Obi-Wan Kenobi's Physical Strength/Physicality

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



TheNuisanceBird
"Though he could be quite stalwart when necessary, his strength was merely baseline." - Jensaarbias-I mean Jensaarai1, Versus Series Strikezone: The Uncut Blocks (Kao Cen Darach Vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi)



The following two are the first two examples that come to mind, both from the ROTS novelization.



"A single slash of his lightsaber amputated the shoulder cannon of one power droid and continued into a spinning Force-assisted kick that brought his boot heel to the point of the other power droid's duranium chin, snapping the droid's head back hard enough to sever its cervical sensor cables."

Compared to other Jedi of his era this is pretty good. If he can cause damage to a spider droid, he should disable an Inquisitor with a physical strike.


This is where it gets juicy:


"But Obi-Wan's arm had the Force to give it strength, and the general's arm only had the innate crystalline intermolecular structure of duranium alloy.

Grievous' forearm bent like a cheap spoon."

For those of you saying this feat "isn't canon" we have this:

https://youtu.be/Q4Rc_3D_0Tc?t=3s

Obi-Wan disarms Grievous which while debatably is indirect, is still a legitimate feat of strength and honestly, I still wouldn't put the cheap spoon feat past TCW Kenobi in the later seasons.

While this is TCW Grievous, I still wouldn't call this "baseline strength" when Kit Fisto chose to avoid Grievous, only engaging when his back was turned and when he got access to Nahdar's saber. Plus TCW Grievous has been shown to be capable of overpower three clones one of which was Commander Cody.

Sorta weird to go back and watch ROTS with the Utapau battle knowing that Grievous and Cody had a physical encounter. lol

During his fight with Maul and Opress, Kenobi manages to block both of their strikes with one arm when he's pinned against the wall, right before he slices Savage's arm off.



Anyways,



During the battle of the heroes, Obi-Wan bowls Anakin over in the junior novelization of ROTS.

"Anakin did a back flip onto the table to gain the high ground, But Obi-Wan had been expecting something like that, and did not follow. Instead, he threw himself into a long slide, bowling Anakin over."



Further more, in the ROTS movie, Kenobi manages to overpower Anakin in a direct contest of strength by redirecting him:

https://youtu.be/xbsBiyG1mnU?t=2m46s

Throughout the fight, Kenobi held his own against a hindered Pre-Suit Vader and while he had to constantly retreat and reposition himself, managed to deal with the power behind Anakin's strikes whereas Dooku could not.

See why this is a big deal in DarthAnt's thread for Anakin's physcial strength here:

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f6/t636525.html



Where Kenobi hurts himself in the ROTS movie by trying to kick Grievous, this is mostly due to him directly trying to strike Grievous. The spoon feat was where Obi-Wan had caught Grievous' arm.

Overall, as an experienced Ataru Kenobi's physicality or even strength isn't "baseline".

Kenobi could possibly have a physicality advantage over ROTS Vader since he should be able to deal with his strength.


Anyways, I made this thread because I have a lot of time to myself in my dorm and everybody else is off campus or taking SAT's so I can't duel with my friends.

Plus, I felt Kenobi is massively undervalued in terms of his physicality.

DarthAnt66
Yeah, Kenobi's physical strength is monstrous - something to be expected for someone who fights combatants like Maul, Grievous, and Anakin on the daily. Jen, like usually, is talking trash.

NewGuy01
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Yeah, Kenobi's physical strength is monstrous - something to be expected for someone who fights combatants like Maul, Grievous, and Anakin on the daily. Jen, like usually, is talking trash.

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Yeah, Kenobi's physical strength is monstrous - something to be expected for someone who fights combatants like Maul, Grievous, and Anakin on the daily. Jen, like usually, is talking trash.

Not sure how his strength would compare to Dooku.

If they dueled I think Kenobi would hold his strength in reserve as a defensive fighter and find it unlikely that Dooku would be overwhelmed by his strength although it could happen in sabers only if Kenobi draws it out.

I'm starting to think that if he fought ROTJ Vader in sabers only a large part of him winning would be being able to meet Vader's strength in a counter offensive.

Rockydonovang
Kenobi's durability is also monstrous:
https://youtu.be/DlJiphrbLyg?t=1m16s

A wrekced Kenobi takes a couple of seconds to get up from two kicks to the skull and one to the chest.

This from a guy who can shatter durasteel.

Kurk
And then there's this entire fight:
https://youtu.be/6w2WZzWa7jg?t=54s


It really is amazing how much Kenobi can take considering he's not top-tier as a force user (as of TCW at least).

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Kurk
And then there's this entire fight:
https://youtu.be/6w2WZzWa7jg?t=54s


It really is amazing how much Kenobi can take considering he's not top-tier as a force user (as of TCW at least).

The best thing about that entire fight is that while Kenobi was holding back massively to buy Anakin time, it's my theory that he also decided to do it because he knew he could take it.

When it's over he just shrugs it off like nothing happened, causing me to believe he faked injury.

I know the ROTS animatics are far from canon, but I wouldn't put Kenobi's durability feat in the Utapau one where he gets dragged along the ground from hanging from Grievous' wheel bike past him.



The same thing can be said about his dueling abilities. Even if he's not on the level of a higher tiered opponent, he's likely to be able to defend against them.

In sabers only I'd say Kenobi > Dooku and Vader.

Kenobi VS Mace in sabers only is tough though.

BlueTiger1144
Kenobi isn't above Dooku in sabers though.

Kurk
In pure sabers I have Kenobi winning against Mace 5-6/10.

Dooku vs Kenobi sabers only would be a boring af fight to watch. Both use defensive forms and rely on counterattacks. When Kenobi breaks his form he loses. When Dooku gets too strained from unpredictability he overextends. A pure saber-fight between the two can't really exist.

DarthAnt66
Originally posted by Kurk
In pure sabers I have Kenobi winning against Mace 5-6/10.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Y-X5i_X23LE/Tl7-EKCZf3I/AAAAAAAAAt4/CWImLck21oA/s640/its-ok.gif

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by BlueTiger1144
Kenobi isn't above Dooku in sabers though.

Gillard says Kenobi's an eight. If we're following Ant's hunch, Dooku should be around Kenobi.

Mace is an "eight bordering on nine", and I remember Ant showing possible evidence of Mace finally surpassing Dooku in sabers skill.

Dooku could possibly eventually work around Kenobi's Soresu, but he'd likely tire out before he could.

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by Kurk
In pure sabers I have Kenobi winning against Mace 5-6/10.

Dooku vs Kenobi sabers only would be a boring af fight to watch. Both use defensive forms and rely on counterattacks. When Kenobi breaks his form he loses. When Dooku gets too strained from unpredictability he overextends. A pure saber-fight between the two can't really exist.

I wouldn't say so. We may have a better answer if SOD had been fully animated with Obi-Wan's fight with Dooku where Anakin's absent.

I actually think Dooku would attack Kenobi first. Either way, Kenobi should be able to defend against Dooku until he starts to tire.

DarthAnt66
While Dooku likely is a better swordsman than Obi-Wan, it's evident from the ROTS novel he's still incapable of breaking through Obi-Wan's stone-wall. At best, you're arguing Obi-Wan can't launch a successful offensive against Dooku and it's effectively a draw; at worst, Obi-Wan gets through and Dooku goes down.

Kurk
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Y-X5i_X23LE/Tl7-EKCZf3I/AAAAAAAAAt4/CWImLck21oA/s640/its-ok.gif You'll have to convince me why Kenobi's soresu could not handle a non-vaapad (or at least not as) amped Windu.

"He must have been trained by Count Dooku," Mace had said, "so you can expect Makashi as well; given the number of Jedi he has fought and slain, you must expect that he can attack in any
style, or all of them. In fact, Obi-Wan, I believe that of all living Jedi, you have the best chance to defeat him." -RotS Novel

If Kenobi's style is best suited for extremely aggressive and unpredictable styles as Mace himself says, why would he lose to Windu whose vaapad relies on the same principles?

DarthAnt66
The Soresu/Vaapad dynamic isn't relevant here given Windu is already teetering on tier 9.

Their general skill-set would have to be closer for that to be a game-changer.

Kurk
Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
I wouldn't say so. We may have a better answer if SOD had been fully animated with Obi-Wan's fight with Dooku where Anakin's absent.

I actually think Dooku would attack Kenobi first. Either way, Kenobi should be able to defend against Dooku until he starts to tire. The problem is that they're both defensive and predictable fighter. If they both know that's where their strength lies, they'll maybe exchange blows and wait for one to become impatient and break form.

Kenobi's soresu is most effective against wild, unpredictable fighters like Grievous and Vader. Dooku is complete opposite of this.

Likewise, Dooku struggles against those who are unpredictable and rely on power-attacks. Kenobi is not this.

So what I'm saying that at the fundamental, theoretical level, a fight between these two could not exist. It would be a passive exchange of blows while they wait for the other to break away from their form due to impatience. In every fight with Dooku, Kenobi was forced to fight offensively along with Anakin. That was his weakness. Because we've never seen him fight Dooku solo aside from SoD, we don't know if he'd take an offensive of defensive approach.

Kurk
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
The Soresu/Vaapad dynamic isn't relevant here given Windu is already teetering on tier 9.

Their general skill-set would have to be closer for that to be a game-changer. What did Gillard say about Mace being a 9? Didn't he say that's only under ideal conditions?

DarthAnt66
Nope. In fact, he mostly refers to Mace as a full-fledged 9, with only one interview saying 8 bordering 9.

YousufKhan1212

BlueTiger1144
How does Obi Wan's "strength" alone compare to Dooku's?

Kurk

UCanShootMyNova
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Nope. In fact, he mostly refers to Mace as a full-fledged 9, with only one interview saying 8 bordering 9.

So you're telling me Grievous is a 10? Hot damn.

UCanShootMyNova
Tbh I think Obi Wan takes a majority against Mace in sabers only as well.

DarthAnt66
Originally posted by Kurk
Gillard's system is the only thing Mace has going for him at this point. Plus his system only applies to the prequels, which are canon, while this thread is referencing EU feats.

Lucas' rating systems takes precedent over any Legends developments.

For example:

If a hundred books allude to Y > X, but Lucas states X > Y, then, factually, X > Y.

thumb up

That being said, Mace has enough in Legends to place him above Obi-Wan anyway.

JKBart
lmao wut

I love Obi-Wan and I really believe him to be in top 10 duelists ever in SW, but u've got to be pretty drunk to place him above Mace lmao

UCanShootMyNova
Obi Wan is twice as fast as Mace. AT LEAST. smile

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Obi Wan is twice as fast as Mace. AT LEAST. smile

Based on what feats exactly?

Kurk
Originally posted by DarthAnt66


That being said, Mace has enough in Legends to place him above Obi-Wan anyway.

Then it should be pretty easy to find, right?

Kurk
Originally posted by JKBart
lmao wut

I love Obi-Wan and I really believe him to be in top 10 duelists ever in SW, but u've got to be pretty drunk to place him above Mace lmao Hey welcome back Bart. I missed yo ass. Please continue with your funny "Anakin sees Dooku raping Padme, who wins?" threads. big grin

UCanShootMyNova
Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Based on what feats exactly?

Obi Wan > Grievous > half speed hindered Grievous > Mace. smile

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Obi Wan > Grievous > half speed hindered Grievous > Mace. smile

Kenobi's victory over Grievous wasn't really because of superior speed.

godemperortrump
Obi and Mace are pretty even in Sabers, honestly. Windu just has a power edge

TheNuisanceBird
Originally posted by godemperortrump
Obi and Mace are pretty even in Sabers, honestly. Windu just has a power edge

In regards to fighting each other? Maybe.

But Mace has the superior skill for sure.

AncientPower
Grievous is explicitly striking too fast for Kenobi to hold out against in the novelisation, kek.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.