If a patient asks a doctor to perform a procedure that is within her expertise, but that she finds unethical, should she do it? If she refuses, is she imposing her values on the patient? What if the doctor knows that such a denial will mean that the patient will find less sanitary and safe means for achieving the same goal, thus putting the patient at much greater risk? Does the doctor have an ethical obligation to ensure that the patient is kept as safe as possible, even if that means performing an otherwise unethical procedure?
There are two different but related problems to address here. The first is the balance between patient autonomy and the doctor' s own values. Which should take precedence?
The second involves the manner in which the principle of "do no harm" should be understood and applied. Is it more harmful to perform a procedure which is unnecessary and unethical, or to let the patient do it independently with greater risk of infection and death?
Source: about.com
__________________
I am not driven by people’ s praise and I am not slowed down by people’ s criticism.
You only live once. But if you live it right, once is enough.
Make poverty history.
Stop aids, keep the promise.
I think a doctor should have the right to refuse any procedure really. From my own moral POV, a doctor should rather perform a procedure than letting the person do it in much less sanitary or safe ways.
__________________
Bardock42 is a whimpering pussy now who lost his flare to debate vigorously and just spouts senseless and thinly veiled puns here and there. You nazi pr*ck. Get your balls back from whoever you sold them to, you fat f*ck. What happened to the manly, chubby German big mouth we once knew, who'd flatten ignorance with a solid argument? Now it's like Andy Dick meets John Candy. You hybrid beefcake. Suck my c*ck
The Doctor should not act in a way that violates their conscience.
__________________
Oh come on...we both know you don't think "boring"...you think "blood-boilingly offensive" and lament the loss of the former glory and torture power of the Holy See.
Gender: Male Location: al-Jumhuuriyya al-Yamaniyya
The doctor should have the right to refuse to perform the procedure but, morally at least, should advise the patient on how to reach another qualified professional that can and will perform the procedure.
__________________
Graffiti outside Latin class.
Sed quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
A juvenal prank.
I would answer...but I'm just about to perform a kidney transplant on myself.
__________________
Oh come on...we both know you don't think "boring"...you think "blood-boilingly offensive" and lament the loss of the former glory and torture power of the Holy See.
I hope it all goes well my friend. I'm going for a lesser thing, to take my wisdom teeth out. We can't really compare it, but if I'm allright then so should you be.
__________________ That something is difficult, is it not more a reason for doing it?
They are making fun of you. Man, some people are oblivious.
__________________
Bardock42 is a whimpering pussy now who lost his flare to debate vigorously and just spouts senseless and thinly veiled puns here and there. You nazi pr*ck. Get your balls back from whoever you sold them to, you fat f*ck. What happened to the manly, chubby German big mouth we once knew, who'd flatten ignorance with a solid argument? Now it's like Andy Dick meets John Candy. You hybrid beefcake. Suck my c*ck
Yes, the doctor should perform what a patient asks if they have the knowledge on how to do it. Yes, she is imposing her own values towards that patient.
__________________ Deja Moo: The feeling that you've heard this bull before.
Great bioethics question! I don't think it interferes with patient autonomy if the doctor refuses because of values they might have, the patient can just go somewhere else if they want.
They should do what they think is wrong? If I was a doctor and was asked to do something that in my opinion violated my oath, I would refuse. Ethically I would be required to, because I might not preform to the best of my ability during the surgery or operation. I would however be required to give a referral to someone willing to do the operation, even if it went against my moral code.
KMC Community Forums
Aug 13th, 2008 12:54 PM
