Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Both at peak who wins in the following:-

1. Light sabers
2. H2H
3. Force powers
4. All out fight with all of the above

It's hard for me to say it but Windu wins

Mace takes it, in my opinion. Especially if this is Legends we're talking about here.

Canon, you could argue it's a bit closer, since both have fought roughly evenly against Count Dooku. However, Mace's feat against Sidious just puts him outside of Quinlan's reach.