Reeve Superman wins. He was basically Pre Crisis Superman, who was strong enough to move the moon, and without That much effort, Smallville Clark moved a city sized Apokolips, the Moon is MUCH bigger than that. Not to mention experience edge of actually being Superman easily goes with Reeves as well.
Gender: Male Location: Balls deep in your cerebral cortex
get outta here with that "basically" stuff. Reeve Superman didn't move the moon or anything close to it. His greatest feat is one that makes phuck all sense.
He move the earth forward and backwards with this speed and travel back in time (Superman I).
Move the moon to cause an eclipse (Superman IV).
Pick up a continent fill with Kryptonite and sent it into outer space (Superman Returns. A continuation of the Reeve’s version of superman.).
Moved so fast he could not be seen (Superman II).
You realize that Superman Returns retconned movies 3&4, so if you want to use the Island lift feat from Returns, that means you can't use the anything from 3&4.
The OP didnt specify that Superman 3 and 4 were omitted, he said Reeve Superman, and Im pretty sure Christopher Reeve was in Superman 4, where you know, he moved the moon.
And no, Apokolips in Smallville was actually surprisingly small, only about the size of Metropolis.
OK, its a bit bigger than Metropolis, but no where near what a planet or even a moon would be. It wa basically a little wider than Metropolis was long, hardly anything close to our Moon, which Reeve Superman pushed around.