Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

As the title says, basically "so and so > so and so > so and so", "so and so >> so and so >>> so and so". You get the picture.

1. Mara Jade Skywalker, Jaden Korr, Kyle Katarn.

2. SoR Revan, The Outlander, Arcann.

3. Lord Scourge, Darth Malgus, Satele Shan, Darth Marr.

4. Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, Kit Fisto, Plo Koon, Shaak Ti.

5. Savage Opress, TCW Darth Maul, Sora Bulq, Quinlan Vos, Asajj Ventress, Rebels Ahsoka Tano.

DISCUSS!

Overall actual combat:

1. Mara = Kyle > Jaden
2. Revan > Outlander > Arcann
3. Malgus > Satele > Scourge = Marr
4. Kit > Agen > Plo > Saesee > Shaak
5. not rating because of Legends/Canon problems

Power only:
1. Mara > Kyle > Jaden
2. Revan > Arcann = Outlander
3. Malgus = Satele > Marr = Scourge
4. Shaak > Plo > Saesee > Kit > Agen
5. as above

Canon or Legend Vos?

Originally posted by Total Warrior
Canon or Legend Vos? Legends.

No one uses canon vos.

Mara >/= Kyle > Jaden
Revan (?) Outlander >/= Arcann
Malgus > Satele = Marr (?) Scourge
Plo > Kit > Saesee/Kolar (?) Shaak
Maul >/= Tano > Savage >/= Ventress > Vos

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Mara >/= Kyle > Jaden
Revan (?) Outlander >/= Arcann
Malgus > Satele = Marr (?) Scourge
Plo > Kit > Saesee/Kolar (?) Shaak
Maul >/= Tano > Savage >/= Ventress > Vos Savage over Ventress....?

1. Mara Jade Skywalker > Kyle > Jaden.

2. SoR Revan ~ Outlander > Arcann.

3. Darth Malgus > Darth Marr > Lord Scourge > Satele Shan.

4. Kit Fisto >~ Plo Koon >~ Agen Kolar > Saesee Tiin. Shaak Ti's placement depends on the version.

5. TCW Darth Maul > Sora Bulq ~ Asajj Ventress > Savage Opress. Ahsoka and Vos's placement depends on if we're using composite versions.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
1. Mara Jade Skywalker > Kyle > Jaden.

2. SoR Revan ~ Outlander > Arcann.

3. Darth Malgus > Darth Marr > Lord Scourge > Satele Shan.

4. Kit Fisto >~ Plo Koon >~ Agen Kolar > Saesee Tiin. Shaak Ti's placement depends on the version.

5. TCW Darth Maul > Sora Bulq ~ Asajj Ventress > Savage Opress. Ahsoka and Vos's placement depends on if we're using composite versions. composite.

1. Mara > Kyle > Jaden
2. Revan > Outlander > Arcann
3. Dunno, Malgus is #1 tho
4. Dunno tbh
5. Maul > Savage > Ventress >(?) Bulq
Dunno about Vos tbh. And Canon Ahsoka is eh

Mara ~> Kyke > Jaden
Revan ~ Outlander > Arcann
Malgus > Marr > Scourge > Satele
Kit is #1
Ahsoka ~ TCW Maul > Vos > Savage > Ventress > Bulq

Legends Vos > Savage?

They're all Canon. Composite is retarded, I just don't know why people use it anymore.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Legends.

No one uses canon vos. smh

Originally posted by Ursumeles
smh Legends Vos >>>>>>>>>> Canon Vos

wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat

Originally posted by JKBart
wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat wat I assumed Dark Disciple was Legends.

Hey Jman wanna join Hangouts?

What does smh mean?

1: Kyle>Mara>Jaden
2: Revan>>Outlander~Arcann
3: Malgus>Marr>Satele>>Scourge
4: Ti>the rest are all ~ each other.
5: Maul>Ventress>Savage~Bulq>Vos>Tano

Kinda shaky on some of these though.

Originally posted by darthbane77
1: Kyle>Mara>Jaden
2: Revan>>Outlander~Arcann
3: Malgus>Marr>Satele>>Scourge
4: Ti>the rest are all ~ each other.
5: Maul>Ventress>Savage~Bulq>Vos>Tano

Kinda shaky on some of these though. ...You realize thats REBELS Ahsoka, right?

Not TCW Ahsoka.

Also, in no world is Satele>>Scourge.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
As the title says, basically "so and so > so and so > so and so", "so and so >> so and so >>> so and so". You get the picture.

1. Mara Jade Skywalker, Jaden Korr, Kyle Katarn.

2. SoR Revan, The Outlander, Arcann.

3. Lord Scourge, Darth Malgus, Satele Shan, Darth Marr.

4. Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, Kit Fisto, Plo Koon, Shaak Ti.

5. Savage Opress, TCW Darth Maul, Sora Bulq, Quinlan Vos, Asajj Ventress, Rebels Ahsoka Tano.

DISCUSS!
1. Mara > Kyle > Jaden
2. Revan > Outlander > Arcann
3. Malgus > Marr = Shan > Scourge
4. Kit > Plo > Agen = Kolar > Shaak
5. Quinlan (C) = Maul > Ahsoka > Savage > Asajj > Sora > Quinlan (L)

Not going to bother with >>s or >=s.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Plo > Kit
Disgusting.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
1. Mara > Kyle > Jaden
2. Revan > Outlander > Arcann
3. Malgus > Marr = Shan > Scourge
4. Kit > Plo > Agen = Kolar > Shaak
5. Quinlan (C) = Maul > Ahsoka > Savage > Asajj > Sora > Quinlan (L)

Not going to bother with >>s or >=s.

This. I love you Ant, not a troll.

1. Mara>Kyle>Jaden

2. SoR Revan>The Outlander>Arcann.

3. Malgus > Marr = Shan > Scourge

4. Kit=Plo=Saesee>Agen>Shaak

5. Vos>Maul>Ventress=/>Tano>Opress>Bulq

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Disgusting.

My recollection of their interactions and performances in the few comics they were together in give me that impression.

Also:



Autism.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
...You realize thats REBELS Ahsoka, right?

Not TCW Ahsoka.

Also, in no world is Satele>>Scourge. I realize it's Rebels Tano, I don't hold her as highly as most others do, I see no reason to.

Satele's feats far outweigh Scourge's own, and Scourge has no accolades to indicate superiority to her either.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
My recollection of their interactions and performances in the few comics they were together in give me that impression.

The OCW ones? Fair, but Plo's portrayal (and thus, "interactions" in that is irrevocably incompatible with... everything.

For "performances," it should be noted Kit didn't want to hurt anyone, whereas Plo was fine with abusing his powers.



Maybe I just really ****ing like Agen Kolar and want to emphasize his placement.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
The OCW ones? Fair, but Plo's portrayal (and thus, "interactions" in that is irrevocably incompatible with... everything.

https://memegenerator.net/img/instances/500x/68331720/i-dont-think-so.jpg

Ahsoka stalemated Maul on a nexus and was authoritatively placed above him.

That it was Rebels Maul and not TCW Maul is irrelevant untill someone can prove

A, Rebels Maul declined

B. TCW Maul is better than Rebels Maul by enough to make up for whatever gap there is between Ahsoka and Maul.

The first one is going to be especially troublesome to prove because the only relevant evidence on the matter implies Maul to have improved rather than decreased. However, even if you ignore that on the faulty premise that authors don't have the creative license to choose how they want to portray something which doesn't contradict the lore(Maul improving after TCW isn't contradicted by the slightest shred of evidence), the onus is still on people arguing for Maul here to prove Maul declined. That proof can't be an absence of evidence.

And no, a quote which doesn't even mention Maul's combative abilities and is specific to a nexus doesn't supersede a direct authoritative statement regarding Ahsoka's on even ground.

As it stands though, Maul > Ahsoka, much like religion, is based on wishful thinking rather than actual evidence.