Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins

Skaar

Skaar chops him in half.

Aquaman.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Skaar chops him in half.

Based on what exactly?

Aquaman will block all of his attacks with the trident.

If anybody's doing the impaling, it's Arthur.

Artie gets eaten.

Skaar crushes Aquaman

Aquaman in a very good and close fight. He is simply superior in h2h, experiance and smarter. Strength is close enough.

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Aquaman in a very good and close fight. He is simply superior in h2h, experiance and smarter. Strength is close enough.


This

Skaar has fought a better class of people and did well against them. Skaar 8/10.

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Aquaman in a very good and close fight. He is simply superior in h2h, experiance and smarter. Strength is close enough. it's highly debatable whether Arthur is superior in anything but intelligence. Keep in mind, Skaar has fought characters with much more experience than Arthur and still walked away from it.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Based on what exactly?

Skaar has a better powerset. True, they're pretty even physically but Skaar could always decide to:

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11119/111192655/4568303-3249297108-26844.jpg

do something like that.

Good on aquaman for his stock being raised enough for this to be a contestable fight.

Originally posted by carver9
Skaar has fought a better class of people and did well against them. Skaar 8/10.

No he hasnt

Originally posted by deathslash
it's highly debatable whether Arthur is superior in anything but intelligence. Keep in mind, Skaar has fought characters with much more experience than Arthur and still walked away from it.

No he hasnt

Originally posted by Damborgson
Skaar has a better powerset. True, they're pretty even physically but Skaar could always decide to:

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11119/111192655/4568303-3249297108-26844.jpg

do something like that.

Finally a proper debater.

His fights arent impressive. He doesnt have gamma anymore. AM is a better fighter, faster, arguably stronger or equal, and has actually won fights. Yea skaar is good but hes still a kid and beneath AM.

Sin, are you able to post scans proving your claim?

Originally posted by carver9
Sin, are you able to post scans proving your claim?

Which claim?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Finally a proper debater.

His fights arent impressive. He doesnt have gamma anymore. AM is a better fighter, faster, arguably stronger or equal, and has actually won fights. Yea skaar is good but hes still a kid and beneath AM.

What happened to his gamma? That's what I get for not keeping up.
-----------
Yeah, I could see AM giving it to him physically but it's also very unlikely he's doing anything without the trident that could put him down.

https://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/124715/5738912-hulk+skaar+-+son+of+hulk+12+06.jpg

Even savage Hulk operates on a noticeably higher level than AM, and Skaar walked away from that fight just fine.

https://static2.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11121/111213429/5160903-4432705681-Hulk_.jpg

And his old power gives him a hard to beat advantage, whereas in a physical fight it's possible AM could dance around and spear him with the trident, more likely than Skaar catching him with his sword, Skaar likes to destroy the terrain underneath, has some powerful telekinesis, can empower his sword etc.

and he hits pretty hard too:

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/6/62144/1221261-incredible_hulk__602_019.jpg

Not that this would be a stomp.

does artie get his trident even in this....? it would likely be the deciding factor. /shrug

Originally posted by leonidas
does artie get his trident even in this....? it would likely be the deciding factor. /shrug

It would fall under standard equipment, though whether that would be enough to win, I can't say.

i think it would be enough to give him the edge. but this is really close imo.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Which claim?

That Aquaman is just better period.

Get KO by Skaar into space and who in their right mind would use a gamma-less version of Skaar?

Originally posted by carver9
That Aquaman is just better period.

Yes

Originally posted by vansonbee
Get KO by Skaar into space and who in their right mind would use a gamma-less version of Skaar?

Skaar was replaced by Cho. Banner didnt want his own kid having the power but some random guy is fine. Blame marvel

Originally posted by carver9
That Aquaman is just better period.

thumbsup

AM is better and truth be told has much more depth than Hulk.

Skaar.

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
AM is better and truth be told has much more depth than Hulk.

Skaar took on an amped Thor, Cyclops, Wolverine, and Iceman and held his own and appeared to have won since he came back from the battle moments later without the hero's showing up after him. By the way, these characters were so amped that they were throwing large ships like a baseball and thus amped Thor was taking on armies of Hulks and winnjng.

Originally posted by carver9
Skaar took on an amped Thor, Cyclops, Wolverine, and Iceman and held his own

During World War Hulks arc? Scans?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
During World War Hulks arc? Scans?


https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082552?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082581?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082620?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082650?list=post-85387417_2732

He shows up here after the battle and nearly kills Betty. Also, the first scan obviously shows Thor sucker shotting him.

https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082681?list=post-85387417_2732

Noticed amped Wolverine wasn't there. Sorry folks. I can't remember what happened with him after this. If anyone is interested, I can find out.

Originally posted by carver9
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082552?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082581?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082620?list=post-85387417_2732
https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082650?list=post-85387417_2732

He shows up here after the battle and nearly kills Betty. Also, the first scan obviously shows Thor sucker shotting him.

https://m.vk.com/photo-85387417_407082681?list=post-85387417_2732

Amusing how you consider a gamma thor amped but not a worthy hulk.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Amusing how you consider a gamma thor amped but not a worthy hulk.

It was said he was amped (Thor). I never said the hammer did nothing for Hulk. What I said was it didn't make him stronger.

Originally posted by carver9
Noticed amped Wolverine wasn't there. Sorry folks. I can't remember what happened with him after this. If anyone is interested, I can find out.

Np.

He and Spidey fought Rulk, I think?

Yep.

Hulked out Wolverine was a beast, he's toyed with Hulk-Bucky for the entire issue... completely humiliated him.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Hulked out Wolverine was a beast, he's toyed with Hulk-Bucky for the entire issue... completely humiliated him.

Amazing. His fight with Cap was beastly as well. I'm trying to think which two it was throwing those ships. Do you have the Bucky scans?

Originally posted by carver9
Amazing. His fight with Cap was beastly as well. I'm trying to think which two it was throwing those ships. Do you have the Bucky scans?

Not on hand - links are broken But I'll get new ones, just need to take a cold shower...

The fight has lasted two issues - World War Hulks: Captain America vs. Wolverine #1-2.

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-KY2PPDZekas/UsiTYTPtT5I/AAAAAAAAYAI/PcqE8MRgyos/s1600/Infinity+V2013+%25236+%2528of+6%2529+-+Amber+%25282014_1%2529+-+Page+5.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-rzBdSmldRgQ/UsiTZKjhemI/AAAAAAAAYAU/a14JvbPB7Po/s1600/Infinity+V2013+%25236+%2528of+6%2529+-+Amber+%25282014_1%2529+-+Page+7.jpg

They had JUST came from a war before facing Thanos. Here's the scans. Here is Cap telling Hulk to soften them up. BE A DISTRACTION. Thor then tells Hulk to harness his appetite.

http://www.universomarvel.com.aq/thanos/Thanos_Avengers_1.jpg

Don't know what comic Insane was reading but everything he said that didn't happen, happened. With that said, since Thanos wasn't able to one shot ko Hulk but Titan admitted Thor could, Thor hit>>>>>>Thanos. Thanks titan. Sad thing is, Thanos fought a fatigued team of Avengers and he still couldn't knock any of them out.

Originally posted by carver9
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-KY2PPDZekas/UsiTYTPtT5I/AAAAAAAAYAI/PcqE8MRgyos/s1600/Infinity+V2013+%25236+%2528of+6%2529+-+Amber+%25282014_1%2529+-+Page+5.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-rzBdSmldRgQ/UsiTZKjhemI/AAAAAAAAYAU/a14JvbPB7Po/s1600/Infinity+V2013+%25236+%2528of+6%2529+-+Amber+%25282014_1%2529+-+Page+7.jpg

They had JUST came from a war before facing Thanos. Here's the scans. Here is Cap telling Hulk to soften them up. BE A DISTRACTION. Thor then tells Hulk to harness his appetite.

http://www.universomarvel.com.aq/thanos/Thanos_Avengers_1.jpg

Don't know what comic Insane was reading but everything he said that didn't happen, happened. With that said, since Thanos wasn't able to one shot ko Hulk but Titan admitted Thor could, Thor hit>>>>>>Thanos. Thanks titan. Sad thing is, Thanos fought a fatigued team of Avengers and he still couldn't knock any of them out.

Sorry, where does it say Thor could one shot Hulk?

👀

Originally posted by Damborgson
Sorry, where does it say Thor could one shot Hulk?

👀

No where. The argument is, Titan said that Thor could one shot Hulk so I brought up Infinity because Thanos didn't one shot Hulk. So I'm saying since he thinks Thor can one shot Hulk but Thanos did not one shot him with a punch, he is basically saying Thor>>>>Thanos. The subject went to another place because he added Thanos henchmen being greater than Hulk which means Thanos is greater than Hulk when we all know plot took out Hulk and the way Hulk was taken out, Thanos can not repeat that. He then say Hulk feared Thanos because he didn't attack Thanos after Thanos punched him.

I had to post scans showing why Hulk didn't attack Thanos. Circular argument about nothing basically. The point I am trying to make is as clear as day. I know of one person who would've caught on to it immediately but joyfully, he is on ignore.