First Order vs Star Trek Federation

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



playa1258
The First Order lead by Snoke , Kylo and Hux.

The Federation post-Nemesis in the prime timeline is lead by Picard, Sisko and Janeway.

Who takes it?

Darkstorm Zero
Huh, well this is a little bit different from the usual throng of Trek vs Wars debates, so I'll entertain it a little. The First order doesn't have the numbers that the Old Empire had. Nor do they have the territory and resources Sheev had. They do however have some very impressive machines. Dreadnoughts, the Supremacy, and Starkiller base are all very capable. and in fact the Starkiller is one weapon that the Federation has no real defense against. However, that is relying purely on a superweapon. If we were to go to ship to ship engagement, I'd see this as much closer than people think, and yet the First Order's firepower remains a head ahead of any Federation ship I can think of in ship to ship combat.

BruceSkywalker
does ben get his lightsaber and force abilities?

SquallX
The First Order has the Star destroyer. That weapon can casually destroy most of the Federation defense with just one blast. That would reduce the Federation to near destruction. Then the FO can casually destroy the rest.

Silent Master
Star Trek just flies a shuttle into it at warp speed smile

playa1258
Yeah Ben can use the force.

quanchi112
First a Order decimates the federation. Snoke would kill Picard via a screen. He'd mock him first.

h1a8
The federation has cloaking abilities.
Snoke can probably force choke the captains.
Idk who wins yet.

quanchi112
Originally posted by h1a8
The federation has cloaking abilities.
Snoke can probably force choke the captains.
Idk who wins yet. I know you're an idiot. We all know that much.

BruceSkywalker
first order prolly stomp anyways..

playa1258
No, they don't.

FO ships are slow, their weapons have pathetic ranges and fighters are a big threat to them.

Fighters and those slow bombers used by the resistance would be easily dealt with by the Federation. FO ships need specifically designed bombardment weapons just to hit the rebel base.

As we see in DS9 episode "Die is Cast" Trek weapons can wipe out 30% of the surface of a planet with an opening barrage. This point is significant because it's standard weapons being used.

Robtard
A single X-wing was able to take out a Dreadnaughts defenses...

playa1258
Which means the Enterprise shits on it.

Robtard
A Defiant class

playa1258
That too. Hell the Peregine could do it.

Robtard
FO doesn't even have a proper medical/dental plan. Did you seen Snoke's disgusting face and snaggly stained teeth. Yuck.

playa1258
Quan dumping too much loads did that damage.

quanchi112
Originally posted by Robtard
A single X-wing was able to take out a Dreadnaughts defenses... So you believe Dameron Poe is your typical pilot ? For ****s sake. First Order annihilates them.

quanchi112
Originally posted by Robtard
FO doesn't even have a proper medical/dental plan. Did you seen Snoke's disgusting face and snaggly stained teeth. Yuck. Snoke envy. Feathers ruffled.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.