First and foremost, both of your sigs were very good. This was a hard duel to judge.
H.S.6
I think the sig has an overall magical feel to it. The background you used really put pulled her out of the sig and drew my attention to it right away.
I liked the fact that you added ( what looks likes leaves ) to the render, for it adds a lot to the overall picture.
I also liked the text that you used, it was a very suitable font, adding to the general feel of it.
Alliance
I liked your sig as well, and the use of Animation was one that I was quite impressed with. Being such a pretty render, you were to capture a innocence of her by simply making her blink so sweetly.
I disliked the font that you used, and the placement of it, for it feels a little out of place as to where it is now.
I'm just trying things out. Many people at KMC have similar styles, I'm trying to work on one that is my own. I really like your comments on the text. I need to think up a snazzy acronym for my name so I can put it so artistically in the coner .
Oh, I like alliance very much. Its just I can't plop it in the corner so easily like "HS6" I'm aiming for a "Hotsauce"/"HS6" type thing where i can use either one when I want too.
I like sticking big long words like Alliance in the background (note the Ahmadinejad), but they are bulky in front of the renders.
Text is so often whored into sigs. I often don't want to put it in. Text is still a hit or miss for me.
In all honesty, I wanted to leave the text out...couldn't find a good place to put it. If anyone thinks of something useful to do with text, let me know...ill give you a dollar.