AS I've said beforf there is no proof of finglolfin being a god-like fighter. Sauron wuold probably kick his sorry ass. Sauron could change shape to anything living and probably fool fingolfin to his death.
__________________ I am proud and honored to be Legolas's sister. In whose friendly embrace i shall feel conforted. And when times are ill he's always by my side.
LOL... WTF's your problem???!! sauron is a maia for crying out loud!!!
fingolfins attempt to fight MORGOTH was completely pointless. anyone can raise his sword before getting trampled to death. and morgoths bad wound was mostly ringils fault. getting squashed is not a proof of power!!! frodo was brave taking on the huge task and carrying the ring in to saurons land. brave not powerful. frodo would have been killed by morgoth too, and sting might have wounded just as bad as ringil did.
if anyone here is to shut up it's you cause you don't seem to know shit.
ur the N00b so STFU.
Gender: Male Location: Gondorlin, but dont tell anyone shh
well....he may be a maia but that dosnt mean that he is not unbeatable, if fingolfin killed sauron he would forfit his pysical form and it was before the ring so no ring-no worry of his spirt/thinggy living on until the ring is destroyed. If fingol slayed that ***** he would die as we no it......and he would kill him, he ran rings around the most powerful being in arda Melkor THE MOST powerful of the lot! he may of been killed but his gave him more of a pounding than tulkas a GOD! so sauron would be out for the count imo ^^
Fingolfin struck Melkor seven times and chopped off his foot. Melkor was afraid to fight Fingolfin because he knew that he might lose (he knew Fingolfin was the man). Sauron never attempted to defeat Melkor because he knew he would lose. Sauron lost in a fight to a dog (albeit a pretty good one). Fingolfin takes this one in a long drawn out fight because of Sauron's shapeshifting, but is never in danger of losing.
well....he may be a maia but that dosnt mean that he is not unbeatable, if fingolfin killed sauron he would forfit his pysical form and it was before the ring so no ring-no worry of his spirt/thinggy living on until the ring is destroyed. If fingol slayed that ***** he would die as we no it......and he would kill him, he ran rings around the most powerful being in arda Melkor THE MOST powerful of the lot! he may of been killed but his gave him more of a pounding than tulkas a GOD! so sauron would be out for the count imo ^^
Fingolfin fought a weakened Melkor who gave most of his power to his servants. Go ahead and read it again; Morgoth was very weak at that time due to the Silmirls and the fact he gave away most of his power. At that time Sauron was on stronger then Morgoth. And the only reason Sauron lost to the "dog" was because what's her name: Lauren I guess: helped weaken Sauron with her magic song thing.
chopped off his foot??? lol.... perhaps you should read the book again cause I'm afraid you're wrong.
and about that dog... huam was a gift from oromë - a vala. he had enormous powers, he wasn't just a dog. huam would never have won the fight between him and "werewolf sauron" without Lútien. It was two against one, so it's not a full victory for huam.
I hope you know that sauron was in control of werwolf's and other creatures. fingolfin would be busy with fighting them while sauron could do.... what ever he felt like doing, (killing fingolfin for example).
and sauron would never attack motgoth, because that's he's master. It's like Gandalf attacking Manwë.
Well, I'm not the most learned in Tolkien Lore, but it is Huan, and It is Luthien, and as for Huan beating Sauron, I personally think, he would have emerged victorious anyways, for If you give care to what has been published, then you would know also about the prophecy in relation to Huan.
I wolud agree with ESB-1138, fingolfin fought a weakend Melkor, and not just that, Melkor was confined to his physical form as of the two trees' incident, sauron was not; not until he made the ring, so logically if Sauron gets impaled upon ringil, he can abandon that physical form, for his fea would have survived, and he could then have taken another form. Thus tiring Fingolfin out, even though he had won several of the battles, he would eventually have tired out and die in the battle at Sauron's hands.
__________________ "Even The Wisest cannot see all Ends"
"The Question is not to be or not to be but to be nad yet not to be"
"If a quiz is quizzical, what is a Test?"
im gonna say fingolfin based on the fact that sauron was weakwer than melkor and filgolfin took it to him......o.k he died but he still gave him the seven mortal wounds.
That was only because Melkor could not leave that physical form.
__________________ "Even The Wisest cannot see all Ends"
"The Question is not to be or not to be but to be nad yet not to be"
"If a quiz is quizzical, what is a Test?"
KMC Community Forums
Feb 19th, 2006 07:08 AM
