This is to see who can take more. They stand right next to each other and each person gets to hit the other one. No one is holding back. Who gets knocked out first? Again dodging is not allowed...and may the toughest man win.
In their last fight Superman wasn't holding back, and Black Adam was... as Black Adam was framed, and was trying to talk sense into Superman.
*I heard on the forum a while ago that Black Adam lost that fight, because he turned around when Supes was about to throw a punch, and BA was apparently not holding back in that comic... but it's not true *
Anyway, don't care who wins... just wanted to throw that out there.
Superman always holds back. Even when he doesn't seem like it. It is due to his mental blocks (subconsciously doesn't want to take life).
For example, he was holding back nearly the whole time in his first fight with DD. It wasn't till the very end where Lois talked him in to not holding back. After I read that, I was blown away at the fact that Superman was actually fighting DD not holding back (his crazy as$). Because it certainly didn't seem like it to me.
I feel that Black Adam wins this. He hits harder than Supes. Both can take a punding and have durability but I feel Black Adam will be going for the kill each and every time he hits him. He has more experience in this regard as well.
Well if its too superpowered guys not holding back in just a slugfest, may the toughest man who's got nothing to lose win. In just strictly a fistfight like this, I'd have to say Black Adam has all the right qualities to win against someone like Superman in only a punchfest: Toughness, no holds-barred attitude, and a willingness to fight dirty. BA 5/10, and Superman 5/10, even split just because Superman is a beast when he gets to cut loose.