Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Switch Thor with Superman

Can Superman tank a planetary blast from an AMPED Galactus unscratched just like Thor did

What condition is he in after


https://i.postimg.cc/dDzYyzYd/7230641-rco018-1580329491.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/9D2HxZzQ/7230643-rco019-1580329491.jpg

There are a couple of showings that suggest he'd be fine.

So Hawkman hits him with the planet:
http://i.imgur.com/ECpFJGC.jpg

Let's go bigger. A Sun eater:
https://imgur.com/a/48Qjd

Or a black hole (a big one):
http://i.imgur.com/nBH6Uuo.jpg

But here, he got hit by EM radiation from an explosion that was 50 times the size of Kepler's supernova, AFTER being weakened by red sun radiation:
https://imgur.com/a/5fpnT

Before you jump on me, remember I said he got hit by the EM rads - I KNOW he didn't get hit by the expanding ball of radiation behind it.
And BEFORE anyone jumps on me and says aha! double standards with Gladiator and his son!!! Remember we are actually shown what happens, as opposed to just Kid Glads saying it.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
There are a couple of showings that suggest he'd be fine.

So Hawkman hits him with the planet:
http://i.imgur.com/ECpFJGC.jpg

Let's go bigger. A Sun eater:
https://imgur.com/a/48Qjd

Or a black hole (a big one):
http://i.imgur.com/nBH6Uuo.jpg

But here, he got hit by EM radiation from an explosion that was 50 times the size of Kepler's supernova, AFTER being weakened by red sun radiation:
https://imgur.com/a/5fpnT

Before you jump on me, remember I said he got hit by the EM rads - I KNOW he didn't get hit by the expanding ball of radiation behind it.
And BEFORE anyone jumps on me and says aha! double standards with Gladiator and his son!!! Remember we are actually shown what happens, as opposed to just Kid Glads saying it.

Then there's non planetary attacks like the recent Red Cloud, this is while he's "stronger" than he was?

https://i.postimg.cc/z3bVYBRK/ress.jpg

This is why I don't play the scaling game because all attacks aren't alike. Some hurt or don't hurt because because they have certain properties that prevent that from happening.

No, he can not.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Then there's non planetary attacks like the recent Red Cloud, this is while he's "stronger" than he was?

https://i.postimg.cc/z3bVYBRK/ress.jpg

This is why I don't play the scaling game because all attacks aren't alike. Some hurt or don't hurt because because they have certain properties that prevent that from happening.

And Cosmic Thor was hurt by a random alien carrying a rock in the same comic. Writers can be incredibly inconsistent.

But to answer your question, based on certain showings, yes, Superman CAN tank it and be fine.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
And Cosmic Thor was hurt by a random alien carrying a rock in the same comic. Writers can be incredibly inconsistent.

But to answer your question, based on certain showings, yes, Superman CAN tank it and be fine.

He wasn't "hurt" just surprised

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
He wasn't "hurt" just surprised

https://i.postimg.cc/4yB1HCr3/RCO010-1580329491.jpg
https://i.postimg.cc/1X9HzR7T/RCO011-1580329491-1.jpg

He was knocked out of the sky, brought to his knees, and lost his hold on Mjolnir. A guy who tanks planetary blasts from an AMPED Galactus unscratched shouldn't even register it.

he wasn't worried about the planet killing him it was because it was the type of planets these are supposed to to be planets with op artifacts an energy

https://i.postimg.cc/SJB3zRg6/image.jpg

Irrelevant.

The ape things clearly hurt him. Which is my point. Writers are inconsistent.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
he wasn't worried about the planet killing him it was because it was the type of planets these are supposed to to be planets with op artifacts an energy

https://i.postimg.cc/SJB3zRg6/image.jpg

I don't think the planet being destroyed matters. Its who the attack is coming from that matters. Example, this attack hurt Superman Prime and it appears to be nuke like. Make a thread asking if Superman could tank this and let's see what people responses would be.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111321350/6192108-zxbscst.jpg

The Galactus attack above would kill Superman. The planet explosion isn't what to worry about, its Galactus power that is in play here and he was using a lot of it during this scene.

Originally posted by carver9
I don't think the planet being destroyed matters. Its who the attack is coming from that matters. Example, this attack hurt Superman Prime and it appears to be nuke like. Make a thread asking if Superman could tank this and let's see what people responses would be.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111321350/6192108-zxbscst.jpg

The Galactus attack above would kill Superman. The planet explosion isn't what to worry about, its Galactus power that is in play here and he was using a lot of it during this scene.

Irrelevant - but even IF you wanted to argue that point....

Here is Emperor Joker. Who was pissed off at Superman:

https://imgur.com/a/vTiS6

Sure, Joker's isn't out to kill him. But even a love tap from him is pretty powerful.

Its funny that people cling to one showing about a story but ignore Superman getting koed by a gas station in DOS Superman and Doomsday failing to kill a shield less Booster Gold (there's more inconsistencies) and still put Dos Doomsday at a high tier. Bias is a man's best friend

Originally posted by carver9
Its funny that people cling to one showing about a story but ignore Superman getting koed by a gas station in DOS Superman and Doomsday failing to kill a shield less Booster Gold (there's more inconsistencies) and still put Dos Doomsday at a high tier. Bias is a man's best friend
Please stop trolling. I am saying that writers are inconsistent.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
And Cosmic Thor was hurt by a random alien carrying a rock in the same comic. Writers can be incredibly inconsistent.

But to answer your question, based on certain showings, yes, Superman CAN tank it and be fine.

Carver, shut the phuck up lol. I was replying to Alberto when he used a low showing.

What goalposts am I moving?

Was he hurt by the aliens, yes or no?

What is JL King even talking about? Post a counter or leave the thread. What I said made perfect sense. Collateral damage doesn't equal power output. Anyone who knows anything about comics should know this.

Originally posted by carver9
Its funny that people cling to one showing about a story but ignore Superman getting koed by a gas station in DOS Superman and Doomsday failing to kill a shield less Booster Gold (there's more inconsistencies) and still put Dos Doomsday at a high tier. Bias is a man's best friend

JL King is talking about this post, you stupid lying troll.

Not my words though

wait why do people call Carver a troll?

he can bias like all of us sometimes i guess, but he doesn't troll lmao

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
wait why do people call Carver a troll?

he can bias like all of us sometimes i guess, but he doesn't troll lmao

Pay Dark no attention. He's the most sensitive girl/I mean, man on this website. He is full of emotions.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
What goalposts am I moving?

Was he hurt by the aliens, yes or no?

Thor wasn't in the sky but hovering.
You shouldn't look up what Unf means as some weird shit pops up lol..
But he WASN'T hurt.

Imagine being hit by something from behind that has gravity behind it..
And when he goes Ah,Hel ITS because he looked up and see that alien race coming at him with more bolders

Neither of them come here because they get debunked every single time, you should follow their footsteps. less fanboyism

You just said cosmic thor would get one shotted by.....JOKER? LOL? and YOU'RE the one to preach about "good posters" WHAT?

Go say joker one shots cosmic thor on any forum and see how fast you get banned troll

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Neither of them come here because they get debunked every single time, you should follow their footsteps. less fanboyism

You just said cosmic thor would get one shotted by.....JOKER? LOL? and YOU'RE the one to preach about "good posters" WHAT?

Go say joker one shots cosmic thor on any forum and see how fast you get banned troll

cool, Stilt and I already wrote a series called "Harley Quinn one shots Asgard"

its totally canon to both marvel and dc

also we wrote

"killer croc anally rapes Thor while Odin watches"

The guy thats preaching about "good" posters is the same one that thinks Joker one shots Cosmic Thor LOL

Theres a reason why kmc is your safe zone, any other battleboard would had banned your trolling butthurt dc tard immediately saying some nonsense like that LMAO

lmfao, so mad, such anger

no need to be, marvels debaters are dominating right now and chasing away dc fans Might need some new recruits

you are dominating by sitting down and pee?

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Thor wasn't in the sky but hovering.
You shouldn't look up what Unf means as some weird shit pops up lol..
But he WASN'T hurt.

Imagine being hit by something from behind that has gravity behind it..
And when he goes Ah,Hel ITS because he looked up and see that alien race coming at him with more bolders

If I can tank unscratched blasts from an AMPED Galactus, then no, a rock thrown by a random alien would register as much as an ant flinging a grain of sand at me.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
If I can tank unscratched blasts from an AMPED Galactus, then no, a rock thrown by a random alien would register as much as an ant flinging a grain of sand at me.

the Boulder was from an enchanted planet, since boulders are part of planet's crust, they would be enchanted too.

Read the comic . Those 5 planets were enchanted and special, that's why Galactus was absorbing only them.

They where still special with energy that fed galactus..
If he consumed all five he would have not had his hunger.. it would have been the first time Galan was actually fully fed

https://i.postimg.cc/RqKN1hBS/bls.jpg

context, use it saint

Ok Albert lmao.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Ok Albert lmao.

DS my man, I don't know how you get any enjoyment schooling albertroll, it's way too easy.

I also like bullying the kids for their lunch money.

But only the retarded fat ones. I'm too much of a coward to actually go against someone who can fight back.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Ok Albert lmao.

concession accepted

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Switch Thor with Superman

Can Superman tank a planetary blast from an AMPED Galactus unscratched just like Thor did

What condition is he in after


https://i.postimg.cc/dDzYyzYd/7230641-rco018-1580329491.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/9D2HxZzQ/7230643-rco019-1580329491.jpg Of course Superman tanks it, easily.

So wait, are people downplaying Thor withstanding that attack because of the rock showing?

Originally posted by carver9
So wait, are people downplaying Thor withstanding that attack because of the rock showing?

No, people are not. I'm surprised you're only asking this question now. If people say yes, they're misunderstanding.

Alberto is downplaying Superman's feats with low showings. So I am merely pointing out that writers are inconsistent. Based on SOME of his showings (i.e. his high showings), yes, Superman can tank the attack.

That's all.

Originally posted by carver9
So wait, are people downplaying Thor withstanding that attack because of the rock showing?

yes

Joker>Rock>Cosmic Thor

it is known

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
yes

Why though? Galactus was already amped past his normal self. Then he ate this planet to the point of being unable to contain his energy/power and exploded. The planet being destroyed is just a side effect. Thor withstanding without a scratch an all out attack from an amped Galactus is insane. That IS an abstract level ft, no denying it. I don't understand why people are even acknowledging the planets destruction because this blast is far more than just that.

Example, Doom shields withstood attacks from 4 pissed Celestials. Nothing done to the area around him, let alone the bridge he was standing on. The high showing here is WHO his shields withstood the attacks from, not the collateral damage.

https://m.imgur.com/U5A0LKo

Superman dies from this attack and so does Hulk just in case someone was interested in knowing.

But no one is.....

batman>old man quill>galactus>cosmic thor

https://i.imgur.com/rhcMM4J.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/UZP5AEm.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/QuOk80D.jpg

it is known

A weakened Galactus destroys 3 star systems...

https://m.imgur.com/a/m3ng0

Tank hits from all of the heroes (and villains) including the Phoenix...

https://m.imgur.com/9q6ze7d

Stands in the heart of an exploding star unphased...

https://m.imgur.com/ly7YDwK

One shot kills a Celestial...

https://m.imgur.com/PDZTooW

His fight against Tyrant destroyed Galaxies...

https://m.imgur.com/kRmE4hv

This is Galactus without even approaching the power in the scan for this thread.

honestly forgot diesude existed, hes like those subs you play in when lebron tired

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
honestly forgot diesude existed, hes like those subs you play in when lebron tired

you and carver play in wnba

Originally posted by MrMind
you and carver play in wnba forget the WNBA, he shows off his participation trophy from the special Olympics.

I didn't understand anything Diesldude said. I don't even know how to counter it.

@Squall,

The point of my post went clean over your skull.

Originally posted by carver9
@Squall,

The point of my post went clean over your skull.

Was making point on your asinine logic.

Originally posted by carver9
I didn't understand anything Diesldude said. I don't even know how to counter it. apparently you dont understand comics either.

Originally posted by carver9
So wait, are people downplaying Thor withstanding that attack because of the rock showing?

No.
Albert is downplaying Superman's good feats with lower showings. Therefore Dark is showing him that he can do the same to Thor (who is greatly inconsistent).

No one is literally using Thor's rock showing against him. And no one should be using Superman's low showing against him either.

Supernova >>>> planet exploding
Holding a singularity >>>> planet exploding

Originally posted by h1a8
No.
Albert is downplaying Superman's good feats with lower showings. Therefore Dark is showing him that he can do the same to Thor (who is greatly inconsistent).

No one is literally using Thor's rock showing against him. And no one should be using Superman's low showing against him either.

. You get me.

Originally posted by h1a8
Supernova >>>> planet exploding
Holding a singularity >>>> planet exploding

Even though this statement is off, are you implying that a Super Nova type of explosion needs to happen from an attack in order for it to hurt Superman?

Originally posted by h1a8
Supernova >>>> planet exploding
Holding a singularity >>>> planet exploding

https://i.postimg.cc/23zrJzrn/snv.jpg

Um this is a non canon feat that more than likely never happened

the whole story was Pa Kent telling a story so that Ma kent would be comfortable with the idea that Superman was missing.

Action Comics 847 for those who want to cross reference it

No, he outraced the explosion of the planet

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
No, he outraced the explosion of the planet

This

@Squall...

I don't think you should look at the attack as a planet exploding attack, look at it as an attack coming from one of the most powerful beings in Marvel who was amped 5 times over when it happened. Imagine judging every attack off of the collateral damage displayed. Trans tiers would be meta to street level

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Switch Thor with Superman

Can Superman tank a planetary blast from an AMPED Galactus unscratched just like Thor did

What condition is he in after


https://i.postimg.cc/dDzYyzYd/7230641-rco018-1580329491.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/9D2HxZzQ/7230643-rco019-1580329491.jpg
Dont see y not

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
https://i.postimg.cc/23zrJzrn/snv.jpg

Um this is a non canon feat that more than likely never happened

the whole story was Pa Kent telling a story so that Ma kent would be comfortable with the idea that Superman was missing.

Action Comics 847 for those who want to cross reference it It happened. He's telling a story, but you're seeing the actual events that transpired while he's talking to Martha.

Pretty sure if someone looked it up, you can find McDuffie talking about it on forums, because he was a comic forum fanboy and loved talking about his comics.

And this was the second time we'd seen him survive him survive a sun eater explosion, the first time was before his death. The canonically weakest version of Superman, as he hadn't started digging into well of power yet. And he survived but was knocked out.

This one he tanked.

it's jus alberto spewing nonsense desperately trying to lowball

Superman survived 50 times the size of Kepler's Supernova feat is definitely canon, such explosion would've evaporate asgard with odin thor and everyone in it.

in the meantime sun goes nova scares the shit out of living jobberno
https://imgur.com/qL2Ltaa
https://imgur.com/wHgZTd8

Originally posted by Juntai
It happened. He's telling a story, but you're seeing the actual events that transpired while he's talking to Martha.

Pretty sure if someone looked it up, you can find McDuffie talking about it on forums, because he was a comic forum fanboy and loved talking about his comics.

And this was the second time we'd seen him survive him survive a sun eater explosion, the first time was before his death. The canonically weakest version of Superman, as he hadn't started digging into well of power yet. And he survived but was knocked out.

This one he tanked.

we'll have to agree to disagree. What I read was his dad telling his mom exactly what he couldn't survive to keep her from worrying about him coming up missing while fighting a group of people just as powerful as him. They even left the concept of what he was lying about ambiguous if you look at the panels were she said thanks for lying to her when she needed it. Superman in deep space hit by red sun is powerless and by all rights and purposes human.

like I said, I'm doing God's work, spreading the TRUTH over your tears

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
we'll have to agree to disagree. What I read was his dad telling his mom exactly what he couldn't survive to keep her from worrying about him coming up missing while fighting a group of people just as powerful as him. They even left the concept of what he was lying about ambiguous if you look at the panels were she said thanks for lying to her when she needed it. Superman in deep space hit by red sun is powerless and by all rights and purposes human.
Nonsense