Why not? Is there anything wrong with my question? I mean if you can have PF VS LT questions, why not this? I'm just trying to clarify the hierachy of power.
i do not degrade the power of THOTU or TOAA sept when in comparison to the presance and i can back up my claims i can also back up my claims to the LT's degrading himself so can GS even greater then me THOTU is suppose to be the main power of all it destroyed the multiverse sept for the places outside of it so who wins hmm let me think THOTU to me maybe GS says no but from my understanding of what THOTU is it is the very power of TOAA but thats just IMO
Fair enough, I'm not saying that those claims are wrong , dont get me wrong.
So in other words, despite being a follower of GS's PF club, you still think HOTU is more powerful and you are not convinced by GS that PF>HOTU? Thank you for your honesty.
And btw all our comments are IMO or IMHO, even GS's ...
im not part of any club me and her or him have probably disputed in the past if i was part of any club id say that thanos or ss was unbeatable thank you my opinions are my own and others share them with me before she or he came up with the idea of the PF being greater then the LT i believe i was the one who hated the LT's guts because people actually thought he was greater then the pre-reconned beyonder.
1. He didn't create doubt about TOAA (surely not in me), but it's clear we don't know much about TOAA, so it's better to put him out, also GS agreed with that. He can't say TOAA isn't supreme as we can't say he trully is supreme (because no where is stated, we can only assume, but that is not enough).
2. He didn't degrade LT, he only showed to many people truth. Many automaticly give LT over Phoenix (why, because they don't follow comic and still think it's the same, while it's not). Even Eternity said Phoenix to be beyond LT and any other abstract. LT wasn't downgraded, it was only told the truth and facts. There is only Phoenix beyond LT, so that really isn't downgrade in power.
3. Well, he didn't downgrade HOTU, but he thinks Phoenix Force to be beyond because of better feats. But we really can't judge by that, since HOTU was so little in comic and has done already one of the greatest feats ever in MU, only in one issue (making most powerful cosmic powers ever and others in MU like an antz at the same time, excluding PF, but could PF do the same to all major cosmic powerhouses, including other, as Zeus, Celestials, Galactus and... many other like HOTU did, I don't know, more no like yes). Even Phoenix didn't succeed with that. I think Phoenix Force cannot compare to HOTU.
__________________
Last edited by Xplosive on Jan 31st, 2006 at 06:09 PM
Yes, put him out, so PF is No 1. Here we are supposed not to speculate, so we take out TOAA.
Please note, my comments about his recent direction, do not imply in any way, whether he is right or wrong. The word 'disgrade' is not meant to imply that he is wrong or right.
I take from your comments, he has succeeded in doing 1) and 2) .
Since most people think HOTU is more powerful than PF due to it's power in making LT look like an ant, to question the power of HOTU is to 'degrade' its power with the intent to make PF more powerful.
In the thread about LT versus PF, he is trying to diminish the feats of HOTU....
exactly. Since we have zero evidence PF can do that, why is it then that GS insists on placing PF beyond HOTU? What happened to the rule of not speculating?
Do we extend the benfit of the doubt only in the direction of supporting PF?
So it seems GS has failed in 3. For you.
Thank you for your comments
Last edited by Richrf on Jan 31st, 2006 at 06:19 PM
Holy firey birds Batman!!! 15 post and GS still hasn't made an appearance yet!
__________________ We're on the side of the demons Cheif. We're evil men in the garden of paradise, sent by the forces of death to bring destruction and devestation wherever we go.
Probably even GS is daunted by the magnitude of the task. He needs a lot of magic, since so far not a single one person is ready to support PF, not even his converts.
My guess is he's going to either go for the "who knows?We don't know enough" arguments and generously concede PF might be equal to HOTU,
OR
he might just say he is proud of his accomplishments so far in
First, making people believe PF = LT (stage 1)
Then, making people believe PF >LT (stage 2)
So he isn't going to push his luck to convince people PF>HOTU even though that is true.
Look, about TOAA, I personaly give him as supreme being and beyond anyone or anything, but can I prove that, no really I can't, so that is why I said, the best is to put TOAA out of debates, bceause we can't prove anything, you also can't, we can only assume he is the supreme.
As you can see, in my opinion PF is not no. 1.
He succede, because he is right. You cannot argue against facts. I agree with him Phoenix being beyond LT, is because he is right.
Now, do you think PF is beyond LT, also Eternity said that, do you think PF is beyond LT?
He cannot diminish HOTU feats. In his opinion PF is more powerful, in your or mine, HOTU is more powerful. He wants PF to be more powerful and trying to prove it, but with me he hasn't succeed in that not even with 0.1%. For me what HOTU did is better than anyhtin Pheonix did, like stopping M'Krann Crystal, for me HOTU feat is far better. And I put HOTU beyond PF, no matter how much I think Phonix is powerful, not in HOTU league.
He can insist, but won't succeed, because PF is not more powerful than HOTU, it's otherwise.
In my opinion, TOAA of course and HOTU are beyond Phoenix. After them is Phoenix in 3rd place and after Pheonix it's LT.
What is true?
__________________
Last edited by Xplosive on Jan 31st, 2006 at 06:46 PM
You cannot talk about TOAA. Because you think we cannot prove anything about him.
GS needs to do one last thing for you, to convicne you that PF>HOTU, this thread is meant to give him a chance to do that. It's the next logical step...
Sure you can. When the 'facts' are merely interpretions. That's the fun of these debates.
Why hasn't he succeeded? Because he is wrong? I'm sure GS would beg to differ.
"For you" ? So does that mean it's subjective? It's not a fact that HOTU is more powerful than PF? It just seems so for you?
But you think it's a fact that PF>LT?
Ah, the naive viewpoint that 'truth' will always win out.. .
Have you changed your mind about anything in comics?
Pretty much when anyone say here one forum anything is subjective (especailly on Vs. Forum).
It was said by Eternity, so it's pretty much a fact.
HOTU is Heart of the Universe, when Thanos had it's power, it seemed he was almighty. He crushed LT, Eternity, Infinity, everything at the same time and destroyed them like with an blink of an eye.
No matter what power opposed him, it was nothing, was it Akhenan or MU Vs. THOTU, it didn't matter, they were nothing, combined or alone. MU Vs. THOTU was like nothing Vs. THOTU.
__________________
Last edited by Xplosive on Jan 31st, 2006 at 07:20 PM
KMC Community Forums
Jan 31st, 2006 04:08 PM
Cap was my hero
