Zeal Ex Nihilo Restricted Gender: Male
Account Restricted
How morally wrong is it to fillet a fish alive?
I was thinking about this today. A couple years ago, my youth group and I were staying at a cottage for the weekend, and we went fishing for dinner. Upon returning, we were to prepare the fish--and I was appalled that they began filleting the fish alive.
__________________ Ask me about my "obvious and unpleasant agenda of hatred."
03:54 AM
Cory Chaos AmStar 14 Manager Gender: Male
Pretty damn wrong. Leave it out of water for a few minutes, it'll be dead soon enough.
03:55 AM
Soleran Fast As Time Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by FeceMan I was thinking about this today. A couple years ago, my youth group and I were staying at a cottage for the weekend, and we went fishing for dinner. Upon returning, we were to prepare the fish--and I was appalled that they began filleting the fish alive.
03:56 AM
NinthCorona Senior Member Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Cory Chaos Pretty damn wrong. Leave it out of water for a few minutes, it'll be dead soon enough.
__________________ Denial isn't just a river in Egypt.
03:56 AM
Zeal Ex Nihilo Restricted Gender: Male
Account Restricted
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Soleran you're going to burn in non vegetarian.
quote: I hope you like the thought of being filleted!
__________________ Ask me about my "obvious and unpleasant agenda of hatred."
04:28 AM
J-Beowulf Senior Member Gender: Male
I usually just give em a good smack on the head with a wooden mallet. Quick and painless, and then you're free to fillet!
__________________
04:38 AM
Tired-Hiker El Bastardo Gender: Male
I think it's flat out rude to fillet a fish while it's still alive.
__________________
04:45 AM
Schecter Restricted Gender: Unspecified
Account Restricted
larger predatorial fish are very intelligent and i would image can suffer. you might do better to just sever the spinal column....less brutal that way.
__________________
06:38 AM
Strangelove Misunderstood Genius Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by =Tired Hiker= I think it's flat out rude to fillet a fish while it's still alive.
__________________
07:39 AM
Fishy Senior Member Gender: Male
I don't think it's something that you would go to hell for, but why somebody wouldn't just kill the fish first is beyond me....
__________________
08:44 AM
Bardock42 Junior Member Gender: Unspecified
Assuming there is something as morally wrong. Assuming fileting a fish alive is morally wrong. I'd say "5"....at least.
__________________
08:50 AM
chillmeistergen Restricted Gender: Male
Account Restricted
I think fishing alone is morally wrong. Dragging a living thing out of its environment using a hook from its mouth, what's humane about that?
__________________
09:32 AM
Magee Senior Member Gender: Male
Must be pretty damn awkward to fillet a live fish, why not just hit it on the head a few times with your trusty mallet?
10:04 AM
Thundar Restricted Gender: Unspecified
Account Restricted
Re: How morally wrong is it to fillet a fish alive?
quote: (post ) Originally posted by FeceMan I was thinking about this today. A couple years ago, my youth group and I were staying at a cottage for the weekend, and we went fishing for dinner. Upon returning, we were to prepare the fish--and I was appalled that they began filleting the fish alive.
__________________
Thundercats Hooo!!!
11:43 AM
ADarksideJedi Jackie Malfoy Gender: Female
I don't eat any kind of seafood and I think that to fish and to hunt is wrong but that is me.I do eat some meat btw!Anyway no I don't think it is morally wrong to do thta to a fish.
__________________ Morning Glory, ,DamienB(my busband),Spoonly,Tired hiker!a1hsauce,Coucil#13,Kongudude,Scottie,Syren
12:13 PM
((The_Anomaly)) 2003 Super Senior Member Gender: Male
How alive are you talking here? Because its pretty difficult to fillet a fish if its alive and moving something wrong with it. It seems kinda cruel IMO. __________________
07:11 PM
{{QS}} Used to be quickshot Gender: Male
FeceMan don't stab it that causes way more pain, less than filleting but a lot more than just a quick smack on the head, it smashes the brain against the skull killing it instantly.Can't really see the purpose of filleting it alive it'd make your fillets poor quality and its not much effort to kill it beforehand
__________________ Free to wreak havoc
08:01 PM
Heaven's Sword "Life is a game" Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by J-Beowulf I usually just give em a good smack on the head with a wooden mallet. Quick and painless, and then you're free to fillet!
__________________ "Not strength...awareness. Feel the moment."-Hiroki Sugimura, Battle Royale
09:58 PM
ADarksideJedi Jackie Malfoy Gender: Female
Kiling a fish is mean and making it suffer while doing that is just pure evil.jm
__________________ Morning Glory, ,DamienB(my busband),Spoonly,Tired hiker!a1hsauce,Coucil#13,Kongudude,Scottie,Syren
02:16 AM
Zeal Ex Nihilo Restricted Gender: Male
Account Restricted
quote: (post ) Originally posted by {{QS}} FeceMan don't stab it that causes way more pain, less than filleting but a lot more than just a quick smack on the head, it smashes the brain against the skull killing it instantly.Can't really see the purpose of filleting it alive it'd make your fillets poor quality and its not much effort to kill it beforehand
__________________ Ask me about my "obvious and unpleasant agenda of hatred."
03:01 AM
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threadsmay not post repliesmay not post attachmentsmay not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG] code is ON
Text-only version
KMC Community Forums
Apr 8th, 2007 03:54 AM
