duelist
-Anakin lacks skill
-kenobi has a weak force defense
-Yoda is a stupid duelist

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Jensaraii's judgements are just plain stupid a lot of the time:
-Sora Bulq is unquestionably physically stronger than anakin
-Dooku<TPM Maul as a duelist
-Dooku has weaker lightning than Malgus
-Malgus is just as good as kenobi as a duelist
-Anakin lacks skill
-kenobi has a weak force defense
-Yoda is a stupid duelist

Dooku VS TPM Maul in sabers is tough.

He said he had weaker lightning?

Kenobi's weak Force defense was probably made up to support his Malgus bias. He REALLY wanted Malgus to win that videos match up.

Rockydonovang
Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Dooku VS TPM Maul in sabers is tough.

it really isn't.

Aside from gillard himself implying there being a massive difference:
"Maul's an eight.Dooku's an eight" But there's a massive difference between tiers"

There are the obvious comparisons that can be made by looking at their performances vs kenobi/grevious

A superior version of maul confirmed to be more skilled and physically superior has consistently been shown as an inferior duelist to season 4-season 5 Kenobi despite generally favorable circumstances. On the other hand Dooku has outclassed a later tcw kenobi while dealing with anakin and has shown superiority to kenobi even as of rots, while dealing with anakin.

Additionally, we can compare there performances vs grevious. Maul has fought grevious relatively evenly on a nexus getting kicked away. Dooku has, without a nexus always won sparring sessions with grevious, with grevious only occasionally being able to press him

There's also there performance vs yoda/sidious.

Dooku legitimatley held his own for about 40 secoonds iirc vs Yoda

Maul managed to fight sids for a grand total of 5 seconds while rage amped, and even then if you go by sc, he was still being toyed with

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.