The previous thread hit almost a hundred pages the last time I ever looked at it. I believe the overwhelming consensus was that BA wins it. There were decent arguments for the other side but it was mostly getting into specific scenarios, "Well, what if she did this instead?" "Well, what if he did that?"
That last thread wasn't a good basis for anything. If I remember correctly, the MAJORITY of it was baiting and flaming. Damn near 100 pages of it. Either that or people arguing over things that just didn't matter for the fight. Or people just coming in the thread and saying "_____ wins." with no evidence or argument whatsoever. If a mod deleted everything but actual debating over the fight, I'm pretty sure that thread would be MUCH smaller.