The thing about this fight is that team 2 cant make not one mistake or they're dead. Either one team 1 have power output that would mess team two up.
We have true planet busters on team 1. Physically, BRB has proven that he can easily unleash planet destroying attacks. Black bolt power output is almost next to limitless along with his versatility.
The edge that team two have is speed and being ultimately strategic.
Theres no reason for Supes to be over thor though.
Thor is as strong if not stronger than supes. Thor durability is above supes. Thor output of power is above supes and BRB bio proves that he can go above the speed of light.
Thor and BRB have everything that supes has plus interest. Thats something I'll never truly understand, thor is more powerful than supes in almost every category but some people still gives him the win.
In the first fight, Thor turned into Donald Blake and Beta Ray Bill knocked out a cripple. In the second fight, Beta Ray Bill was given the direct advantage, as he couldn't take Thor in a fair fight. And that's with Thor being underwritten horribly in that entire arc to the point some lava is apparently fatal. The same Thor who flies through the hearts of Stars without bother and has withstood the power of an exploding Sun completely unharmed. Heat has kind of been proven useless against him.
Outside of that, whenever they've meet on even grounds, Beta Ray Bill has had his ass kicked. Three times. Badly. The best he did was jump Thor and momentarily down him as he downed Silver Surfer.
Please, enlighten me with these showings of Beta Ray Bill kicking the crap out of Thor.
That was some bad writing. All of a sudden the greatest warrior in the DCU starts underestimating her opponents and loses to a group far below her? Forgetting her powerset? I really hope Gail explains that one . . .
Anyway, Team 2 wins 7/10. Aegis is all that team 1 needs to protect itself from BB most dangerous weapon. Supes or WW beat BB in my opinion and who ever is fighting BRB can hold on long enough for the other to assist when done with BB.