ohh this is a fun one. shuma gets talked about like he's some major power, but when it comes to actual feats?
the pf is in a similar boat but overall certainly has better on-panel feats. magic vs cosmic is notoriously hard to gauge but going by feats i'd say phoenix has it all over shuma. going by narration, i'd probably take shuma. maybe. i'm willing to be convinced otherwise in both cases lol