Saw most of those already, I was in fact just reading that page.
[SPOILER - highlight to read]: A lot of the stuff on it is very contradictory, though. I mean, compare what's said about the epilogue (written like a newspaper article) to what the 'scans' on the bottom shown (written like just another chapter), also the events in the scanned epilogue state that Ron lives, which goes against what's at the top of that page.
However, from what I can find the US edition of the book is 784 pages long. That scanned epilogue is nearly 30 pages short on that.
Those are all rumors that've been going around for a few days now. I wouldn't really buy any of them as being true because they're all so contradictory.
Though apparently, from what I've heard elsewhere, the first...2/3rds, I think, of the book has been scanned and put online. I like spoilers but that's going a bit too far I think
I hadn't seen this before so it was interesting. I made sure to scan carefully because I didn't want to be spoliled in case it is true. But the fact that some have scans from the book iteself, with pictures, yeah, a bit too much. I'm sure they can get in a LOT of trouble if they were caught.
__________________
Learn from yesterday...
Live for today...
Hope for tomorrow...
Those scans have been circling the internet for a few days; they usually don't last long wherever they are because they get spotted and pulled down almost immediately. I've been following the fun over on livejournal and it's taken me two days just to find a post that HAD them so I could see what all the fuss was about.
However, the very fact that there's been nothing done about the scans other than them being deleted off the sites they've been hosted on leads me to believe that they're fake. I mean, there was a freaking explosion when that page from HBP was leaked. This is an entire chapter and nothing.
Not to mention, as I pointed out above, a lot of contradictions with other spoilers, and one of the very few facts that we know.
2) There is absolutely no confirmation that the leaked epilogue is true. As I also pointed out, it ends on page 759, when the US edition is confirmed to be 784 pages long. Thus there's 25 pages just...missing.
Gender: Male Location: Past the Point of No Return
I just want to say this title is misleading. There are potential spoilers in this thread, in which it says no spoilers. If I didn't read the part about "These are suppose to be legit spoilers" I would have clicked on the link. Please be more careful about this.
__________________
Thank you Neha for the sig!
This years Musical: Little Shop of Horrors (sig for it hopefully coming soon)
Gender: Male Location: Past the Point of No Return
It says (no spoilers). It's misleading. Once more, if it wasn't labeled in the first post that the link holds legit spoilers I and probably others would have looked at it. It's misleading.
__________________
Thank you Neha for the sig!
This years Musical: Little Shop of Horrors (sig for it hopefully coming soon)
Gender: Male Location: Godric Hallow, with gryffindors swo
this is bad... Deathly hallows, the whole book, has been leaked on bittorrent. this isn't god for harry potter fans who are waiting for the boos to come out. so i urge you to stay away from anytorrent websites if you dont want to have the book spoiled for you. Also remember use the spoiler highlight to hide anything about the book. And if you spoil it for me i will go on a rage that will make voldemorts reighn look like it was ruled by carebears.
In all fairness, Solo did not post any spoilers in the thread, and it would be harsh to argue that a link is a spoiler in itself. What other people posted does not make the thread a misleading title; it is quite clear, (no spoilers).
You have nitpicked so much, that you seem to be blurring the reality and your own assumptions here. Why place emphasis on such a trivial detail when it's blatant to anyone with any reading comprehension that he did not, in fact post a spoiler on this page?
He posted a link to a spoiler, with a spoiler warning. The title is not misleading at all.
KMC Community Forums
Jul 16th, 2007 07:07 AM
