quote: (post)

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Anyone?

I doubt even Melkor could.

Lets not even bring any version of Sauron into this conversation, Eonwe would destroy him.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by NemeBro
I mean, Melkor isn't particularly skilled at all. Fingolfin far outmatched him in terms of skill at arms, but Melkor was of such considerably higher power that he won anyway.

Anyway, in a contest of hand to hand or with weaponry no other Maia could defeat him. This is explicit. Sauron was probably more powerful, but he was a relatively average hand to hand combatant.

So I guess Tulkas. Tulkas would body him with absolutely no effort.

quote: (post)

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Yeah, but Morgoth was well past his prime, to the point Sauron in his prime would have been ahead of him.

I dunno about that. He is directly compared with Tulkas, tbh.

I know Tulkas is said to be the mightiest in terms of strength, but Eonwe is said to be the best with weapons in all of Arda.

I know, in terms of feats, Tulkas should theoretically take it, but its far more complicated then that due to the accolades.