Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Yo!! Okay, i was thinkin. U know in the fifth book how sirius dies? well, harry has gotten pretty close to lupin, i mean with helping him and all. Do u think maybe lupin can replace sirius?

Maybe lupin will just replace him by giving him another home and food on the table .......

What do u think?

I dont think so because the reason Harry became so close to Sirius was because he was his godfather and he was the closest to JamES.

No i dont really think so either. but that is still possible!!!!!!!

maybe as in a father figure way, but not as a godfather nor brotherly/friend conroderie (sp?).

friend.....probably....maybe.....the story will keep twistin and a turnin...

Yeah, Lupin is sweet - the poor guy is starving because he is a warewolf!

i am suprosed that he hasn't found anything to eat yet.....i mean, he is a carnovaire right?/????

no! Not when he's in human form - then he eats normally!

Yeah, I agree that he can only be a friend or a brother-figure, but not like they way Sirius was .

remember in JK's interview, how Lupin always keeps distance wid other ppl.. he doesnt wanna get really attached, because of him being warewolf.
I think he'll help Harry, but he'll push him away, whenever things gets really close like Harry-Sirius relationship.

remember how he left Hogwarts, so fast, like he's in a hurry (in book 3). maybe he didnt wanna show how he feels sooo sad leaving hogwarts n Harry.. *shrugs* dats juss a thought.

i think lupin just wanted to not hurt any body n that is why he left hogwarts in book 3 so fast

I think, that Lupin won't replace Sirius in every way, but he might become something like the most important grown-up person for Harry in the next book. But even if it would be great, I don't think that he will adopt Harry or give him a new home.

i agree. lupin is such a troubled man...

u guys sirius isnt dead... he cant die he is 2 coo. u dont kill off the best guy in the book

EXACTLY LEE!!!, you are the smartest person on this board.....SIrius cant be dead, they wouldnt kill off the coolest person...get rid of ron or some other gay guy...ROCK ON LEE

Lupin cannot replace Black, but he would have much role in the next book , I hope so ,,, maybe he'll be much more closer to Harry and stop keeping himself from everybody and maybe he would be the next defense against dark arts teacher.........

No one can replace Sirus, but i think that Lupin and other members of the Order will help fill the void.

i agree

yeah

I can't see why Professor Lupin can't replace Sirius. I know that Sirius was James' best friend, but Professor Lupin was their close friend.
Yeah, the only one problem is that Lupin is a werewolf. And it's not a little thing. But Lupin could love Harry, even as much as Sirius did. Besides, Lupin spent more time with Harry. Okay, I know this relationship was formal, for it was a teacher/student one.
I don't want to hurt either of them, I love Lupin and Sirius the same. And it's not worth that Harry loses everybody he loves.
Always good guys fall.
For saving the day.

R.I.P.

do you think lupin is next to die???

Hopefully not...

And I don't think Lupin can take Sirius's place but I think him and Harry will become very much closer as in there friendship and stuff

Haha!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My secret is poured ou to you. When I checked the website that J.K Rowling made I saw that I Remus Lupin is also Harrys Godafather!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

omg realy ? y didnt he say?

ok if he is it would be really cool and he would die too and i'll be really sad and angry

I'd rather choose Lupin, if I had to, because he suffered a lot and is still not broken. And he is the one who, if appears, makes me want to scream. When I read the Order of the Phoenix, and Lupin came with the others to save Harry, I was so happy that I jumped the house round.
I know that Sirius suffered, too. His best friend was killed and everybody thought it was him who betrayed Lily and James. And for this injustice, he had to spend 12 years in Azkaban, without any human relationship.
And Lupin...First of all, he is a werewolf. That would be enough reason for him to be sad. And for 12 years, he thought one of his friends kill the two other. He couldn't get a job for being a werewolf.

Everything seemed to be quite good. Lupin and Sirius refreshed their friendship. They can get on well. Because Sirius was loyal, protective, temperamental, wild, mischievous and Lupin is rather calm, composed, mysterious, passive, secretive, caring, intelligent, introvert. I think Lupin knew Sirius better than Harry did, for they were friends for a long time. Lupin has to be the saddest of everyone.

I love Sirius, too. Of course I cried when he died, and I can cry anytime when it comes to my mind. I believe or I wanna believe that he'll be back somehow.
He must.