Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Synopsis - Fury decided to take out Comedian, because he crossed too many lines by killing innocent people.

Both fighters are in character. Fight to death, KO or incapacitation.

Both fighters has their standard gear. Fight takes place on the NYC streets.

Probably Fury. Guy has thrown down with Captain America. Comedian got thrown out a window by Ozymandias.

Originally posted by tkitna
Probably Fury. Guy has thrown down with Captain America. Comedian got thrown out a window by Ozymandias.

To be fair, in their first fight Comedian has defeated Ozymandias, but it had a context - Ozzy was younger and less experienced, and he actually was studying how Comedian fights, and let him win in the end (which Ozzy outright states). Ozymandias also had defeated Rorschach and Nite Owl II at the same time, but their feats aren't that impressive (they at best was defeating only fodder thugs and cops).

Fury has a black belt in taekwondo and brown belt in jiu-jitsu,and also knows boxing, judo and fencing. Fury also fought toe-toe woith Moon Knight, easily put Daredevil in an armlock and defeated Baron Strucker several times (this guy is one of the best fencers in Marvel). And Fury has defeated Absorbing Man's son in a boxing match, despite the fact that guy was a legit metahuman.

Plus, Fury held his own against Captain MAerrica and even against Wolverine (though Logan was holding back and Fury used gagets/prep).

So.....you're saying Comedian has a chance?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So.....you're saying Comedian has a chance?

Only if he catches Fury off-guard, which is hardly possible.

Originally posted by tkitna
Probably Fury. Guy has thrown down with Captain America. Comedian got thrown out a window by Ozymandias.

Because Comedian was drunk as **** and taken by surprise.

You haven't read their rematch from Doomsday Clock? Or their first fight from Before Watchmen?

Of course, Nick still has the advantage of having well over 1000 appearances while Comedian has less than 50. But his showings against Cap aren't particularly helpful there.

Originally posted by Alex_Ferrana
Plus, Fury held his own against Captain MAerrica and even against Wolverine (though Logan was holding back and Fury used gagets/prep).

Fury was prepped against Steve, too. Didn't help him much.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Because Comedian was drunk as **** and taken by surprise.

You haven't read their rematch from Doomsday Clock? Or their first fight from Before Watchmen?

Of course, Nick still has the advantage of having well over 1000 appearances while Comedian has less than 50. But his showings against Cap aren't particularly helpful there.



Fury was prepped against Steve, too. Didn't help him much.

Yeah, Cap still defeated Fury even after having prep. Logan also wrecked him even while holding back and beinmg struck by Fury's anti-metahuman gadgets.

Fury also didn't defeated Moon Knight, he retreated when he saw than he can't take him in H2H.

Futy also had a fight with Viper (Madame Hydra) to draw/stalemate (though they was interrupted). Viper held her own against Black Widow, until BW BFR'ed her.

Originally posted by Alex_Ferrana
To be fair, in their first fight Comedian has defeated Ozymandias, but it had a context - Ozzy was younger and less experienced, and he actually was studying how Comedian fights, and let him win in the end (which Ozzy outright states). Ozymandias also had defeated Rorschach and Nite Owl II at the same time, but their feats aren't that impressive (they at best was defeating only fodder thugs and cops).

Fury has a black belt in taekwondo and brown belt in jiu-jitsu,and also knows boxing, judo and fencing. Fury also fought toe-toe woith Moon Knight, easily put Daredevil in an armlock and defeated Baron Strucker several times (this guy is one of the best fencers in Marvel). And Fury has defeated Absorbing Man's son in a boxing match, despite the fact that guy was a legit metahuman.

Plus, Fury held his own against Captain MAerrica and even against Wolverine (though Logan was holding back and Fury used gagets/prep). The film prison fight indicates these gus are superhuman. Far more so than in the comics. The film Comedian might have a chance, the comic Comedian has none.

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
The film prison fight indicates these gus are superhuman. Far more so than in the comics. The film Comedian might have a chance, the comic Comedian has none.

Superhumans?

Meaning their movie feats impressed Whirl more than their comic ones.

For what it's worth, Fury was revealed to be one of the guys (re)training Wildchild in his later career (as Weapon Omega).

Fury's gear can vary from book to book, don't think he has a "standard" one unless it's just regular guns.

What works in Comedian's favour is that plenty of Fury's appearances are about him being the man in charge, not getting any action.

But in the end, he's done stuff Comedian can't even dream about, such as this:

https://i.ibb.co/GQ8J51n/stonewall.png

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Meaning their movie feats impressed Whirl more than their comic ones.

For what it's worth, Fury was revealed to be one of the guys (re)training Wildchild in his later career (as Weapon Omega).

Fury's gear can vary from book to book, don't think he has a "standard" one unless it's just regular guns.

What works in Comedian's favour is that plenty of Fury's appearances are about him being the man in charge, not getting any action.

But in the end, he's done stuff Comedian can't even dream about, such as this:

https://i.ibb.co/GQ8J51n/stonewall.png

Fury is helluva tough fighter and he can fight all by himself. And this feat alone shows how Fury is really capable as a fighter (out-boxing a son of pro heavyweight boxer, who is also a legit meta).

So yes. Comedian is wrecked.

Originally posted by Alex_Ferrana
Only if he catches Fury off-guard, which is hardly possible.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1e/a2/98/1ea298ea0988d889cb9fd3569e5a6ba3.jpg

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1e/a2/98/1ea298ea0988d889cb9fd3569e5a6ba3.jpg

And Fury would catch them even without one eye.

He tried to rape Silk Spectre only to get pummeled by Hooded Justice so there's that.

Originally posted by tkitna
He tried to rape Silk Spectre only to get pummeled by Hooded Justice so there's that.

And also was caught off-guard by a Vietnamese woman, which he apparently raped and impregnated.

Blake's best h2h-esque feat was stalemating Ozy in Before Watchmen... But there were a few major factors at play there:
a.) It was later stated that Ozy allowed Blake to 'win' in order to get a better read on his fighting style.
b.) That fight occurred when Ozy had literally just been in the hero game for 1 year. He was still immensely skilled, but not nearly as skilled as he became later on. Conversely, Blake had already been in the game for a few decades at that point, and therefore had a LOT more practical experience... Yet he still didn't pull an actual victory.

They also fought again in Doomsday Clock, but that fight was inconclusive at best. Moreover, Ozy was effectively fighting with one arm there, because he was holding/protecting Bubastis with the other arm.

I don't even count their fight in the original Watchmen series, because Blake was drunk and really didn't even try to fight back... Though he likely would have lost anyway, imo.


Seems like Blake's only real chance here is hoping that he can shoot Fury in the face, before he gets gunned down himself and/or beaten to death. Don't get me wrong, Blake is skilled... He's just not beating most of the noteworthy Marvel/DC streets who have more legitimate quantifiable feats.

Originally posted by Galan007
Blake's best h2h-esque feat was stalemating Ozy in Before Watchmen... But there were a few major factors at play there:
a.) It was later stated that Ozy allowed Blake to 'win' in order to get a better read on his fighting style.
b.) That fight occurred when Ozy had literally just been in the hero game for 1 year. He was still immensely skilled, but not nearly as skilled as he became later on. Conversely, Blake had already been in the game for a few decades at that point, and therefore had a LOT more practical experience... Yet he still didn't pull an actual victory.

They also fought again in Doomsday Clock, but that fight was inconclusive at best. Moreover, Ozy was effectively fighting with one arm there, because he was holding/protecting Bubastis with the other arm.

I don't even count their fight in the original Watchmen series, because Blake was drunk and really didn't even try to fight back... Though he likely would have lost anyway, imo.


Seems like Blake's only real chance here is hoping that he can shoot Fury in the face, before he gets gunned down himself and/or beaten to death. Don't get me wrong, Blake is skilled... He's just not beating most of the noteworthy Marvel/DC streets who have more legitimate quantifiable feats.

Like said it before, yes. Comedian has defeated (it's considered as a win, although more looks like a stalemate) Ozymandias when Ozzy was young, less experienced (yes, he has skills, but before that he hardly has enough experience, unlike Comedian) and was actually studying Comedian's fighting style.

Agree about fight in Doomsday Clock. Prime Ozymandias vs Prime Comedian would likely end with Ozymandias' victory.

Yeah. But it's unlikely, because Fury is too fast and too experienced to be shoot in the face in direct fight. So yes, Fury wins. Blake is good, but in comparison to other characters from Marvel or DC (outside of Watchmen) he isn't that great. Even in comparison to Punisher.