Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Prime versions. This is a lightsabers only fight, but Force augmentation is still allowed; however, Mace isn't in the amped state that he was in against Sidious (standard Vapaad amp due to him fighting a dark sider is allowed still, if relevant). Fight takes place on neutral ground.

Who wins and why?

Mace, but he should be challenged.

Mace, decent fight.

Mace.

Mace.

Originally posted by MythLord
Mace, decent fight.

The one who can compete with Sidious

Mace, though Kun would win all out.

Mace.

Mace curbs

None can compete with Sidious.
On topic, Mace shreds him apart.

Lucas disagrees, and I'll take his word over yours tbh

So, movie Mace can compete with movie Sidious. Cool.
EU Mace vs EU Sidious is entirely different.

as if the movies aren't integral to the eu themselves and what the eu is based on

Mace could barely even react to Sidious, having to angle his lightsaber to guard and do nothing more. Mace also has no power feats to suggest he can compete with Sidious, and Sidious had him at saberpoint+could have killed Amped Mace with Lightning anytime he wanted to. How is this Mace competing with Sidious?

Originally posted by thesithmaster
Mace could barely even react to Sidious, having to angle his lightsaber to guard and do nothing more. Mace also has no power feats to suggest he can compete with Sidious, and Sidious had him at saberpoint+could have killed Amped Mace with Lightning anytime he wanted to. How is this Mace competing with Sidious? because unless otherwise stated, those books are non canon and mace is therefore a peer of Sidious in sabers.

Originally posted by deathslash
because unless otherwise stated, those books are non canon and mace is therefore a peer of Sidious in sabers.

The novel is canon, lol. At least to Legends.