Rank these incarnations of Sidious, Mace and Anakin in sabers
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
The Ellimist
Anakin (S6)
Anakin (early/mid invisible hand fight)
Anakin (Zone state)
Anakin (Knightfall)
Sidious (BoTPM)
Sidious (EoTPM)
Sidious (RotS)
Sidious (DE)
Windu (TPM)
Windu (AotC)
Windu (S6)
Windu (RotS - no superconducting loop)
Windu (RotS - with Sidious's energies)
NewGuy01
Is this a comparison of pure skill, or overall effectiveness?
The Ellimist
Overall effectiveness
TenebrousWay
Sidious (DE)
Windu (RotS - with Sidious's energies)
Anakin (Knightfall)
Sidious (RotS)
Anakin (Zone state)
Sidious (EoTPM)
Windu (RotS - no superconducting loop)
Anakin (early/mid invisible hand fight)
Windu (S6)
Sidious (BoTPM)
Anakin (S6)
Windu (AotC)
Windu (TPM)
NewGuy01
RotS Vader
RotS Sidious / RotS Mace (vs Sidious)
RotS Anakin
RotS Mace
TPM Mace / TCW Anakin
Something along those lines. The differences between TPM/AotC Mace, TPM/RotS Sidious, "Zone"/"Knightfall" Anakin, and so on are pretty vaguely defined, so I stuck with what we know. No comment on DE Sidious.
CactusJoe
Originally posted by NewGuy01
RotS Vader
RotS Sidious / RotS Mace (vs Sidious)
RotS Anakin
RotS Mace
TPM Mace / TCW Anakin
Something along those lines. The differences between TPM/AotC Mace, TPM/RotS Sidious, "Zone"/"Knightfall" Anakin, and so on are pretty vaguely defined, so I stuck with what we know. No comment on DE Sidious.
https://www.kanyetothe.com/forum/Smileys/default/rsz_ckkn9up.png
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2025 KillerMovies.
