if you were lord elrond and you were in mount doom with isildur, would you kill him when he refused to throw the ring into the fiery chasm from whence it came?
remember, the race of men already shown weakness against the rings of power (ie. the ringwraiths), what more could they do against the will of the one ring... and the fate of the peoples of middle earth depended upon the destruction of the one ring...
i woulda chopped his head of so quick, put the ring in his pocket then throw his body with the one ring into the fires of mount doom...
Well I wouldn't try to kill Isildur to get rid of the ring, I was attempt to grab it and throw it in even if Isildur would be angry, it would be his decision whether to believe that it was for the best.
__________________
Thank you so much Eezy!!
I'm starting over, do not mistake me for my brother - he has left. Eezy has convinced me to come back, give him some credit.
isildur will fight for the ring. smeagol killed for it, and there is no doubt in my mind that isildur would try to kill elrond just to keep the ring...
Well you have to consider that Isildur may not have that same deep obsession/relation with the ring. Isildur, one of the great Numenoreans, should've had that stronger sense, unlike Smeagol which was only a small hobbit of the River folk.
__________________
Thank you so much Eezy!!
I'm starting over, do not mistake me for my brother - he has left. Eezy has convinced me to come back, give him some credit.
I'll leave him alone and let him do what he wants with the Ring. Watch me care. Besides, if I took the Ring from him, Mt. Doom will explode and neither of us could get out alive unless the Eagles are nearby. I don't want to die yet. I'll let him take the Ring for his own and I myself will flee to Valinor and leave the peoples of Middle-earth carrying their burden.
Or maybe not.
I will try to wrestle with him at least, whoever wins could do what he wants with the Ring.
the books mention, how the ring must be given up freely to be over it. gollum lost it so his need for the ring never left him. Bilbo gave it up, and eventually got over it. as for frodo, it didn't matter 'cause it got destroyed. even when Isildur lost, just before he died, he felt a great sense of relief to be rid of it.
I think Elrond should have come up with a better speech than "throw it in!" but then, it was probably Gil-Galads job to give the 'cast it in' speech! unfortunatley he got killed.
also elrond wasn't going to kill him and take it, because the elves would be more susseptable to the evil of the ring and know to avoid it. It would have been far more dangereous in the hands of Elrond than Isiuldur...
Kitoky> does it really matter? sooner or later, he will be taken over the ring... still he would not give it up to elrond or anybody for that matter...
I can't even think about what I would do! I would love to say that I would overthrow Isildurs decision and throw the ring into the fire. But the weakness of men did not run as strongly in Isildur as it did in many. As kit said he isone of the Numenoreans. Now for sure the weakness was shown after the ring had been possesed but Sauron was thought to be defeted,so why destroy the ring? Hind sight is always 20/20.
Gender: Male Location: The Faroe Islands - Thorshavn
I would have tried to wresel with him to get the ring, and if I would have been unable to defeat him I would have chooped his head off, and trown the ring in, I would have told the Humans that he fell on the edge into the fire
I would have probably pushed him and the ring into the fire. it would have saved a lot of trouble and death. Jsut isildur dieng would have been better than all those millions that died afterwards because of the ring during the war.
Gender: Male Location: The Faroe Islands - Thorshavn
didint see that Iirima, but you would jump in the fire, why not just go over too him and say hey whats that on your foot and hi'd look down and you would punch him in the face and grab the ring and trow it in? thats acturly a better ida then to jump in the fire
yes, much better idea...but I liked the idea of saying to the humans,
"Err...he...he, well, uh...oh, yeah! He fell in the fire! And, uh, I forgot to try to grab him before he fell! Oh, and by da way...the ring's been destroyed!"
Elrond doesn't sound like that, but I think it'd be funny.
((Whoo-hoo, go me, now I have an avatar!!)
__________________
Last edited by Nienna on Feb 4th, 2004 at 06:36 PM
No. This would only cause problems between elves and men and thats really the last thing that would help us. Sure, maybe it would have killed (eeek no!!!) or at least defeated Sauron, but it would have continued as it always goes... one dark lord dead, the next comes. there are always people who seek for power and might, hidden if there is some ruler but as soon as he's gone they suddenly pop out of the shadows. Thats not worth it. Feanor's sons showed what acting like that causes - weakening the own lines.
__________________ Life is complex: it has both real and imaginary components.
Could he have taken the ring from Isildur anyway? the ring would have given him incredible power.
And even if he took it from him with the intent to destroy it, could he have resisted the ring? the temptation of the ring was so great Gandalf didn't even want to touch it for a second. I doubt anyone of any race or creed in middle earth could destroy it purposefully
plus Isildur would die/kill before giving up the ring, Elrond taking it from him with force would have resulted in endless war between elves and men ruining what was achieved with the last alliance and probably all of middle earth too.
sure the next dark lord is just around the corner, but i'd rather destroyed one dark lord rather than none. let him be the example for the next. and the elves would've abandoned middle earth anyways. i don't think they are very keen to lingering evil just waiting to pop out any minute. if i knew there was another dark lord coming, i would get the f@#$ outta dodge...
after pushing him in, I would have come out saying:
"alright everybody shows over, nothing to see here!! let's all go home."
some human: "where is Isiuldur? where is the King?"
elrond/me: "ah,... he's still inside, he said he wanted to watch the ring melt, he'll be out in an hour or so... he said he wanted to be alone for a while...
come on elves let's go... (quickly)."
KMC Community Forums
What would Elrond do?
Feb 4th, 2004 02:07 AM
Besides, if I took the Ring from him, Mt. Doom will explode and neither of us could get out alive unless the Eagles are nearby. I don't want to die yet. I'll let him take the Ring for his own and I myself will flee to Valinor and leave the peoples of Middle-earth carrying their burden. 
You and sauron always manage to make me laugh in this forum. 
