Better Point Guard? You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
Jason Kidd 6 42.86%
Steve Nash 8 57.14%
Total: 14 votes 100%
Darth Martin The Yautja King Gender: Male
Jason Kidd vs Steve Nash
Both in their prime. Which for Nash is now and Kidd was a few years ago.
07:47 AM
Lord Evolution Legendary Gender: Male
I think I will take the guy that is a walking triple double has been to two NBA championships and can play defense... __________________ http://broughtoyou.com
07:49 AM
Myth Give me your babies!!! Gender: Male
I'm going with Kidd as well. His prime was also before the league made rules that benefit PGs. Plus what Lord Evo mentioned (minus the Laker thing).
__________________
08:35 AM
Darth Martin The Yautja King Gender: Male
Alright let's compare them!
04:58 PM
wuTa Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
I'm going with Nash, two MVPS, more effective offensively, plays at just a high level as a Kind in a better conference, and way tougher division. unless Kidd has a championship over Nash, I'm going with Steve.
__________________
05:18 PM
Myth Give me your babies!!! Gender: Male
Kidd was higher than Shaq on MVP votes in 2002 which to me is more effective than Nash who could barely beat a lesser Shaq in 2005.
__________________
09:09 PM
RecSpecs110 Link Saves the Day Gender: Male
Kidd should have won an MVP that year.
__________________ Beware of my shadow.
09:14 PM
wuTa Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Myth Kidd was higher than Shaq on MVP votes in 2002 which to me is more effective than Nash who could barely beat a lesser Shaq in 2005.
__________________
09:25 PM
Myth Give me your babies!!! Gender: Male
I don't see how it is irrelevant. It shows that Kidd beat out a dominant Shaq while Nash barely beat out a lesser Shaq. Thats an undeniable point in Kidd's favor.
__________________
09:33 PM
wuTa Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
Hmm, maybe irrelevant was a poor choice of words, Kidd beating Shaq out was 5 years ago, Nash is beating out todays best presently, not to mention that Kidd had to be traded to the East to finally get MVP recongition, Nash has always stay put in the West where we all know the level of competetion is much higher.
__________________
09:40 PM
Corndog Member Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by wuTa I'm going with Nash, two MVPS, more effective offensively, plays at just a high level as a Kind in a better conference, and way tougher division. unless Kidd has a championship over Nash, I'm going with Steve.
__________________
11:05 PM
Myth Give me your babies!!! Gender: Male
Both? Kobe wasn't deserving two years ago.
__________________
12:12 AM
Corndog Member Gender: Male
He's always deserving.
__________________
02:02 AM
RecSpecs110 Link Saves the Day Gender: Male
Nash deserved his first MVP.
__________________ Beware of my shadow.
02:22 AM
Corndog Member Gender: Male
But Kobe was right there.
__________________
02:42 AM
Corndog Member Gender: Male
Two years ago.
__________________
02:46 AM
Darth Martin The Yautja King Gender: Male
Let's stay on topic please.
03:45 AM
Myth Give me your babies!!! Gender: Male
quote: (post ) Originally posted by RecSpecs110 Nash deserved his first MVP.
__________________
06:28 AM
wuTa Senior Member Gender: Unspecified
I beg the differ, he earned them both. If anything, he was more deserving the 2nd time.
__________________
06:33 AM
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threadsmay not post repliesmay not post attachmentsmay not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG] code is ON
Text-only version
KMC Community Forums
Feb 22nd, 2007 07:47 AM
