Gender: Male Location: With a bunch of Aqua-Bitches fool !
Did Dumbledore and Severus Snape had a relationship?
Ok so i always wonderd why Dumbledore trusted Snape..
I mean the guy was a deadeater and stuff and because of him Harry parents got killed...
So what if Dumbledore was in love with Snape it's a nasty thought but it's possible it would explain his strong trust in him ..
This quote i found on wikipedia what if this love was Dumbledore
Could it be that Dumbledore was in love with Snape...
I wanna know you're though about my theorie...
i mean Dumbledore was a smart man but maybe his love for Snape clauded his judment..
Gender: Male Location: With a bunch of Aqua-Bitches fool !
And why is this theorie retarded? give me a reason.. or do you just like calling me name's like a little punk who get's big balls whenever he sits before a pc because he knows nobody gonna kick his a like a hooker who owed her pimp money ...
Gender: Male Location: With a bunch of Aqua-Bitches fool !
Wel with every new book the story matures...
Book one starded like a innocent childrens book and in book 4,5 and 6 people get killed and stuff..
So bringing in homosexualtity could be a new way for Jk to enter a next level of maturity and controversy i mean damn something like that would shine a whole new light on the series..
Worldwide yes, it's being accepted and even embraced more readily. Same-sex marriage is legal in some parts of the world already.
In a Potter book? Hell no.
Dead and mutilation are generic and come from the fact that Voldemort is back, of course there is going to be death, mutilation, injury. Blood. Your point being? Those are not the same thing and not on level with homosexuality. It's like comparing chairs to pianos, they're two completely different things. Don't associate them with each other.
That's because she hasn't actually done it yet, dimwit. You're probably one in ten million who speculate certain theories that was crap before and was crap in the end anyways.
Gayness in a children's book? You kidding me?
Even though kids have been reading it as they grow up, don't forget the younger generation that have only just started. What do you suppose Mom will think when little Kenneth asks why two men are kissing?
Gender: Male Location: Past the Point of No Return
Mom: "Give me that book." *goes into room for long period of time reading book. Kenneth is scarred for life hearing moaning sounds coming from the room and accidentally walking into the room to get his book back.*
__________________
Thank you Neha for the sig!
This years Musical: Little Shop of Horrors (sig for it hopefully coming soon)
Gender: Male Location: Barkdonald's Inc. OMFGPlulz: dunt
I always laugh when the best retort someone can come up with has to do with sex somehow. It's kind of pathetic, especially since you know nothing about me. Kinda random, like a last resort.
Gender: Male Location: With a bunch of Aqua-Bitches fool !
Yeah dead and mutilation are the most normal things in a childrens book..
The Harry Potter books are famed because with every new book they bring in aspecs a mature adience is familair with and in many countries the've evolved so far that there not holding there assses and light on the torches every time they hear the word gay witch means there familair with it England where Jk lives being one of them You're point being?
So i'f my theorie is crap why do you border debating my crap? Do you just love my crap or are you just afraid my crap could be true..
Who said anything about sex? I sure didn't the thread statedid
Dumbledore and Severus Snape had a relationship not are Dumbledore and Snape gonna have a gay sex scene in Harry Potter and the deadly Hollows a la Broke Back mountain..
Why the hell are you being off topic fantasizing about a gay sex scene dude...Jk can put some hints in here new book about a relationship not a fr*kkin sex scene smartass
Again who said anything about sex??!!
Didn't you read the thread ?? Why are you fantasizing about a gay sex scene that wasn't my intend when i created this thread ..So gues that means you're the pathetic one
And i don't know you but uhm.. with these kind of statements you're giving me the strong impression someone is locked up in the closet..
Gender: Male Location: With a bunch of Aqua-Bitches fool !
Well it could be .. I mean it was never stated in any of the other books that he had a wife or was heterosexuel ..
JK killed Dumbledore in book six i really didn't saw that coming and in the end it brought in more money controversy and fans and making Dumbledore turn out gay would cause a similar if not greater effect..
I wouldn't like it if he'd turned out gay personally i would be shocked just like how i was shocked at when she killed Dumbledore i wouldn''t eat or speak for days
But it made me like her more as a writer i'f she just killed of characters which the fans love that's a sign that woman doesn't give a f*ck gotta give her mad props for that ...
It's true, they bring newer concepts and realities into the children's world. While death and multilation are familiar in children's books, none convey the tragedy of it as much as Rowling does in her Potter books.
However, bringing in an oblique and controversial subject matter such as homosexuality for example, or racism into the Potter books is much more dangerous to incorporate into a childrens' book. Do you see those justified for a good reason in any "children'"s books? No. Your argument is moot. Even if England and the world is familiar with it, it would be a stupid idea to insert into every aspect of everyday life there is.
Oh, because someone "loves" your crap means that they'll oppose you about it every time you throw a moronic point out into the blue.
That's the stupidest logic I've ever seen.
No, I just feel very strongly against your idea and I happen to like a good debate. Stop assuming nonsense.
"Afraid your crap" would be true? Absolute bullshit. Because hey, it'll never, ever happen. Face it.
Whether sexuality is involved in your so called couple doesn't have relevance to the actual subject itself. You really pulled that point out of your ass, didn't you?
Sex or not, homosexuality as a topic is still homosexuality.
I personally challenge you to find any point in his statement where he seriously indicated that he was fantasizing about said sex scene. And JK may have set some hints about a relationship, but not a homosexual one and certainly not between Dumbledore and Snape.
Stick to the subject, not to pathetically attempting to make yourself look good by giving the scapegoat tag to someone else.
If you take his inherent trust in Snape and slap it as "love", then you're more delusional than I thought. Read book five and six again.
This is supposed to be a debate, my shortsighted impudent friend. And yet, here you are throwing completely off-topic insults about others who oppose your sense of view like a foolish little child throwing toy bowling pins at the neighbour.
Two words: grow up.
No no no, it's you who's pathetic. Not only do you accuse him of being gay and an extremely perverted one at that, which was entirely uncalled for, you did it to me as well. Tell me, is that the only comeback you can muster? Take an originality pill for once. Not once have you given back a true and clearly expressed point, with backing arguments to be debated. You're just slinging barbs around, that's what you're doing.
Oh, and stop making childish little assumptions about his own sex life as well. That's his business and none of yours. Kindly mind your own bloody business, thank you very much.
And neither it was stated in any of the books that he had a husband or was homosexual.
So why are you assuming above, especially when it has almost no real concrete backup? Seems premature to me. It's far too controversial a topic, having Dumbledore die caused enough uproar. And no you think she'll honestly ship him up there with Snape? Death is one thing, finding out that the greatest wizard in the Potter series was gay is another. Learn to distinguish the two.
A lot of people like surprises, that's true. But there's different kinds. The reaction after being X or Y or so on. Death, hey that's normal even in the world of a child.
They don't, however, have to find out that Dumbledore was in love with Snape. It's just too dangerous a topic to bring into a child's world.
You love her as a writer because she kills people off and hits us where we expect it least? That's not what I value in her as an author. I value her ingenuity and talent for creating a world that is unreal, yet still keenly imaginable. If you want suspense and being caught off guard, go read Jeffery Deaver.
KMC Community Forums
but it's possible it would explain his strong trust in him ..
Feb 7th, 2007 12:05 AM
id
