Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

H2h only. Set in Central Park at day. Who wins?

Bump

So 5 Jesse Ventura's.

Matt loses to just one.

Well, based on the implied ability of the MCU, Daredevil would win. He consistently beat up groups of zombie ninjas towards the end of S2, and ninjas specialise in that type of combat, so they should be comparable to Seals. And the military forces in the MCU seem to have a fluctuating standard of ability. Punisher and even Luke Cage show solid H2H skill, but the military guys Gao recruited to rescue her on IF couldn't even handle Claire and a half-dead Colleen.

With real life Seals it's tough to gauge, because they don't operate in comic book terms, where people can casually catch arrows and survive the kind of damage people like Matt or Frank can soak up.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Well, based on the implied ability of the MCU, Daredevil would win. He consistently beat up groups of zombie ninjas towards the end of S2, and ninjas specialise in that type of combat, so they should be comparable to Seals. And the military forces in the MCU seem to have a fluctuating standard of ability. Punisher and even Luke Cage show solid H2H skill, but the military guys Gao recruited to rescue her on IF couldn't even handle Claire and a half-dead Colleen.

With real life Seals it's tough to gauge, because they don't operate in comic book terms, where people can casually catch arrows and survive the kind of damage people like Matt or Frank can soak up. These are my thoughts on it too. Matt is implied to be more skilled than most military in his world but real life is something I cant comment on

Bump

Seals easily. TV daredevil almost got killed by one assassin. Once one guy grabs him, it's pretty much over. They have some of the best teamwork there is. Comic book Daredevil would win though.

Only because Comic Book Military Forces are always Crap.

What "one assassin" almost killed him? The only person who has ever come close to managing that was Nobu, who was an immortal uber ninja with multiple life times worth of XP. One other Hand guy gave him a bit of trouble, but A. at that point they could hide from his senses, which the Seals can't, B. it was a sneak attack at home, unlike the match stips, and C. he shot him with a poison arrow through the shoulder at the start of the fight, which the Seals don't have.

Didn't he get wrecked in the first few episodes? By a bunch of thugs? That dude he killed to get the name of Fisk gave him the business early in the fight I thought. Seals don't need to hide from him, they need to grab a hold of him. This wouldn't be some movie where they all come one at a time.

Originally posted by socool8520
Didn't he get wrecked in the first few episodes? By a bunch of thugs? That dude he killed to get the name of Fisk gave him the business early in the fight I thought. Seals don't need to hide from him, they need to grab a hold of him. This wouldn't be some movie where they all come one at a time.

He got ambushed by a bunch of Russians offscreen at the end of episode 1. We never see the fight. He later takes out a bunch of them while severely injured, so the group that ambushed him must have been significant. And he fought Healy (the assassin in question) while still suffering heavily from said injuries, and Healy was on the backfoot for like 90% of that fight (he briefly got Matt into a full nelson and tried to force him onto a spike, but it only lasted like a few seconds). And Matt didn't kill Healy either. He committed suicide because of his fear of Fisk. And that was an early S1 Daredevil, who was less skilled and experienced than he currently is. In S2 he fought off multiple attackers at once on multiple occasions, like when he fought the Dogs of Hell (while not even at 100%, after multiple fights with the Punisher, as well as having a bullet ricochet off his forehead the previous night), and multiple instances where he fought groups of Hand Ninjas at the end of S2.