Rumor has it that arms dealer socialite Bruce Wayne has been cheating with his butler Alfred J. Pennyworth. Wayne's publicist has denied rumors, but Jimmy's gonna do a little investigative journalism and sneak into Wayne Manor, seeking the evidence he needs.
Pre-Flashpoint Jimmy, Pre-Flashpoint Alfred.
Jimmy has 2 weeks prep, Alfred has a few minutes/seconds warning because he hears Jimmy moving around. Jimmy doesn't know Alfred hears him.
Hand to hand + anything they can find lying around the setting. And Jimmy is armed with an Olympus C7070 camera with wide zoom lens, night vision, and "no flash" option with carrying case.
Battle takes place in a long gallery at Wayne Manor. Because Alfred has the jump on Jimmy, he can start this battle from any distance he'd like. He can say "Don't move!" from 20 feet away, or he could grab a fire poker, sneak up on Jimmy, and bean him in the head. Unless Jimmy hears Alfred sneaking around first and flips it on him.
Jimmy doesn't have his signal watch. It's nighttime, so Batman is out on maneuvers. It's just Jimmy and Alfred.
Battlefield removal on. Alfred has morals on. Jimmy's morals are... complicated somewhat to allow him to go after this evidence. Character-induced stupidity on. Plot-induced stupidity off.
Jimmy wins by K.O. or otherwise subduing Alfred, or getting the evidence he needs. If he can run from the battle to find some visual evidence to prove this affair, a letter or something, he wins. Alfred wins by K.O. or otherwise subduing Jimmy, ideally getting Jimmy arrested. But Alfred MUST keep all of Bruce's secrets secret. Jimmy can't discover that he's cheating with Alfred. IF he's cheating with Alfred.