The biggest failure: Luke vs. Yoda?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Mendax
Who failed the jedi order more?

Haschwalth
Luke's Band of a dozen students over a decade or so, or Yoda's Hundreds of thousands of Jedi over the past 800 years.

relentless1
Yoda for sure, he let the Jedi fall to one guy after 1000 generations of the orders existence; when by all accounts they could have and should have caught on to Palpatine before it was too late. Luke failed 12 students and gave up, Yodas failure was on a much more massive scale.

FreshestSlice
Ultimately, any of Luke's failures as a teacher fall on Yoda's shoulders. Especially since he's still around.

Nephthys
Didn't TCW establish that Yoda knew the Jedi were about to get purged? And he did ****all to prevent it?

Deronn_solo
Yeah, Yoda was pretty incompetent, ngl.

Galan007
Overall? Yoda, and I don't see how that's even debatable.

Under Yoda's direct watch, one of the most powerful Sith Masters of all time rose to power and affected the slaughter of thousands of Jedi -- nearly driving the entire Order("at the height of their power"wink into extinction... And if fallen apprentices are a measure of a Jedi's failure, as Luke seemed to think, then Yoda was also responsible for the training of Count Dooku, whose Separatist army murdered untold billionS.

...Luke lost a dozen students in all(some were killed; some turned to the dark side) -- a drop of water in an ocean compared to Yoda's failure.

Kurk
Yoda by far

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.