Gender: Male Location: Eastern Seaboard, United States
Supes for the majority. This Superman really would spend the whole fight speedbitzing and going invisible/intangible. During this era, he was least likely to fight like a brick.
Thor during Blood and Thunder fought like a deranged brick. Thor would definitely be a handful, but Supes has a clear advantage.
Gender: Male Location: Drinking gasoline. Pissing napalm.
Isn't the first time he goes intangible two years after OWAW was written, in 2003 (Doomsday Rex)?
And while I definitely agree that Superman would blitz Thor to hell, I don't think he's going to be able to drop him like that. Too durable during that run. And Thor in that arc was one-shotting planets and easily physically overpowering SS, BRB, and Drax w/ PG (even one-shotting him at one point.) So, I'll take Thor for the majority. 7-8/10.
And Thor beat the shit out of the Silver Surfer, Beta Ray Bill, Drax with the power gem, classic Dr. Strange, and Adam Warlock before he received the PG.