Cheetah is still too fast.
Kalibak may not be as fast, but imho this incarnation of Kalibak is durable to enough to withstand some of Thor's strongest blows.
Besides, he can provide as a distraction for Cheetah to maul Thor.
Barring the Godblast, I'd give Thor a 3/10.
__________________
"Farewell, Damos... Ash, Pikachu... And you. All of my beloved." -- Arceus
I'm not impressed with Cheetah's "mauling" ability. It would be just scratches to Thor. Thor was taking much more powerful cuts recently in Mephisto's realm. I'd say who was doing the cutting but just saying their name has them poofing before you and cutting you up. I'm too chicken. I also won't say candyman in front of a mirror 3 times.
Mother box is standard for New Genesis Gods, not Apokoptian ones. However, if they have their own tech, it can activate the Boom Tube. Big Barda did so with her Megarod. The Boom Tube itself is fairly standard for any NG of any importance.
In Kalibak's case, I believe his beta rod activates his boom tube, and I'm pretty sure I've seen him show up from a tube on his own or with parademons.
I've never seen him use it offensively in battle like Barda and Orion sometimes do, but he can use it to get around.
If we're talking Perez' Cheetah, and Kalibak in general, then I'd go with Thor for a solid majority. He might be in some bruised shape, but he'll take the team.
Of course, limiting Barbara to the 80's/90's version is a touch intellectually dishonest; at that point, you would have to comparably use a "low-showing" Thor, one more vulnerable to piercing/slashing attacks, like how (for example) WW was back in the late 80's/early 90's.
Post-"Zoom upgrade" (which, btw, I don't like as a reference, as it very much misleads many posters into thinking Zoom had something directly to do with Barbara's increase in power, which he didn't, other than telling her over and over again "I can't help you with that -- the power is within you already, you just have to realize it for yourself..."), Team has a better chance of getting wins via Cheetah's vastly superior speed (faster than WW or SM in combat, when she decides to "get serious") and Kalibak really fighting as hard as he can. But overall, I go with Thor.
__________________ Why am I here commenting on this crap?