Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

1. Force
2. Sabers
3. All Out.

Battle takes place in the Jedi Temple.

Koon

Plo Koon

Jinn.

Jinn.

https://pre00.deviantart.net/6542/th/pre/i/2010/326/3/5/the_coon____vectorized_by_kaczorq-d33byrh.jpg

Lmao, respect earned.

Koon defeated Yoda in Lightsaber combat once, didn't he?

Jinn couldn't even keep up with Maul.

Koon also couldn't keep up with Savage.

Originally posted by MythLord
Koon also couldn't keep up with Savage. Neither would Jinn.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Koon defeated Yoda in Lightsaber combat once, didn't he?

Jinn couldn't even keep up with Maul.

Once in a sparring session but we don't know context or anything. It was just talk around the temple in a videogame (IDK which videogame).

Meanwhile we have an easier means to compare them. Jinn's performance against Maul was similair to Koon's performance against Savage and of course Maul is stronger than Savage.

Jin>Plo Koon.

Originally posted by HP Legend
Once in a sparring session but we don't know context or anything. It was just talk around the temple in a videogame (IDK which videogame).

Meanwhile we have an easier means to compare them. Jinn's performance against Maul was similair to Koon's performance against Savage and of course Maul is stronger than Savage.

Jin>Plo Koon. Savage has a lot of tantrums, for example, ragdolling both Dooku and Ventress with the Force.

Also, I don't think TPM Maul is his Prime.

Savage>TPM Maul.

I don't think TCW Maul would beat TPM Maul as effectively as he did Savage, especially not when TCW Maul was mostly on par with his younger self(as was stated in Sith Hunters) and only really started getting any noticeable power-increase after going on Mandalore(as per Shadow Conspiracy).

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Savage has a lot of tantrums, for example, ragdolling both Dooku and Ventress with the Force.

Also, I don't think TPM Maul is his Prime.

Savage>TPM Maul.

Savage didn't have a tantrum against Plo IIRC and even if he did it wouldn't compare to his tantrum against Dooku and Ventress because that scenrio has special circumstances.

Savage>TPM is based on what?

Savage doesn't have any feats beyond TPM and Maul absolutely stomped Savage in S5 of TCW which given Maul's power growth wasn't that significant it should put him beyond Savage.

Which ones?

Beating fodder Jedi and holding off the duo of jobbers (Anakin and Obi Wan)?

Originally posted by HP Legend
Which ones?

Beating fodder Jedi and holding off the duo of jobbers (Anakin and Obi Wan)? Cough And Dooku Cough.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Cough And Dooku Cough.

Savage gets a rage amp and manages to overpower Dooku but before that he was getting his ass kicked with help from Ventress. Definitely seems like a decent feat.

TPM Maul stomps Savage, Jinn humbles Koon.

TPM Maul is the same TCW Maul. It's not until Mandalore that you can argue that Maul grew enough in power to make a difference between them. "But muh feats" isn't an argument...

Originally posted by HP Legend

Meanwhile we have an easier means to compare them. Jinn's performance against Maul was similair to Koon's performance against Savage and of course Maul is stronger than Savage.

Jin>Plo Koon.





Originally posted by victreebelvictr


Savage>TPM Maul.


Nah

Dookus goal with Savage was to get him to TPM Maul level.

Eh. maybe I am wrong, but how low does everyone rate Koon and why?

I just don't see how he is rated so low...

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Eh. maybe I am wrong, but how low does everyone rate Koon and why?

I just don't see how he is rated so low...
he wins this fight, forum is just full of delusional liam neeson fanboys

Originally posted by Intr3pId
he wins this fight, forum is just full of delusional liam neeson fanboys I respect you now.

Got to admit Savage>TPM Maul had me laughing

Originally posted by MythLord
TPM Maul is the same TCW Maul. It's not until Mandalore that you can argue that Maul grew enough in power to make a difference between them. "But muh feats" isn't an argument...

Not really. SC notes that Maul became more powerful than his TPM version by S4 and he obviously got a big increase there by Revival

It didnt note that by S4. Only by Revivial. And even then it was in the Force, not necessarily all combat prowess at that point. It was also Kenobis own observation. So Fallible opinion and all.

Only by The Lawless is he stated to be outright better than he ever was. And even then extent of that is left quite vague.

So I dont see anything to contradict Filonis statement of Maul being at a combat disadvantage in those Chicken Legs. Or the fact that he was still in recovery.

Objective statements in SC note that Maul had returned more powerful by S4 actually. Then in Revival Savage again indicates that Maul has grown much more powerful.

So, no, Maul even by the time he actually returns is more powerful than he ever was.

Originally posted by TheIndyJedi
Got to admit Savage>TPM Maul had me laughing

This.

OT-Jinn.

Even if TPM Maul>Savage.

How do we know that Jinn>Savage?

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Even if TPM Maul>Savage.

How do we know that Jinn>Savage?

We don't know Jinn>Savage.

Originally posted by HP Legend
We don't know Jinn>Savage. Than why do you use the fact that Koon<Savage if Jinn<Savage as well?

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Than why do you use the fact that Koon<Savage if Jinn<Savage as well?

It's logical that given their performances against Savage and Maul were equal Jinn would be more powerful since Maul is more powerrful than Savage.

Maul didn't "struggle" with Jinn, no, but the idea remains that Jinn's feats against a superior duelist scale him above Plo Koon.

Originally posted by LordOfTheLight
Objective statements in SC note that Maul had returned more powerful by S4 actually. Then in Revival Savage again indicates that Maul has grown much more powerful.

So, no, Maul even by the time he actually returns is more powerful than he ever was.


What Objective statement? SC beings at the beginning of S5.

And Maul had trouble TKing a Lightsaber into his hand when he returned in S4