Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

H2H

Hulk is Hulk.

Hulk

Based on?

Having infinite power.

Thanos, easily.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thanos, easily. This

Originally posted by carver9
Having infinite power.

Yet was taken out by acid bullets.

Originally posted by carver9
Having infinite power.

No one agrees with you

Hulk eats him.

To be as fair as possible. The Hulk has never defeated Thanos in the 616 verse to my memory. They have faced off against each other, and Thanos won each of those times. ATM I don't recall a time that they fought a 1 v 1 brawl, so I don't know who'd actually win in a pure H2H fight that had them both operating at optimal levels.

Thanos overall is more durable, and can deal with more types of powers being thrown his way.

Thanos wins imo.

Hulk eats Stoic, too.

No doubt.

Originally posted by Stoic
To be as fair as possible. The Hulk has never defeated Thanos in the 616 verse to my memory. They have faced off against each other, and Thanos won each of those times. ATM I don't recall a time that they fought a 1 v 1 brawl, so I don't know who'd actually win in a pure H2H fight that had them both operating at optimal levels.

Thanos overall is more durable, and can deal with more types of powers being thrown his way.

Thanos wins imo.

When have Hulk and Thanos fought?

Did you read what I wrote? Every time that Thanos has had a run-in with the Hulk, he has won. These weren't fist fights as I wrote, but Thanos still came out on top. When Annihilus was bombarding that planet and one to two shot killing the heroes (Gladiator, Thor, Silver Surfer, etc) the Hulk was one among that crowd to fall. Before the bombardment Thanos zapped the Hulk once, and he was nearly taking a snooze. The benefit of doubt has to be given to Thanos in this case as far as I'm concerned.

When has the Hulk ever come close to beating the life out of the Surfer? When has the Hulk ever shown the durability to take hits from a Sky Father and continue to get up? When Thanos physically beat Anni-Hulk, who had recently mauled Gladiator, can you say that the Hulk would have been able to do the same?

I'm looking at two different perspectives here.

1. We know that the Hulk can eventually exceed Thanos in strength, but why would Thanos ever give him time to ramp up to those levels?
2. There is a strong possibility that Thanos wouldn't be able to KO this version of the Hulk, as we saw him literally get his face crushed by Grandmaster Prime, and laugh it off as if it did no damage. This is where my doubt comes in.

Anyone want to explain how Thanos would win over a guy that can laugh off getting his face crushed? I'm game to hear it, because the more I think about it, the more that this seems to be Hulk's fight to lose. It's purely H2H.

Originally posted by Stoic
To be as fair as possible. The Hulk has never defeated Thanos in the 616 verse to my memory. They have faced off against each other, and Thanos won each of those times. ATM I don't recall a time that they fought a 1 v 1 brawl, so I don't know who'd actually win in a pure H2H fight that had them both operating at optimal levels.

Thanos overall is more durable, and can deal with more types of powers being thrown his way.

Thanos wins imo. This 👍

Still doesn't answer how Thanos would manage to KO him. I never bought the Thing KOing a guy that was fully conscious while being cut into pieces and stored in separate lab jars. Not to mention the Grandmaster Prime face breaker.

To be fair, he had the regulator at that point. And Starlin had Thanos kill himself by blasting his own head off.

Take it however you want, it's not a usual feat for Thanos. Starlin didn't even him healing from a slash from Annihilus.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Take it however you want, it's not a usual feat for Thanos. Starlin didn't even him healing from a slash from Annihilus. lol so you try to lowball it with another feat. Comics are full of inconsistent feats. Fact is he never used the regulator so it counts. Starlin also has Thanos tank 5 or so blast that were 1 shot killing heroes.

@Stoic...

Can you post the scans of Thanos beating the Hulk? I need to see those confrontations. Or the ones where he is looking better.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
lol so you try to lowball it with another feat. Comics are full of inconsistent feats. Fact is he never used the regulator so it counts. Starlin also has Thanos tank 5 or so blast that were 1 shot killing heroes.
It really doesn't.

Never said otherwise about the blasts.

Originally posted by carver9
@Stoic...

Can you post the scans of Thanos beating the Hulk? I need to see those confrontations. Or the ones where he is looking better.

I'm unable to post scans. These times were when Thanos made the Hulk fight for him, another time was when he shot the Hulk one time making him fall down nearly KOing him, but as I said, I've never once seen them have a fist fight. However Thanos easily beat the mess out of the Silver Surfer, which has been something that has always been a problem for the Hulk, not to mention that Dione had him locked up in his basement. An alternate reality Hulk yes, but not necessarily a weaker Hulk. I'm being as neutral as possible here. I have no idea who would win, but again, the Hulk would have to close the power gap awfully fast in order to win this. I repeat, I have never seen Thanos fight Hulk in a H2H brawl.

Thanos has always shown the advantage over Hulk though they have not had a real throwdown to the end. Below is during the Indestructible Hulk days.

https://imgur.com/a/jOl2WPb

Originally posted by Stoic
I'm unable to post scans. These times were when Thanos made the Hulk fight for him, another time was when he shot the Hulk one time making him fall down nearly KOing him, but as I said, I've never once seen them have a fist fight. However Thanos easily beat the mess out of the Silver Surfer, which has been something that has always been a problem for the Hulk, not to mention that Dione had him locked up in his basement. An alternate reality Hulk yes, but not necessarily a weaker Hulk. I'm being as neutral as possible here. I have no idea who would win, but again, the Hulk would have to close the power gap awfully fast in order to win this. I repeat, I have never seen Thanos fight Hulk in a H2H brawl.

He TP'ed Hulk during the time they were not fighting. I'm asking for a time when they were literally fighting.

He blasted Hulk who was still active after the blast. The team then ask Hulk to stand down. Where was he near ko? Also, Thanos hid behind shields.

Silver Surfer drains Hulk. Nothing more, nothing less and Hulk have become SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful since then.

Alternate realities doesnt equal current versions of the Hulk. Also, Thanos didnt have control of this Hulk, cosmic Ghost Rider did.

Basically everything you said is wrong. Theyve never truly fought. Even Starlin himself said Indestructible Hulk could give Thanos a run for his money.

Originally posted by carver9
He TP'ed Hulk during the time they were not fighting. I'm asking for a time when they were literally fighting.

He blasted Hulk who was still active after the blast. The team then ask Hulk to stand down. Where was he near ko? Also, Thanos hid behind shields.

Silver Surfer drains Hulk. Nothing more, nothing less and Hulk have become SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful since then.

Alternate realities doesnt equal current versions of the Hulk. Also, Thanos didnt have control of this Hulk, cosmic Ghost Rider did.

Basically everything you said is wrong. Theyve never truly fought. Even Starlin himself said Indestructible Hulk could give Thanos a run for his money.

They've never had a prolonged fist fight. Which is why no one can say for sure. At least I can't. However if all powers were considered, which they aren't here, I'd vote in favor of Thanos. H2H only, nerfs Thanos giving this version of the Hulk the advantage IMO. You have scans right? Make a stand Carver.

Never knew Thanos' armor also had a healing factor. Things you learn.

https://i.postimg.cc/BXhMBTkP/35.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/mPJj0bbb/36.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/DJKgwBJH/37.jpg

Originally posted by abhilegend
Never knew Thanos' armor also had a healing factor. Things you learn.

https://i.postimg.cc/BXhMBTkP/35.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/mPJj0bbb/36.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/DJKgwBJH/37.jpg

Not sure Abhi? Thanos like all Eternals can manipulate molecules. Can you say for certain that he wasn't actively using his cosmic powers to heal? It says in those scans that he really didn't know what the Regulator was. If that's the case, he wouldn't have been able to actively use it. The evidence isn't strong enough IMO. It's possible either way.

Tbh, by how Thanos acts in those scans it would seem all of that was done under his own power.

He didn't even look concerned by the moderate weight loss after wrestling that comet or the healing afterwards-- like it was always going to happen.

Originally posted by Stoic
Not sure Abhi? Thanos like all Eternals can manipulate molecules. Can you say for certain that he wasn't actively using his cosmic powers to heal? It says in those scans that he really didn't know what the Regulator was. If that's the case, he wouldn't have been able to actively use it. The evidence isn't strong enough IMO. It's possible either way.
Thanos has never shown power like that in the past. Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Tbh, by how Thanos acts in those scans it would seem all of that was done under his own power.

He didn't even look concerned by the moderate weight loss after wrestling that comet or the healing afterwards-- like it was always going to happen.
He also had the power to restore him. It was only after he used it, he began to heal.

Hhhhmmmm... I'm confused. ABHI could be right this time. If you look at the orb during the time Thanos was healing, it was getting brighter and brighter.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thanos has never shown power like that in the past.
He also had the power to restore him. It was only after he used it, he began to heal.

You could be right. However it is part of his power set to have the ability to heal, or manipulate molecules. This is something that he has in common with the Eternal race.

Originally posted by carver9
He TP'ed Hulk during the time they were not fighting. I'm asking for a time when they were literally fighting.

He blasted Hulk who was still active after the blast. The team then ask Hulk to stand down. Where was he near ko? Also, Thanos hid behind shields.

Silver Surfer drains Hulk. Nothing more, nothing less and Hulk have become SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful since then.

Alternate realities doesnt equal current versions of the Hulk. Also, Thanos didnt have control of this Hulk, cosmic Ghost Rider did.

Basically everything you said is wrong. Theyve never truly fought. Even Starlin himself said Indestructible Hulk could give Thanos a run for his money. Starlin never said that, again why do you always lie when it comes to Thanos.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thanos has never shown power like that in the past.
He also had the power to restore him. It was only after he used it, he began to heal.

https://m.imgur.com/a/sAqy6

https://m.imgur.com/a/uICYZ

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Thanos has always shown the advantage over Hulk though they have not had a real throwdown to the end. Below is during the Indestructible Hulk days.

https://imgur.com/a/jOl2WPb

He punched him while Hulk was jumping at the team. Hulk then smiled that punch off. Punching someone isnt an advantage.

@Broly...

When did Thanos slap Hulk into a coma?

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Starlin never said that, again why do you always lie when it comes to Thanos.

He didnt say that, he said something even better...

"But on the other hand the Hulk's lack of intellectual curiosity would quickly bore the Titan. But he'd be wary of the brute because of that infinite rage thing he has going. Banner would think of the Titan as nothing but a menace, to be defeated or escaped from".

Thanos would be wary of Hulk infinite rage while Hulk wont see Thanos as anything.

Source...

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbr.com/intergalactic-titans-tussle-in-starlins-thanos-vs-hulk/amp/

Thanks for helping me look this up. Now go away

Originally posted by carver9
@Broly...

When did Thanos slap Hulk into a coma?

When was Hulk states as being stronger than Celestials?

Originally posted by BrolyBlack
When was Hulk states as being stronger than Celestials?

Did I say that in THIS thread? Stay on topic.

Hhhhmmmm, wonder if I should post Beta Ray Bill knocking Thanos over or Hulk knocking over Thanos with the Gauntlet? Glad I have enough common sense to know that knocking someone over doesnt mean defeating them.

Originally posted by carver9
He didnt say that, he said something even better...

"But on the other hand the Hulk's lack of intellectual curiosity would quickly bore the Titan. But he'd be wary of the brute because of that infinite rage thing he has going. Banner would think of the Titan as nothing but a menace, to be defeated or escaped from".

Thanos would be wary of Hulk infinite rage while Hulk wont see Thanos as anything.

Source...

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbr.com/intergalactic-titans-tussle-in-starlins-thanos-vs-hulk/amp/

Thanks for helping me look this up. Now go away

Aren't forum rules pretty clear on interviews?

Immortal Hulk is gonna drop Thanos in the future. remember I said this

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Aren't forum rules pretty clear on interviews? Interview Hulk is still Hulk.

Hulk is above Thanos.

Hulk gets two pieced.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk is above Thanos. care to try and even prove that.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
care to try and even prove that. https://media.giphy.com/media/3o7WIHHtNjTHwITYAg/giphy.gif

Originally posted by Badabing
https://media.giphy.com/media/3o7WIHHtNjTHwITYAg/giphy.gif

This incarnation wasn't said to be stronger.

Also Hulk was amped on Sasquatch's power when he fought Avengers (and even then he didn't beat She Hulk).

One more thing, Enigma wasn't Pod. It was destroyed by a random Martian (who got beat up by Rescue armor) and Enigma was just a piece of it.

https://i.postimg.cc/rdtNzvX1/image.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/MM2bBdqh/image.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/H8TwZnJz/image.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/c6WB49D3/image.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/grKqwV5T/image.jpg

So many things are out of context in that post, must be from comicvine.

Proper, you forgot to mention he one shot koed the One Below All, recently took on 4 Hulk level beings by himself and one shot dropped all of them with ease. The mere presence of Hulk showing up made the Monitor run. He damaged The Grandmaster and probably wouldve beat him, a being who killed the Collector in a single hit and was stomping the Avengers. Lol... Hulk is approaching skyfather level power and is probably above it since it has been outright said nothing on Earth could stop him if he went rogue.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Also Hulk was amped on Sasquatch's power when he fought Avengers (and even then he didn't beat She Hulk).

Stop trolling. Also, Rogue used absorption on him. Show me where he lost anything he absorbed. The guy just took on 4 Hulk level beings (which is more powerful than the Avengers line-up) and stomped them with ease.

Feats for these 'Hulk level beings'?

Originally posted by carver9
Proper, you forgot to mention he one shot koed the One Below All,recently took on 4 Hulk level beings by himself and one shot dropped all of them with ease. The mere presence of Hulk showing up made the Monitor run. He damaged The Grandmaster and probably wouldve beat him, a being who killed the Collector in a single hit and was stomping the Avengers. Lol... Hulk is approaching skyfather level power and is probably above it since it has been outright said nothing on Earth could stop him if he went rogue.

He never did anything to TOBA, BERSERKERS are featless. Monitor?

Grandmaster? Collector? Are you drunk?

Originally posted by carver9
Stop trolling. Also, Rogue used absorption on him. Show me where he lost anything he absorbed. The guy just took on 4 Hulk level beings (which is more powerful than the Avengers line-up) and stomped them with ease.
It was removed when Hulk went to hell.

Feats for these hulk level characters?

Originally posted by abhilegend
It was removed when Hulk went to hell.

Feats for these hulk level characters?

Prove it. Where was it said that Hulk was weaker than he was before? Wait, didnt you accept a statement of Immortal Hulk being>Savage Hulk? You are the most picking and choosing person on this site.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He never did anything to TOBA, BERSERKERS are featless. Monitor?

Grandmaster? Collector? Are you drunk?

Lol... yes, he did drop TOBA. Stop being a hypocrite. It was said on panel they are equal to the Hulk.

Naah, you're drunk.

Who is this Proper?

Hulk is stronger (not by much) and has a HF.
Thanos is more durable(not by much and much more skilled.
Could go either way depending on how much stronger Hulk gets in the fight.
For example, if Hulk gains no extra strength or a little extra strength then Thanos wins. But if Hulk's strength (durability and HF also increases) significantly then Hulk wins.

Lol...trust me, ABHI is the true representative of someone who hates everything about Marvel. Especially Hulk, Thor and Surfer (Odin as well). Those are his primary target.

You mean the Sasquatch that got amped to be on Hulks level? Something that has been explained in both the comic and by the writer himself. Can you show me where it was mentioned that Immortal Hulk is current amped by anything? Especially since it's been DAYS between the time Hulk absorbed Sasquatch gamma and him fighting Avengers. I hope you realize that the thing fight has context with your leaving out.

Like I said it all depends on how dynamic Hulk's strength is. If Hulk's strength double or triples then he will win but if it stays nearly the same then he loses.

Originally posted by Proper_
You mean the Sasquatch that got amped to be on Hulks level? Something that has been explained in both the comic and by the writer himself. Can you show me where it was mentioned that Immortal Hulk is current amped by anything? Especially since it's been DAYS between the time Hulk absorbed Sasquatch gamma and him fighting Avengers. I hope you realize that the thing fight has context with your leaving out.
Mind showing where Hulk released the excess gamma energy like he did here?

https://i.postimg.cc/hzXt16W2/image.jpg

Also want to point out that Egnima outright stated that she was going to be as powerful as her most powerful form when she fought the Hulk...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/46224884/SmartSelect_20191125-005031_Chrome.jpg.html

Nice try Abhi.

Originally posted by carver9
Also want to point out that Egnima outright stated that she was going to be as powerful as her most powerful form when she fought the Hulk...

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/46224884/SmartSelect_20191125-005031_Chrome.jpg.html

Nice try Abhi.
Do you have reading problem? Enigma was just a part of POD, it's her own maximum power (as hard as diamond), not equal to POD's power.

Shut up troll.