Match The Feat

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



abhilegend
Which of the below characters can match this feat?

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11112/111121634/6909095-6513416253-JUSTL.jpg
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11112/111121634/6909096-7829381646-JUSTL.jpg

1. Silver Surfer
2. Thor
3. Gladiator
4. World War Hulk
5. World Breaker Hulk
6. Thanos

Characters are at full power and they can destroy the planet by only jumping.

AlbertoJohnAvil
Anybody on that list

DarkSaint85
Alberto, please post their jumping feats.

Philosophía
Maybe WBH.

Maybe.

abhilegend
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Anybody on that list
Reason?

AlbertoJohnAvil
for one the planet size is unspecified, looks smaller than usual so doesn't matter

abhilegend
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
for one the planet size is unspecified, looks smaller than usual so doesn't matter
How does it look smaller and how doesn't it matter?

AlbertoJohnAvil
...by looking at the scan...

abhilegend
And what gave you the idea that the planet is small?

AlbertoJohnAvil
I don't do rhetorical questions

abhilegend
But you are fine with doing it yourself.

MrMind
none of them

abhilegend
Where is carver to say this isn't impressive?

AlbertoJohnAvil
The irony eh? Hit me up when you wanna do a feat war with one of the characters on the list

abhilegend
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
The irony eh? Hit me up when you wanna do a feat war with one of the characters on the list
Are you talking to me boy?

MrMind
beware the fusion Calverto

AlbertoJohnAvil
Originally posted by abhilegend
Are you talking to me boy? Yup

qwertyuiop1998
Some biases are always trying so hard to diminishing Supes feats with they imaginations

This comics never mentioned superman shattering planet was small

abhilegend
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Yup
Why don't you prove this first then? Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Anybody on that list

byrdgang21
If WBH could cause earthquakes with just a few steps. Id wager he could replicate that feat by punching the earth then jumping just as Supes did in the scan

Galan007
WBH is the only one on that list who *might* be able to match the feat of a grossly weakened/diminished Superman... But I'm not even fully confident that he could. Just think he has the best shot out of all them. /shrug

carver9
I'm not even going to comment on what I think of the ft but let's presume this is the size of an actual planet (and its not) are we really saying this is better than Hulk exhausting the power of In-Betweener whom power itself was destroying reality? Let's be real here and we are not even talking about the most powerful versions of Hulk. Hulk has even shaken an actual planet we know about by punching beings in the face and stomach and again, this isnt even the strongest versions of Hulk. Superman fans get to excited. Beta Ray Bill and Terrax have been destroying planets physically for the longest. The weakest form of Hulk destroyed an asteroid twice the size of Earth. All of them do it. WBH who is more powerful than any Hulk that has shaken planets just by punching beings and overpowered Abstracts, does it with his pinky toe.

carver9
Hell, Cho Hulk punched with enough force to destroy a Universe not to long ago.

qwertyuiop1998
Originally posted by carver9
I'm not even going to comment on what I think of the ft but let's presume this is the size of an actual planet (and its not) are we really saying this is better than Hulk exhausting the power of In-Betweener whom power itself was destroying reality? Let's be real here and we are not even talking about the most powerful versions of Hulk. Hulk has even shaken an actual planet we know about by punching beings in the face and stomach and again, this isnt even the strongest versions of Hulk. Superman fans get to excited. Beta Ray Bill and Terrax have been destroying planets physically for the longest. The weakest form of Hulk destroyed an asteroid twice the size of Earth. All of them do it. WBH who is more powerful than any Hulk that has shaken planets just by punching beings and overpowered Abstracts, does it with his pinky toe. Prove it was not the size of an actual planet.

DarkSaint85
Carver is an actual astronomer, he can tell you what a planet is and it's size.

Then he'll tell you what level Frankenstein is to Superman.

carver9
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Prove it was not the size of an actual planet.

Justice League #18 page 20. Justice League #21 page 4.

qwertyuiop1998
Originally posted by carver9
Justice League #18 page 20. Justice League #21 page 4. Why are you lying?
Justice league #18 was Lex talking with Brainiac about The Universe and human history story

Justice league #21 only mentioned WG creating a pocket universe to imprisoning Supes

carver9
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Why are you lying?
Justice league #18 was Lex talking with Brainiac about The Universe and human history story

Justice league #21 only mentioned WG creating a pocket universe to imprisoning Supes

I gave you the page numbers that gave me my decision on what I said. Observe it.

abhilegend
Originally posted by carver9
I'm not even going to comment on what I think of the ft but let's presume this is the size of an actual planet (and its not) are we really saying this is better than Hulk exhausting the power of In-Betweener whom power itself was destroying reality? Let's be real here and we are not even talking about the most powerful versions of Hulk. Hulk has even shaken an actual planet we know about by punching beings in the face and stomach and again, this isnt even the strongest versions of Hulk. Superman fans get to excited. Beta Ray Bill and Terrax have been destroying planets physically for the longest. The weakest form of Hulk destroyed an asteroid twice the size of Earth. All of them do it. WBH who is more powerful than any Hulk that has shaken planets just by punching beings and overpowered Abstracts, does it with his pinky toe. Originally posted by carver9
Hell, Cho Hulk punched with enough force to destroy a Universe not to long ago.
laughing out loud

There's carver.

Philosophía
Originally posted by carver9
Hell, Cho Hulk punched with enough force to destroy a Universe not to long ago. Who rebuilt the Universe after he destroyed it?

MrMind
scan of universe actually being destroyed by cho hulk?

qwertyuiop1998
Originally posted by carver9
I gave you the page numbers that gave me my decision on what I said. Observe it. Here is the JL #18 link
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Justice-League-2018/Issue-18?id=150237#18

Tell me Carver, Where did you got this planet was not an actual planet size?

And this is JL #21 link
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Justice-League-2018/Issue-21?id=152935
Again tell me Carver, Where did you pull out this planet wasn't a real planet size nonsense

carver9
@Phil,

Your response is like me asking you to show me the planet being destroyed. Both are statements. One made by a narrator and the other made by one of the most intelligent beings in the universe.

AlbertoJohnAvil
where it was stated to be an actual planet size?

carver9
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Here is the JL #18 link
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Justice-League-2018/Issue-18?id=150237#18

Tell me Carver, Where did you got this planet was not an actual planet size?

And this is JL #21 link
https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Justice-League-2018/Issue-21?id=152935
Again tell me Carver, Where did you pull out this planet wasn't a real planet size nonsense

Size, diameter, length, etc, etc... that doesnt matter though. For this thread, we are going to say it is an unknown planet size, a lot of the people on that list can achieve the ft. Let's stay on topic.

AlbertoJohnAvil
This is the first time Superman has ever destroyed a planet, which was small of course. don't act if those guys on that list hasn't done so a dozen times

Philosophía
Originally posted by carver9
@Phil,

Your response is like me asking you to show me the planet being destroyed. Both are statements. One made by a narrator and the other made by one of the most intelligent beings in the universe. What are you babbling about, Carverstein?

You said that Cho Hulk punched with enough force to destroy the Universe.

What Universe did he destroy?

Surely he actually destroyed something -- a galaxy cluster -- or a galaxy? Maybe a solar system? Maybe a sun? Maybe a planet?

Oh wait, he didn't even destroy a moon with the same punches?

Oh shit, Superman must've jumped with the power to destroy Megaverses here thumb up

Btw:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t661268.html

^Here, coward.

Stop being such a poopy pants and don't keep running away.

qwertyuiop1998
Originally posted by carver9
Size, diameter, length, etc, etc... that doesnt matter though. For this thread, we are going to say it is an unknown planet size, a lot of the people on that list can achieve the ft. Let's stay on topic.
Size, diameter, length, etc. etc
This Comics never mentioned them, So how did you got this planet was smaller than an actual planet?

Sensui
Originally posted by Galan007
WBH is the only one on that list who *might* be able to match the feat of a grossly weakened/diminished Superman... But I'm not even fully confident that he could. Just think he has the best shot out of all them. /shrug

Agreed. And the funny thing is...Hulk would HAVE TO BE at FULL POWER to maybe, maybe, pull the feat off.

Can you imagine the Hulk at HIS WEAKEST being shown to shatter a planet like that?

Grossly Weak Superman > WBH now confirmed.

Philosophía
Weakened Superman would drop kick Hulk's head so hard it would decapitate the other Hulks.

DarkSaint85
It's a planet. So according to carver, it wasn't the size of a planet.

Lmao

carver9
@Phil...

We received info telling us how much was used to achieve what Cho did. Destructive forces are never an indication of what actually took play, we were literally told what happened. And you mentioning the moon being destroyed during Cho scene; I'm not seeing a planet being destroyed during Superman jump. Lol. Also, how big is that planet.

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It's a planet. So according to carver, it wasn't the size of a planet.

Lmao

All planets are the same size? Thor was shattering planets with the shockwave of his hits from a distance.

carver9
Originally posted by Sensui
Agreed. And the funny thing is...Hulk would HAVE TO BE at FULL POWER to maybe, maybe, pull the feat off.

Can you imagine the Hulk at HIS WEAKEST being shown to shatter a planet like that?

Grossly Weak Superman > WBH now confirmed.

He wasnt at full power when he destroyed an asteroid twice the size of Earth. Not even close.

Galan007
^ That also wasn't just a brute strength feat. Not even close.

Philosophía
Originally posted by carver9
@Phil...

We received info telling us how much was used to achieve what Cho did. Destructive forces are never an indication of what actually took play, we were literally told what happened. And you mentioning the moon being destroyed during Cho scene; I'm not seeing a planet being destroyed during Superman jump. Lol. Also, how big is that planet. Cho 'achieved' a double-fisting of moon that didn't even break it. Superman on his death bed jumped light-years and shattered the planet.

Superman >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Superman on his death bed >>>>>>> Planet >>>>>>>>>> Moon >>>>>>> Cho Hulk

Random statements not supported by what's happening on panel showings don't mean anything.

Otherwise Cyborg (who can generate 1,000,000 decibels: http://i.imgur.com/CxUGBON.jpg) >>>>>>>>>> Owlman>>>> Power Ring >>>> Johnny Quick >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WBH >>>>>> all other Hulks

Supergirl (who can tank a billion decibels: http://i.imgur.com/GAhEcVL.jpg) >>>>>>>Silver Banshee >>>>>>>>>> Omniverse >>>>>> Cyborg >>>> WBH >>>>>> all other Hulks

Superman >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> weakened Superman >>>>> Weakened Superman's legs >>>>>>> WBH >>>> every Hulk.

Before I forget..

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t661268.html
^Here, coward.

Stop being such a poopy pants and don't keep running away.

carver9
Originally posted by Galan007
^ That also wasn't just a brute strength feat. Not even close.

It was literally said in the comic that Hulk STRENGTH played a factor.

Philosophía
Originally posted by carver9
He wasnt at full power when he destroyed an asteroid twice the size of Earth. Not even close. He didn't destroy the asteroid under his own power, the same way your head didn't destroy the neighbour's car by its lonesome, when it was your mother who threw you it from the 7th story.

Carver's mom throwing carver >>>>>>>>>>> Carver's momentum >>> Car >>>>>> Carver's neck strength

carver9
Phil, you're literally repping a statement of an unknown even since (here's the important part), we...do...not...see...the...small...moon appearance...planet...destroyed. lol

Philosophía
Originally posted by carver9
Phil, you're literally repping a statement of an unknown even since (here's the important part), we...do...not...see...the...small...moon appearance...planet...destroyed. lol Being able to think rationally >>>>>> Being able to see clearly >>>> Being able to read comics >>>>>>> Being able to understand a panel with absolutely zero ambiguity = https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11112/111121634/6909096-7829381646-JUSTL.jpg >>>>> being incapable of destroying a moon = Cho >>>>>>>> being able to understand statements are a dime a dozen and actual feats matter >>>>>> being incapable of rational though >>>>>>> brain damage >>>>>> cowardice >>>>>>> carver9

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t661268.html
Carver, why are you such a coward?

SquallX

Senor Cage
laughing out loud

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
It was literally said in the comic that Hulk STRENGTH played a factor. Entire scene:
http://i.imgur.com/gHSSIhb.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xbR7212.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/gfL4Fg7.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/wmWkzxc.jpg

As you can see, the rocket springs catapulted Hulk 'faster and farther than ever before.' They propelled him with such force/speed, in fact, that he didn't even begin slowing down until AFTER he busted through the asteroid(last scan)... Which means he was moving really fast.

Suffice to say: Hulk was essentially a bullet shot out of a gun in that scene. Calling it solely a brute strength feat is, well, wrong. Did it require a a good deal of strength/durability? Sure. But compositional differences aside, is it remotely comparable to walking up to a mass twice the size of earth and destroying it with a single punch? Absolutely not. The added force/speed/velocity gained from the rocket springs was detrimental to the feat. This is unarguable.

playa1258
None can do it.

Philosophía

carver9
Originally posted by Galan007
Entire scene:
http://i.imgur.com/gHSSIhb.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xbR7212.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/gfL4Fg7.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/wmWkzxc.jpg

As you can see, the rocket springs catapulted Hulk 'faster and farther than ever before.' They propelled him with such force/speed, in fact, that he didn't even begin slowing down until AFTER he busted through the asteroid(last scan)... Which means he was moving really fast.

Suffice to say: Hulk was essentially a bullet shot out of a gun in that scene. Calling it solely a brute strength feat is, well, wrong. Did it require a a good deal of strength/durability? Sure. But compositional differences aside, is it remotely comparable to walking up to a mass twice the size of earth and destroying it with a single punch? Absolutely not. The added force/speed/velocity gained from the rocket springs was detrimental to the feat. This is unarguable.

It literally tells you in the second scan that his STRENGTH combined with the device assisted in this. And then right after that it's stated that he received LITTLE assistance from the device. Cant get any clearer than this. Then they went to the Hulk because he was the only one STRONG enough to pull this off.

Galan007
https://i.imgur.com/BmYHrO6.jpg

abhilegend
Originally posted by carver9
@Phil...

We received info telling us how much was used to achieve what Cho did. Destructive forces are never an indication of what actually took play, we were literally told what happened. And you mentioning the moon being destroyed during Cho scene; I'm not seeing a planet being destroyed during Superman jump. Lol. Also, how big is that planet.
How is the planet not destroyed in the Superman scene?

playa1258
Just imagine the reaction if Superman beats Doctor Manhattan. This feat alone has the anti-Superman crowd ordering record numbers of razor blades.

StiltmanFTW
King Kai sized planet stick out tongue

Made out of shit weaker than shadow shit

Superman is Grundy's f#ckdoll still

Weak feat

quanchi112
Originally posted by playa1258
Just imagine the reaction if Superman beats Doctor Manhattan. This feat alone has the anti-Superman crowd ordering record numbers of razor blades. You will ignore the context. No one really cares it will change nothing. Bias on both sides is all too real.

Philosophía
Originally posted by Galan007
https://i.imgur.com/BmYHrO6.jpg One of my all time favorite posts from a fellow Hulk fan:

Originally posted by psycho gundam
The more Carver posts the more evidence mounts that would probably get me out of prison when my defense shows the judge his posting history. I have no doubt his murder by strangulation would be deemed justifiable, they might even pat me on the back after

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
It literally tells you in the second scan that his STRENGTH combined with the device assisted in this. And then right after that it's stated that he received LITTLE assistance from the device. Cant get any clearer than this. Then they went to the Hulk because he was the only one STRONG enough to pull this off. carver, Hulk was propelled at such ridiculous speed that colliding with an asteroid 2x larger than earth didn't even begin to slow him down.

What has the potential to cause more damage: me physically throwing a bullet at your head, or me putting that same bullet into a gun and firing it at your head?

...Now tell me *why* that is, ol' chum. thumb up

Bentley
Originally posted by quanchi112
You will ignore the context. No one really cares it will change nothing. Bias on both sides is all too real.


I care and as long as Batman doesn't come into the picture I'm unbiased.

Magnon
Originally posted by Galan007
Entire scene:
http://i.imgur.com/gHSSIhb.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xbR7212.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/gfL4Fg7.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/wmWkzxc.jpg

We can also clearly see that the asteroid Hulk destroyed was NOT spherical i.e. its mass was too low to cause a gravitational collapse into a sphere. This means that its mass is at most ca. 0.01% of the Earth's mass. When such a mass is distributed in a volume twice the size of the Earth you will get an object that is likely very weak and fragile.

On the other hand, the planet Superman destroyed was clearly spherical in shape and thus much more massive than the Hulk's asteroid.

carver9
Originally posted by Magnon
We can also clearly see that the asteroid Hulk destroyed was NOT spherical i.e. its mass was too low to cause a gravitational collapse into a sphere. This means that its mass is at most ca. 0.01% of the Earth's mass. When such a mass is distributed in a volume twice the size of the Earth you will get an object that is likely very weak and fragile.

On the other hand, the planet Superman destroyed was clearly spherical in shape and thus much more massive than the Hulk's asteroid.

How big was that planet and how durable was it? Was it hollow internally? Show proof and show me it being destroyed. Thanks in advance.

carver9
Originally posted by Galan007
carver, Hulk was propelled at such ridiculous speed that colliding with an asteroid 2x larger than earth didn't even begin to slow him down.

What has the potential to cause more damage: me physically throwing a bullet at your head, or me putting that same bullet into a gun and firing it at your head?

...Now tell me *why* that is, ol' chum. thumb up

Come on Galan. It clearly states that the machine helped him a "little" bit and his strength was a key to him destroying the asteroid. It can not get any clearer than this. You're basically arguing with what is said on panel vs getting your point across. Was it said that Hulk strength (more than once) is a key factor in this? Yes!!! Was it said that the propeller assisted in Hulk destroying the asteroid? Yes!!! But a little of assistance.

carver9
Originally posted by playa1258
Just imagine the reaction if Superman beats Doctor Manhattan. This feat alone has the anti-Superman crowd ordering record numbers of razor blades.

What I've seen in the past 5 PLUS yrs.

"Just imagine if Superman beats the team up of Mongul, Zod, etc... by himself". Neer happened. "Just imagine if Superman beats H'el by himself". Nope, never happened. Imagine Superman coming back to beat Rao who is defined with all of the Kryptonian power". Never happened. Let's add this to the list because at this point, he need this victory since he haven't beaten anyone worth noting for the past 5 or 6 yrs (probably longer). Ain't that right, ABHI?

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
Come on Galan. It clearly states that the machine helped him a "little" bit and his strength was a key to him destroying the asteroid. It can not get any clearer than this. You're basically arguing with what is said on panel vs getting your point across. Was it said that Hulk strength (more than once) is a key factor in this? Yes!!! Was it said that the propeller assisted in Hulk destroying the asteroid? Yes!!! But a little of assistance. Hulk's strength/durability *was* "a key" to preforming the feat -- I said as much several posts ago. He could not have preformed the feat if he weren't strong and durable. No one is saying that your average human could have done the same thing, lol.

However, the rocket springs clearly helped Hulk far more than just "a little", as evident by the fact that they propelled him SO ridiculously fast that colliding with an object 2x larger than earth didn't even BEGIN to slow him down. So again: the added force/speed/velocity gained from the rocket springs was obviously detrimental to the feat itself. This is unarguable.

What I'm saying is that it is not a quantifiable strength feat. There is NO evidence to suggest that Hulk could have destroyed the same asteroid without the assistance of the rocket springs.

Magnon
Originally posted by carver9
How big was that planet and how durable was it? Was it hollow internally? Show proof and show me it being destroyed. Thanks in advance.
There's not enough information in those panels to answer your questions exactly. Pretty much the only thing we can say with absolute certainty is that the planet Superman destroyed was MUCH MORE massive than the asteroid Hulk destroyed.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
All planets are the same size? Thor was shattering planets with the shockwave of his hits from a distance.

What does that have to do with anything, lol.

If it's a planet, by definition, it's planet size lmao.

carver9
Originally posted by Magnon
There's not enough information in those panels to answer your questions exactly. Pretty much the only thing we can say with absolute certainty is that the planet Superman destroyed was MUCH MORE massive than the asteroid Hulk destroyed.

It was? How massive was the planet Superman damaged?

StiltmanFTW
King Kai

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
I'm not even going to comment on what I think of the ft but let's presume this is the size of an actual planet (and its not)

Prove its NOT the size of an actual planet, please.

MrMind
Originally posted by quanchi112
You will ignore the context. No one really cares it will change nothing. Bias on both sides is all too real.

the irony of quanchi calling people bias laughing out loud

you are a living example of why abortion should be legal

playa1258
Donald Trump should sign an executive order deporting Quan's father naked to the Taliban for not pulling out.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Prove its NOT the size of an actual planet, please.

Planets come in many sizes.

Pluto was considered one, too.

Superman failed to impress his readers once again, Abhi is on his knees, praying to Ganesha and wiping my ******* with his Superman cape from cosplays.

Abhi's tonsil stones were planets, too. I shattered them with my penis.

#superstiltman

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Prove its NOT the size of an actual planet, please.

"However, not all of the moons are smaller than all of the planets. There are seven moons in our Solar System, including our own Moon, that are larger than Pluto. Jupiter's moon Ganymede is the largest moon in the Solar System, and Ganymede as well as Saturn's moon Titan are both larger than Mercury and Pluto".

What size are we talking here because there are moons that are bigger than planets?

smile

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
"However, not all of the moons are smaller than all of the planets. There are seven moons in our Solar System, including our own Moon, that are larger than Pluto. Jupiter's moon Ganymede is the largest moon in the Solar System, and Ganymede as well as Saturn's moon Titan are both larger than Mercury and Pluto".

What size are we talking here because there are moons that are bigger than planets?

smile

But....it's a planet. So sure, it could be a small planet.....but by it's very definition, it's planet size.

Like dogs can be small or large dogs. Some cats (tigers, for example) are larger than dogs.

But a Chihuahua is still dog sized. Because it's a fricking dog lol.

How are you so stupid lmao.

Btw: Pluto is a dwarf planet. Just an fyi. That object Superman destroyed was NOT called a dwarf planet. So at the very least, we can say it was bigger than Pluto smile

Philosophía
The planet was so massive/dense, that Superman couldn't reach escape velocity even when he first step foot in there.
https://s7d6.turboimg.net/t/41201988_IkXEvFu.jpg https://s7d6.turboimg.net/t/41201989_R0Rb3AB.jpg https://s7d6.turboimg.net/t/41201990_jDZgEvD.jpg https://s7d6.turboimg.net/t/41201991_yLgT9RD.jpg

By comparison, on Earth, even young 'Golden Age' Supes easily does it:
https://s7d3.turboimg.net/t/41201992_5559036-runs20at20252C00020mph201.jpg https://s7d3.turboimg.net/t/41201993_5559037-runs20at20252C00020mph202.jpg https://s7d3.turboimg.net/t/41201994_5559038-runs20at20252C00020mph203.jpg

The planet was made by a Multiversal being to not let him escape. Suffice to say, it is created to be far above any planet in our solar system - since even Jupiter only has about 5 times Earth's escape velocity:
https://i.imgur.com/6qNi43f.png

darthgoober
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But....it's a planet. So sure, it could be a small planet.....but by it's very definition, it's planet size.

Like dogs can be small or large dogs. Some cats (tigers, for example) are larger than dogs.

But a Chihuahua is still dog sized. Because it's a fricking dog lol.

How are you so stupid lmao.

Btw: Pluto is a dwarf planet. Just an fyi. That object Superman destroyed was NOT called a dwarf planet. So at the very least, we can say it was bigger than Pluto smile
Yeah but it's not being called a dwarf planet doesn't actually mean too much. When they're talking about Martinex the on panel narration(at least in general) says he's from the planet Pluto, not the dwarf planet Pluto.

Personally I have no problem with acknowledging that the feat is impressive, but I don'y know why so many people(not you) have suddenly flipped their stance on planets. Not knowing how big a planet is, how dense a planet is, etc. are all things that Supes's fans have been questioning to no end for years before Supes's springboard in an effort to downplay the feats of other characters...

celeyhyga17
Nyone on that list could prolly do it

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Planets come in many sizes.

Pluto was considered one, too.



This is as stupid as saying 'Cap America (or any other character) is as strong as 10 men' then saying 'Oh, men come in all sizes, so let's assume they're all 10 sick men, or 10 midgets, or 10 sick old midgets with no arms' or some stupidity.

Let's lowball Phildo's comics, and use RL logic.

https://www.quora.com/Which-is-the-average-planet-size-in-the-universe-approx

This is the average size of planets in the Universe:
https://i.postimg.cc/52LQ7QxT/main-qimg-acb7a1700ba8ada112d899ed038e83e0.png

See that? There's a peak at around 2.4/2.5 times Earth size.

So lowballing, with RL science, we get 2.4 times the size of Earth. Using lowballig, with comics, we get about 5x the size of Earth.

At the very least, we can get to Earth size.

abhilegend

abhilegend
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Nyone on that list could prolly do it
Anyone? Prove it.

abhilegend

Damborgson
Just world breaker

celeyhyga17
Originally posted by abhilegend
Anyone? Prove it.
Using what..? Breaking planet feats? Jumping?



Oh wait.. Surfer's here..? Not sure about him.

Other than him, everyone on the list had had some ridiculous showing of strength and durability. Wouldn't be surprised if they do something similar

Magnon
Originally posted by carver9
It was? How massive was the planet Superman damaged?
The mass of the PLANET Superman DESTROYED was somewhere between 0.03 to 6000 Earth masses, because:

- if it was smaller than that it wouldn't be called a planet but e.g. an ASTEROID (the thing Hulk destroyed was an asteroid)

- if it was larger than that it would be called e.g. a star, dwarf star or neutron star, depending on its properties.

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But....it's a planet. So sure, it could be a small planet.....but by it's very definition, it's planet size.

Like dogs can be small or large dogs. Some cats (tigers, for example) are larger than dogs.

But a Chihuahua is still dog sized. Because it's a fricking dog lol.

How are you so stupid lmao.

Btw: Pluto is a dwarf planet. Just an fyi. That object Superman destroyed was NOT called a dwarf planet. So at the very least, we can say it was bigger than Pluto smile

Kid, calm down. Anyways, the size of that small looking planet is unknown. There's no taking away from this. We do not know the density or anything of said planet. Looking at the panels, it looks extremely small. Blame the artist, not me.

Galan007
You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is currently stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison planet' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?

But here we are, arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity...the being who literally created all physical bodies in the DC multiverse(ie. World Forger)...must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid to trap Superman on here, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level...cuz reasons?

Lol. This 'logic' will never cease to amuse me. smile

carver9
Originally posted by Magnon
The mass of the PLANET Superman DESTROYED was somewhere between 0.03 to 6000 Earth masses, because:

- if it was smaller than that it wouldn't be called a planet but e.g. an ASTEROID (the thing Hulk destroyed was an asteroid)

- if it was larger than that it would be called e.g. a star, dwarf star or neutron star, depending on its properties.

Are you sure? Can you show the inside of the planet not being hollow? Example, the planet Bills destroyed is clearly in every perspective a planet by looking at it....

https://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11120/111202308/5199437-1.jpg

Can you show me the same?

Philosophía
Originally posted by Galan007
You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes that Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?

...But here were are arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity -- the being who literally created everything in the DC multiverse(World Forger) must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid for Superman to stay trapped in for some reason, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level.

This logic will never cease to be amusing to me. smile Galan, World Forger obviously cleaned the whole pocked Universe of Suns and had trials with a shitload of Supermen to make sure it's inescapable on a, uhmmm...<= Earth sized planet, obviously...

edit: right above this post, Carver is arguing the planet is hollow.

I legitimately can't believe some people are in the same species.

abhilegend
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Using what..? Breaking planet feats? Jumping?



Oh wait.. Surfer's here..? Not sure about him.

Other than him, everyone on the list had had some ridiculous showing of strength and durability. Wouldn't be surprised if they do something similar
Post those feats then.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
Kid, calm down. Anyways, the size of that small looking planet is unknown. There's no taking away from this. We do not know the density or anything of said planet. Looking at the panels, it looks extremely small. Blame the artist, not me.

So we all agree it's planet sized? Step by step little Carver smile

We've at least moved on from your first statement on this subject lmao.

xJLxKing

Galan007
^ That's not really an argument against what I was saying.

Seems like we both agree that the planet/galaxy World Forger created to trap Superman in, was designed with the sole intent of making this 'prison' as inescapable as possible. Therefore it is absolutely idiotic to try and pretend like the planet was made out of paper mache or some shit.

carver9
Originally posted by Galan007
You guys realize that World Forger doesn't want Superman to ever escape that world because he believes Superman's existence in the mainstream reality will ultimately bring about the end of ALL existence, right? You realize that he created the entire galaxy Superman is currently stuck in, and positioned all the planets/stars within it accordingly, just to make the 'prison planet' as inescapable as he possibly could, right?

But here we are, arguing that this fully multiversal, hyper-dimensional entity...the being who literally created all physical bodies in the DC multiverse(ie. World Forger)...must've just created a dwarf, hollow, and overall fragile planetoid to trap Superman on here, despite being intimately familiar with everything Superman represents on a fundamental level...cuz reasons?

Lol. This 'logic' will never cease to amuse me. smile

He also pointed Superman in another direction that had food, etc... for him. He asked Superman to go the other way vs jumping to the light and Superman declined it. That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him.

Also, when I posted this...

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/13/136540/3016411-3817689242-28568.jpg

Abhi declined it because of this dimension being connected to a door. He said that since we see a pathway that takes us (directed at ABHI) through this dimension, everything within it must be small. Why are you accepting this showing ABHI even though a doorway was used to get here?

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him. Proof that you've not read the issues right here.

World Forger absolutely did NOT want Superman to escape from that planet. Ever.

carver9
Originally posted by Galan007
Proof that you've not read the issues right here.

World Forger absolutely did NOT want Superman to escape from that planet. Ever.

Who said anything about leaving? Here he tells Superman there is a cosmic garden on the other side with for you with food, etc...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202023/Screenshot_20190527-153216_Chrome.jpg.html

Maybe I'm reading this wrong but he is telling Superman that he have what he needs there but NOT where his friends are at.

ShadowFyre
I think its impressive and that they could all break a planet with their legs, but I dont necessarily see Thor ir Surfer doing it as a side effect of flying vecause they dont fly that way

Worldbreaker Hulk shoukd be able to surpass this quite easily.

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
Maybe I'm reading this wrong thumb up

Magnon
Originally posted by carver9
Are you sure? Can you show the inside of the planet not being hollow? Example, the planet Bills destroyed is clearly in every perspective a planet by looking at it....

https://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11120/111202308/5199437-1.jpg

Can you show me the same?
I already answered your question earlier in this thread. Here, in case you've forgotten:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=16911980&highlight=userid%3A137215#post16911980

carver9
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
I think its impressive and that they could all break a planet with their legs, but I dont necessarily see Thor ir Surfer doing it as a side effect of flying vecause they dont fly that way

Worldbreaker Hulk shoukd be able to surpass this quite easily.

Thor was hitting Gor in the face cracking nearby planets. He will do just fine.

carver9
Originally posted by Magnon
I already answered your question earlier in this thread. Here, in case you've forgotten:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=16911980&highlight=userid%3A137215#post16911980

You also said you cant provide proof. smile

Thanks anyways though.

celeyhyga17
Originally posted by abhilegend
Post those feats then.
Dunno which ones? *shrug*
I'm sure u already know them anyway.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by Magnon
There's not enough information in those panels to answer your questions exactly. Pretty much the only thing we can say with absolute certainty is that the planet Superman destroyed was MUCH MORE massive than the asteroid Hulk destroyed.

We have a pretty good idea.

We know it has an escape velocity greater than Earth, because Superman....Well, can't escape.

So it has a massive amount of gravity.

Now, as Carver asserts, it's a small planet. Which, as D =M/V tells us, means that this tiny planet must have a massive density, in order to have enough mass to create a gravitational field strong enough to hold Superman.

Do we all see where I'm getting at? Assuming it's 1/2 Earth size, yet keeping 2x the gravity of Earth, means that the hollow shell (assuming it's hollow) is still incredibly dense, and thus, much more durable than Earth.

Carver cannot have it both ways. The constant is that it's strong enough to keep Superman there. So if it's a small planet, it's super dense and thus, super durable.

Unless he wants to change his tune and claim it's a super large planet, lol.

darthgoober
Wait a sec, this whole thing took place on a planet specifically designed to hold Supes, in a whole pocket universe designed to hold/weaken him, by a virtually omnipotent/omniscient being? That does kinda throw shade on the whole thing depending on what all happened after it. Not on the magnitude of impressiveness, but it does seem like it might bring it more into the realm of an unquantifiable scenereo that's actually showcasing something other than strength or something like that. I haven't read the issue and have no awareness of it outside the threads posted here so it's very possible that none of that is applicable, if so just ignore me.

carver9
Lol... it was designed just for him. No sunlight, nothing. Crazy thing is, an untold amount of Supermen died there...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202046/Screenshot_20190527-160032_Chrome.jpg.html
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202047/Screenshot_20190527-160055_Chrome.jpg.html

It even states it isnt meant to escape. Explains why the guy is struggling.

darthgoober
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
We have a pretty good idea.

We know it has an escape velocity greater than Earth, because Superman....Well, can't escape.

So it has a massive amount of gravity.

Now, as Carver asserts, it's a small planet. Which, as D =M/V tells us, means that this tiny planet must have a massive density, in order to have enough mass to create a gravitational field strong enough to hold Superman.

Do we all see where I'm getting at? Assuming it's 1/2 Earth size, yet keeping 2x the gravity of Earth, means that the hollow shell (assuming it's hollow) is still incredibly dense, and thus, much more durable than Earth.

Carver cannot have it both ways. The constant is that it's strong enough to keep Superman there. So if it's a small planet, it's super dense and thus, super durable.

Unless he wants to change his tune and claim it's a super large planet, lol.
Yeah it would actually makes more sense for it to be super dense/durable. The reason Jupiter only has two and a half times Earth's gravity despite being much more massive, is because the surface of the planet is so far from the center of the planet. I'm not trying to claim that it's small or anything, but when you're dealing with increased gravity on a planet ultra denseness is a pretty safe bet.

DarkSaint85
Wait so is Carver arguing it was designed to hold him or not?

Damborgson
Um, wouldn't that make it even more impressive?

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by darthgoober
Yeah it would actually makes more sense for it to be super dense/durable. The reason Jupiter only has two and a half times Earth's gravity despite being much more massive, is because the surface of the planet is so far from the center of the planet. I'm not trying to claim that it's small or anything, but when you're dealing with increased gravity on a planet ultra denseness is a pretty safe bet.

thumb up

Carver is now in my trap.

Carver, is it a small tiny planet?

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
thumb up

Carver is now in my trap.

Carver, is it a small tiny planet?

What I'm saying is, the planet IS small. He is struggling to escape because he is depleted of power, not fully depleted but just enough for him to not be able to get off said planet. It even states in the same pages that his bones are starving. What I am saying is, 1. The planet is tiny based off what I've seen. 2. Hes struggling to get off said planet due to him being near exhausted and 3. Using a lot of people arguments here, there's no proof the planet was fully destroyed.

#3 can be overlooked.

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
thumb up

Carver is now in my trap.

Carver, is it a small tiny planet?

Your trap is lame because we dont know what all is taking place there since we know nothing of that pocket dimension.

playa1258
Superman is the lifeblood of KMC.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
What I'm saying is, the planet IS small. He is struggling to escape because he is depleted of power, not fully depleted but just enough for him to not be able to get off said planet. It even states in the same pages that his bones are starving. What I am saying is, 1. The planet is tiny based off what I've seen. 2. Hes struggling to get off said planet due to him being near exhausted and 3. Using a lot of people arguments here, there's no proof the planet was fully destroyed.

#3 can be overlooked.

Of course #3 can be overlooked, the text literally says the planet was shattered lmao. As for the other points?

#2? The very first time he tried to escape, he falls back.

So the gravity is already too strong for him. Even before he starts starving.

#1 just means the planet is super durable lmao. If you want to continue to insist it was tiny (and PLANET SIZED, lmao) then it was an incredibly dense (and thus, super durable ) planet.

The size is actually less important. A kg of feathers and a kg of iron....The kg of feathers will occupy a larger space than the kg of iron of course, but shattering a kg ball of iron is way more impressive.

Thanks smile

quanchi112
Originally posted by playa1258
Donald Trump should sign an executive order deporting Quan's father naked to the Taliban for not pulling out. Triggered.

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Of course #3 can be overlooked, the text literally says the planet was shattered lmao. As for the other points?

#2? The very first time he tried to escape, he falls back.

So the gravity is already too strong for him. Even before he starts starving.

#1 just means the planet is super durable lmao. If you want to continue to insist it was tiny (and PLANET SIZED, lmao) then it was an incredibly dense (and thus, super durable ) planet.

The size is actually less important. A kg of feathers and a kg of iron....The kg of feathers will occupy a larger space than the kg of iron of course, but shattering a kg ball of iron is way more impressive.

Thanks smile

It SAID that it was destroyed just like it SAID Cho punch generated enough Force to take out a universe.

He did fail to escape the planet the first couple of jumps. His last jump basically shows and insist that he put more power into it. Lol.

The gravity wasnt too strong for him, he was just to weak to escape.

I think you're getting the pages mixed up when it mentioned his bones was starving. Reread the book please

cdtm
Blowing up King Kai's planet is nothing, because it's tiny. Never mind that it's so dense, the gravity is ten times that of Earth.


Carv should know better then anyone that planet size means nothing.

quanchi112
Originally posted by playa1258
Superman is the lifeblood of KMC. Nah.

carver9
Originally posted by cdtm
Blowing up King Kai's planet is nothing, because it's tiny. Never mind that it's so dense, the gravity is ten times that of Earth.


Carv should know better then anyone that planet size means nothing.

Who said anything about gravity here though? Look at my argument. I am literally saying he is too weak to achieve what he wanted to achieve and he only exceeded his previous attempts by adding more power to his legs. mad

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
It SAID that it was destroyed just like it SAID Cho punch generated enough Force to take out a universe.

He did fail to escape the planet the first couple of jumps. His last jump basically shows and insist that he put more power into it. Lol.

The gravity wasnt too strong for him, he was just to weak to escape.

I think you're getting the pages mixed up when it mentioned his bones was starving. Reread the book please

The effects were also shown.

Were the effects of Cho's punches shown?

Ermm..

https://s7d6.turboimg.net/t/41201988_IkXEvFu.jpg

Literally shows him too weak to fly. He's falling down. Unless this is one of ypur arguments where Superman WANTED to fall or somesuch?

A few panels later, he's shown to be starving....what pages am I getting mixed up?

Is WF trying to imprison him or nah?

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
hat planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him.


Originally posted by carver9
Lol... it was designed just for him. No sunlight, nothing. Crazy thing is, an untold amount of Supermen died there...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202046/Screenshot_20190527-160032_Chrome.jpg.html
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202047/Screenshot_20190527-160055_Chrome.jpg.html

It even states it isnt meant to escape. Explains why the guy is struggling.

So is it a prison or not?

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him. Originally posted by carver9
Lol... it was designed just for him. No sunlight, nothing. Crazy thing is, an untold amount of Supermen died there...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202046/Screenshot_20190527-160032_Chrome.jpg.html
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/41202047/Screenshot_20190527-160055_Chrome.jpg.html

It even states it isnt meant to escape. Explains why the guy is struggling. https://i.imgur.com/NOBBkZd.jpg

DarkSaint85
There's something about Britney and wigs here, but I can't quite put my finger on it....

DarkSaint85
Here's what's so hilarious about this thread.

If I said I ate a ham the size of a car, apparently according to Stilt, Carver and Alberto (amongst others) it's not that impressive.

Because cars come in different sizes, so since we can't pinpoint the EXACT dimensions of said car, the ham eating is a non feat.

Then, we all forget that Superman did this whilst EXTREMELY weakened. IOW, everyone is trying to equate their pet characters......to a Superman who was essentially dying.

carver9
We are not just going to give a planet the biggest size just because you feel tend to overhype DC characters. The size is unknown but looking at the scans, it appears to be a small planet. Cry about it all you want but it looks small AH. Sorry.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
We are not just going to give a planet the biggest size just because you feel tend to overhype DC characters. The size is unknown but looking at the scans, it appears to be a small planet. Cry about it all you want but it looks small AH. Sorry.

But is it a prison????

And nobody said biggest size? Are you drunk? And where does Frankenstein fit in these power levels??

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But is it a prison????

And nobody said biggest size? Are you drunk? And where does Frankenstein fit in these power levels??

It's set up to prevent Superman from escaping. I've told you this before, stop asking me the same questions.

Where do you think he belongs powerwise then I will answer it.

abhilegend
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Dunno which ones? *shrug*
I'm sure u already know them anyway.
Where these characters destroy a planet by just jumping? Show us please.

abhilegend
So what's Carter's argument now? Hard to keep track.

abhilegend
Originally posted by carver9
He also pointed Superman in another direction that had food, etc... for him. He asked Superman to go the other way vs jumping to the light and Superman declined it. That planet wasnt meant for him to remain on, it was a starting point for him.

Also, when I posted this...

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/13/136540/3016411-3817689242-28568.jpg

Abhi declined it because of this dimension being connected to a door. He said that since we see a pathway that takes us (directed at ABHI) through this dimension, everything within it must be small. Why are you accepting this showing ABHI even though a doorway was used to get here?
What the **** are you talking about?

TheHulkster
Doesn't he punch it first to begin it cracking? It's not only from jumping.

abhilegend
Originally posted by TheHulkster
Doesn't he punch it first to begin it cracking? It's not only from jumping.
He pushes his fist in the ground. Probably a homage to Henry Cavill flying scene.

TheHulkster
The sound effect of "BOOM" doesn't fit a push. It appears that the tactic is to destroy then planet in order to eliminate the gravity pull. So he punches it first before pushing off.

SquallX

abhilegend
Originally posted by TheHulkster
The sound effect of "BOOM" doesn't fit a push. It appears that the tactic is to destroy then planet in order to eliminate the gravity pull. So he punches it first before pushing off.
Except the "punch" didn't even make a craters in the ground and the planet is shattered by the jump.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
It's set up to prevent Superman from escaping. I've told you this before, stop asking me the same questions.

Where do you think he belongs powerwise then I will answer it.

That sounds like a prison to me. But earlier you said it wasn't? I'm very confused.

I don't know. That's why I keep asking you. I don't think he's on Superman's level, especially for a BZ, but you say yes?

qwertyuiop1998
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
where it was stated to be an actual planet size? It stated was a planet, That is enough to say it was a planet size since as far as we see there is no evidence to contradiction it

For example, If a comic said one object is an apple then we know this object is an apple, And when you said it was not apple then you are the one should prove it

DarkSaint85
Yeah the other two are just being stupid, lol.

I mean, Carver gets all jizzy over Gladiator and his dead rock.

AND Glads needed several hits. AND he wasn't half dead....

Laminator_X
I think the whole premise here is out of whack for a few different reasons. If you're enjoying having a "How many angels could dance on the head of a pin?" discussion, please ignore my thread-crapping.

What is shown there is out of step with how superman's flight power is usually shown to work. Comics are not always consistent, of course, but it makes it hard to draw meaningful comparisons.


Putting that aside, this event is solidly in the realm of Comic Book Physics, it's Rule of Cool driven event.

Pushing off something so hard that it breaks apart doesn't propel you any faster, and is quite likely less effective ordinary jumping would be. It's like suddenly flooring your gas-pedal on a gravel road, your tires spin and dirt and rocks fly out behind you, but you don't actually accelerate very efficiently.

Even if he's pushing with his leg muscles with so much sudden impulse that even as he's pushing off the planet the counter-force is such that his foot makes the rock underneath him move faster than the speed-of-sound-through-rock, that "planet" would have to be structured very differently than anything we're aware of to break apart like that.

While it's fine to have a "Heracles wrestles the river to make it change course and flow through the stables." sort of story-telling in a comic book, it's not something you can really use as a basis for rigorous comparisons to anything else, since it's not based on any sort of rules we understand, other than the Rule of Cool.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by Laminator_X
I think the whole premise here is out of whack for a few different reasons. If you're enjoying having a "How many angels could dance on the head of a pin?" discussion, please ignore my thread-crapping.

What is shown there is out of step with how superman's flight power is usually shown to work. Comics are not always consistent, of course, but it makes it hard to draw meaningful comparisons.


Putting that aside, this event is solidly in the realm of Comic Book Physics, it's Rule of Cool driven event.

Pushing off something so hard that it breaks apart doesn't propel you any faster, and is quite likely less effective ordinary jumping would be. It's like suddenly flooring your gas-pedal on a gravel road, your tires spin and dirt and rocks fly out behind you, but you don't actually accelerate very efficiently.

Even if he's pushing with his leg muscles with so much sudden impulse that even as he's pushing off the planet the counter-force is such that his foot makes the rock underneath him move faster than the speed-of-sound-through-rock, that "planet" would have to be structured very differently than anything we're aware of to break apart like that.

While it's fine to have a "Heracles wrestles the river to make it change course and flow through the stables." sort of story-telling in a comic book, it's not something you can really use as a basis for rigorous comparisons to anything else, since it's not based on any sort of rules we understand, other than the Rule of Cool.

Too true.

However, for the premises of this thread, it SHOULD be somewhat comparable, as we're using comic characters who are equally 'cool', who also violate RL logic through comic physics.

Laminator_X
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Too true.

However, for the premises of this thread, it SHOULD be somewhat comparable, as we're using comic characters who are equally 'cool', who also violate RL logic through comic physics.

In that case the answer is, "Any of them could, provided there's a page or two of dramatic buildup, especially if their name is on the cover of the book."

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by Laminator_X
In that case the answer is, "Any of them could, provided there's a page or two of dramatic buildup, especially if their name is on the cover of the book."

Then the next stage would be could ANYONE do it (for example, would it be feasible -given what we know so far of the character - for say, Batman to do it?

Then we slowly move up the rankings, as it were. Sabretooth? Venom? Colossus? Etc etc.

But if you think the cutoff point is below all the characters named in the thread, then that's fair enough. The next question would be,'Based on?'

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Too true.

However, for the premises of this thread, it SHOULD be somewhat comparable, as we're using comic characters who are equally 'cool', who also violate RL logic through comic physics.

But you're using real world logic throughout this thread. embarrasment

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
But you're using real world logic throughout this thread. embarrasment

Because you guys started it first with this 'small planet' rubbish lmao

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Because you guys started it first with this 'small planet' rubbish lmao

laughing out loud ... how is that comparable to using real world logic for this? Either something is small for its size or not. Did you just make this up? Just typed the first thing that came to your mind and hit send?

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
laughing out loud ... how is that comparable to using real world logic for this? Either something is small for its size or not. Did you just make this up? Just typed the first thing that came to your mind and hit send?

What does it's size have to do with anything? Lmao

Edit:. Take deep breaths and think before you post haha. If you're trying to down play the feat because small planet needs less energy to break (lol), that's.....well, that's RL logic there my man.

-Pr-
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
What does it's size have to do with anything? Lmao

Edit:. Take deep breaths and think before you post haha. If you're trying to down play the feat because small planet needs less energy to break (lol), that's.....well, that's RL logic there my man.

Size matters for Carver, I guess.

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>