Best Manga stories vs Best Comic stories

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



MrMind
for those of yall dabble in both realm

could works like attack on titans, naruto, berserk, fullmetal alchemist, hunter x hunter, cowboy bebop etc

compare to the works of

morrison, johns, moore, claremont, ellis etc?

could the best fictions in anime/manga compare to those of marvel and dc through history?

ODG
Originally posted by MrMind
for those of yall dabble in both realm

could works like attack on titans, naruto, berserk, fullmetal alchemist, hunter x hunter, cowboy bebop etc

compare to the works of

morrison, johns, moore, claremont, ellis etc?

could the best fictions in anime/manga compare to those of marvel and dc through history? AoT and Berserk are the only ones that you'd hold up to the very best of western comics.

I'm a huge fan of Cowboy Bebop... which I consider very much a satire of multiple genres, e.g., noir, slapstick, romance, horror, westerns, sci-fi, etc. But the anime was it's primary manifestation and the music of Yoko Kanno elevates it well beyond the bounds of comics/manga pages.

It's simply not fair to compare the silent pages of comics/manga against the Cowboy Bebop anime.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.