I agree with your AL predictions, and I am very curious as to what your NL predictions are...Here is mine
Dodgers VS. Cardinals
Starting Rotation:
Game1: Perez(7-6) VS Williams(11-8)
Game2: Weaver(13-13) VS Marquis(15-7)
Game3: Lima(13-5) VS Morris(15-10)
The Cardinals rotation would be better than the Dodgers if Chris Carpenter was going to be playing (he's out for the entire NLDS), and if Matt Morris wasn't struggling. With that said, I think the starting pitcher's will matchup well. All three pitchers for the Dodgers can have great success...but all 3 can also be out of the game within the first 3 innings. It's hard to tell with those guys, they aren't consistent. Lima is prolly throwing the best right now.
Advantage: Even
Hitting:
Cardinals obviously have the best offense in the Majors. They hit for power, average, and can clutch hit. The Dodgers have an offense that could be one of the best, if they were more consistent, and didn't rely on late inning heroics.
Advantage: Cardinals
Bullpen:
If the Dodgers wouldn't have traded Mota, and Gagne was 100%, then I might give the edge to the Dodgers. However, that is not the case. The Cardinals have Isringhausen and others who have performed well under pressure...but some of the relievers are also known to choke.
Advantage: Even
Defense:
Dodgers have made less errors (I believe) and have a better Fielding Percentage (not by much). Besides errors, the numbers almost match.
Advantage: Dodgers, slightly
Managers:
Jim Tracy has done a swell job with the Dodgers this year. His playoff experience isn't much...and if they plan on making late inning comebacks, they will have already lost.
Tony La Russa has playoff experience, and is a definite Hall-of-Famer. If he continues to manage the way he has all year, the Cardinals should be just fine.
Advantage: Cardinals
Prediction: Cardinals in 4
Astros VS. Braves
Ahhhh Atlanta...the team I have followed since I was 7, since they lost the 91 World Series. This year was the year the Braves were sposed to find themselves in 3rd place, behind the Phillies and Marlins...but no, that didn't happen. Supreme coaching has led them back to the playoffs for the 13th consecutive year. The Astros are on a very
hot streak...but we all know streaks will end. Roger Clemens won't be 100% on Wednesday, no matter what he says.
Starting Rotation:
Game1: Clemens(18-4) VS Wright(15-8)
Game2: Oswalt(20-10) VS Thomson(14-8)
Game3: Houston hasn't made a dection VS Hampton(13-9)
Wright and Thomson were both huge surprises this year in their success. They have done well, and I think they will
both do well in the playoffs. I will never doubt Clemens, whether he is 100% or not, but I think that he will matchup perfectly with Wright(remember, Wright has post-season experience with the Indians). Although the Astros look better statistically, historically the Braves have dominated the Astros in October. I think that out of all
the series to watch, this none will be the most fun.
Advantage: Even
Hitting:
Phew, Biggio, Bagwell, Burkman, Beltran...scary! I would not want to face these guys. If the Astros continue to
hit the way they have since the end of August, only the Cardinals will be able to match them. However, I have a feeling that the Astros are losing steem. Chipper Jones is supposedly ok, after being hit on the hand with a Carlos Zambrano fastball on Saturday. With both teams healthy, and Clemens and Wright on the mound for game 1, I think the bats of both teams will be tamed. Also, Oswalt has either killed the Braves, or the Braves have killed Oswalt. The Braves have better pinch and clutch hitting, while the Astros have a better 1-8 lineup (statistically).
Advantage: Astros, slightly
Bullpen:
Sure, Brandon Lidge has done awesome as the closer for Houston. But does he compare to Smoltz? Simply put,
no. As far as relievers, Juan Cruz, Antonio Alfonseca, and Chris Reitsma all can go 2 innings for the Braves. I think this is where the Braves must succeed...in getting the Astros into their bullpen by the 6th inning. The Astros bullpen is probably their Achilles Heel. Also, the Braves have the best ERA in the NL(possibly majors?).
Advantage: Braves
Defense:
The Braves first half was horrible. All baseball fans know that. A lot of their errors came in the first half. Once Chipper Jones returned to 3rd, and Charles Thomas and Eli Marrero took over in Right Field, these guys become solid by mid-August. The Astros have a good defense, but it's just that - it's good. The Braves have an awesome defense. They have the fastest outfield in the majors, led by the 2nd best center fielder to ever play the game, Andruw Jones (Willie Mays will be the best until Jones retires, when their numbers will be compared). The Braves are top 3 in turning double plays (I think they have turned the most, but I'm not positive).
Advantage: Braves
Managers:
Phil Garner took over around the All-Star Break for Jimmy Williams. He has done a good job, but I don't credit the Astros success to him. I credit it to the Cubs! If the Cubs wouldn't have went into the Astrodome, acting "tough" one might say, then the Astros Players wouldn't have kicked it into high gear for the final 60 games of the season. The Cubs/Astros scuffle that occured lit a fire in Houston.
Bobby Cox. Need I say more?
Advantage: Braves by far
Overrall:
I think the Braves play better as underdogs...they proved it all year. With Andy Petite out, I think the Braves have the overall edge over the Astros. As long as the Braves can get into the Astros bullpen, there is no reason this shouldn't be over in 3 games. But then there is Roger clemens and Roy Oswalt. If they both pitch to their
abilities, this will go to game 5.
Braves in 4