When Luke was hanging upside down in the Wampa's cave, his feet were apparently frozen over or stuck to, the ceiling. When he used his saber, he gave one quick swing and suddenly his feet drop free. Since lightsabers don't give off heat, it couldn't have flash-melted it, and you wouldn't think one, barely aimed swing would cut through ice so precisely as to miss his feet. Is there something else behind this amazing feat?
__________________ Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos.
the Force Answer to all SW scenes that don't make any sense.
I've always wondered since Anakin as a young boy had "quick reflexes...can see things before they happen, etc," did that mean Luke should've experienced some Jedi traits too as a child? Or had they been diluted from his mother's non-Jedi side?
__________________ Paying member of the Official Cliegg Lars Fan Club
if you swing a lightsaber thru a forest, could you start a fire then?
Maybe it's a noncombustible energy source.
Oh and I think Tangible meant he sorta just swung at it, and his feet fell out of the block of ice, when it coulda actually cut his feet off as well. If he had cut just the top part, his feet would've been still incased in ice even though he wouldn't be hanging anymore.
__________________ Paying member of the Official Cliegg Lars Fan Club
Last edited by SpyCspider on Jan 20th, 2006 at 05:41 PM
Registered: Jun 2005
Location: Down at the River of Dreams
And if it didn't give off heat why would Anakin's arm but burnt from where Dooku sliced it off. If it wasn't for the heat of the lightsaber Anakin and Luke would have died.
of course it gives off heat, you don't see blood when Anakin got his arm off, cause the heat immediatly closed the wound, same with Dooku's hands, you can actually see it burns...except in ANH, but that was an error.
__________________
"The greatest hero is the one who learns to face his fears and overconquers it!"
This is a problem embedded with the chronology of the movies. In the OT, whenever a lightsaber makes contact with matter, that matter doesn't burn. You don't even see any sizzled flesh or cloth.
In the PT however, everything the lightsaber touches, burns.
I mean it doesn't give off heat in the sense that, if you held your hand close enough to it, you wouldn't feel any heat coming from it, but once you touched it you would.
To restate my question, Luke just made a random swing at the ice. It wasn't controlled or disciplined, how could he have carved out the shape of both feet in one quick swing?
__________________ Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos.
That's the point. Lightsaber's HAVE officially been said to not radiate heat. And if you watch that scene again, he made one, quick, virtually random swipe, and his feet drop free. His whole foot was stuck in the ice, he would have to carve it out to drop as fast he did.
__________________ Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos.
Registered: Jul 2005
Location: Wouldn't you like to know?
All valid points!
I think lightsabers give off heat when they touch an object (e.g. in ROTS, right when Obi turns on his lightsaber to face Dooku, his saber was like 1 inch from himself. he should have felt the heat otherwise). When the saber touched the ice, it gave off enough heat to melt all the ice
Yes, there was a mistake how the wampa's arm was bloody, while the legs of the ackley and the arms and heads of humans were burned
__________________
"And thus I clothe my naked villainy/With old odd ends, stol'n forth of holy writ;/And seem a saint, when most I play the devil."
And I don't truly know how sabers work, but I know that they give off no heat, no matter how close you are to the blade. Heat is only added to the material it touches, AFTER it touches it, e.g. The blast doors Qui-Gon cut.
When Obi-Wan's robes were cut, no flames, no sizzling.
When both that Aqualish's and the Wampa's arm were cut, again, blood, but nothing burnt.
When Luke loses his hand, no blood, but there is charred flesh and cloth.
Only when the PT was made did they correct all these mistakes. Sabers now have a set repercussion for whenever they touch something, unlike in the OT when it seemed to vary.
__________________ Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos.
Jan 20th, 2006 03:24 AM
Answer to all SW scenes that don't make any sense.
